I know, I'm just saying that's another one of the reasons Star Trek Janeway is a silly idea.
Poll They neen to make Star Trek janeway like they did with picard
- Thread starter trekmania2456
- Start date
I prefer my Voyager "Season 32" revival streaming miniseries idea. 
I don't think any person said every captain needs their own show, someone was just showing an interest in a Janeway one.
Sisko... well he went down a fiery hole. In some ways I feel his story was complete. If I had a choice, I'd see more value in a Janeway series. But... the Archer series that's been discussed would be my top trump.
Quite. Not all ideas need to be shut down. We can have fun, we can theorise and do what-ifs.
Trek fans can take things very seriously. And nothing worse than when Trek fans want to be serious and tell other fans they can't have silly ideas.
Agreed 100%.
Yep, 1LT Kim proved promoting Harry would be a bad idea.
I agree with everything you said, except I would watch. It's Star Trek - I'm here until the final starship's orbit decays.
I hear ya.
I look at how they tried to destroy the legacy of my beloved TNG with Picard. Tried to unsew the tapestry of Generations and undermine its message. See the utter tomfoolery of SNW.
Then when an Archer show is floated I think "Yeah... I'd watch that."
Personally, I don’t think we need another send-off or a return to characters from 30 years ago. We already said goodbye to them decades ago—why keep reheating them like old tea?
I’m just not interested in reboots of a bygone era. That’s also why I’m against a TOS reboot disguised as “Year One.” And honestly, I’m worried Star Trek: Janeway could end up tarnishing her legacy—just like Picard almost did his.
I’m just not interested in reboots of a bygone era. That’s also why I’m against a TOS reboot disguised as “Year One.” And honestly, I’m worried Star Trek: Janeway could end up tarnishing her legacy—just like Picard almost did his.
It’s called lack of imagination or originality.
Don’t worry. There will be no Star Trek Janeway.
And as for Star Trek Picard…we find out that 20 years after we last saw him, Jean-Luc has become a cranky old man whose mom killed herself when he was a boy and now he pretends that she lived to be an old lady? What on earth is so tarnished about that?
Dude was already cranky. He didn't become that.And as for Star Trek Picard…we find out that 20 years after we last saw him, Jean-Luc has become a cranky old man whose mom killed herself when he was a boy and now he pretends that she lived to be an old lady? What on earth is so tarnished about that?
He just went from dude with discipline to dude with daddy issues.
PICARD: No. In fact, it's amazing how little it has changed. Everything is exactly as I remember it. The house, the hills, every tree, every bush seems untouched by the passage of time.
MARIE: Robert's worked hard to keep it that way. It's very important to him.
PICARD: As it was to our father.
Seemed to also be there.
Perhaps in the Janeway series she can get another dog.
Also banking on an audience they know will show up in droves. Less risk of a total flop. Even if we despise the series, if it says Star Trek in the title, most of us will watch if only to come here and complain about it.
I dunno. How many times are they gonna reboot Kirk and Spock before even hardcore Trekkies stop giving a shit about them?
Only if it's like the first 2 seasons of Picard and had its own identity. If it's going to be televised slop from the deepest recesses of ao3 like season 3 then no thank you, consider the regression that would befall characters like Kim, even if they gave him captain's pips he would just be stood behind ops with one line about the sensors.
