• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Have you ever given up on a Trek series? If so, what was the last straw for you?

I stopped watching both DS9 and VOY due to more external circumstances rather than choice. (Work schedules, availability…) Still, immediately got the finale of DS9 on VHS at release, and tried downloading the finale for VOY the night it aired. But had to wait instead.

Nem was the first film I didn’t bother with in the cinema, and I really didn’t make any effort to continue Enterprise past its pilot, but again, the opportunity wasn’t there.

The *only* Trek’s I could/can watch and basically don’t because I can’t be arsed are Disco, and to an extent SNW. (And Section 31, but that goes without saying.) I have tried, goodness knows, but DSC lost my interest in season 2, and SNW manages to interest me and not interest me at the same time. As a realisation of that sort of Phase Two style TOS, it’s great, as an adjunct to the great Trek History I so loved in the nineties, it’s… hit and miss.

It’s odd, because whilst I am attached to the TOS films, I am pretty sure there are episodes of TOS I still haven’t seen, so I am not some die hard. In fact I really like the design elements of the new shows, that function better as set up for the Movie Era than they do as representations of that period in Treks fictional ‘History of the Future’. It sort of works.
Everything else doesn’t, particularly the writing. DSC has its 32nd century after the time jump, and I tried, I really did — but I don’t believe in it. Because I don’t believe in the basic characters and writing of the early season, I found it even harder to get behind the sort of ‘second apocalypse’ post dystopia.

PIC would have lost me after the abysmal series 2, but the actual closure on the TNG era offered by season 3 was impossible to ignore, and mostly enjoyable.

So I suppose, it’s really just DSC I actively avoid. Some I am meh on.
 
The only one I gave up on was Enterprise sometime during its second season during the original airing. It just wasn’t doing it for me at the time. I’ve since gone back and seen the whole thing.

In terms of movies, I nearly gave up on Section 31 during the first act, but I guess I was enough of a masochist to keep going.
 
I gave up on ENT after the second season because I felt it was a TOS prequel in name only. My position on that eventually changed 180 and I came back for the fourth season (and now, I wished it had gone on longer).

Although I really liked it, I gave up on PROD after the first season solely because it moved from Paramount+, and I wasn't going to pay for another streaming service.
I was the same with ENT. Took awhile to come back to it and realize it got better.
 
...something something K-Pop...

-------------
I gave up on Enterprise when I realized I was mostly watching just to see if this is the episode where Archer says "Oh, boy!" Sam Beckett style. It otherwise wasn't what I had wanted in a TOS prequel.
 
I gave stopped following the Star Trek franchise in general during my teenage years, though it was more about me being an idiot than anything to do with the Trek franchise. Basically, I was convinced I was a loser because I was a Trek fan and the key to becoming cool was stop being one. Of course, I was so well known on the school yard for being a Trekkie that no one believed me when I said I wasn't one anymore, making the whole think even more idiotic on my part. But I suppose teenage years are when we're supposed to be stupid.

As an adult I did give up on the Trek novels for awhile, right around the time they really got going with the interconnected continuity thing and began referencing things from other novels and even comic books. There was one novel where they made a reference to something I didn't know about at all. at which point I closed the book and said "I'm done. If I don't understand a reference in a Star Trek novel, there's a problem." Ironically, years later when I did get back into the Trek novels and they referenced the other novels from the period where I wasn't reading them, I actually liked the novelty of a Star Trek reference I didn't understand.
 
...something something K-Pop...

-------------
I gave up on Enterprise when I realized I was mostly watching just to see if this is the episode where Archer says "Oh, boy!" Sam Beckett style. It otherwise wasn't what I had wanted in a TOS prequel.

When I first heard ENT was in production, I'd hoped that it was going to be about the first voyages of NCC-1701, back when the interior smelled new, the bank held the title and the clear coat still shined. But...no.

An 'Oh, boy' would have been awesome as a callback to QL. Maybe even an episode where Sam leaps into Bakula...

"Where am I, Al?"
"You're not gonna believe it but you're a starship captain. (bangs device) Oh, you're AN ACTOR named Scott Bakula who plays a starship captain. That explains all the cameras. Sam, you're like William Shatner."
"Oh.... boy"

Dean Stockwell was still acting in 2002, wasn't he?
 
Last edited:
I gave up on Enterprise when I realized I was mostly watching just to see if this is the episode where Archer says "Oh, boy!" Sam Beckett style. It otherwise wasn't what I had wanted in a TOS prequel.
This is a funny story: Back when I was going to the Kubert School (If you don't know what it is, it's an art school for comic books & cartooning), we had an assignment to draw a two-page comics adaptation of a television show. I decided to be cheeky and start out doing a TOS adaptation, and then halfway through the page, I revealed it was really a Quantum Leap adaptation when Sam Beckett leapt into Captain Kirk. At the bottom of the page Sam saw Spock with his pointed ears and said, "Oh, boy." (Al entered on page two to brief Sam.)

Now here's the weird part; I drew this assignment around 1996 or 1997, at least four years before Scott Bakula was cast in Enterprise. It was pretty surprising when I found out that Scott Bakula was actually going to be the lead on a Star Trek series! :lol::lol::lol:

Dean Stockwell was still acting in 2002, wasn't he?
He was. He even guest starred on an episode of Enterprise that year.
 
Enterprise season four was the first Star Trek I dropped. I like the Organian episode (if that was season 4?) but the fanwanky three-parters were just impossible to get through.

Didn't last more than a couple episodes into Lower Decks, don't get the appeal at all. A lot of people who I otherwise agree with on everything Trek-related say it's great, but I thought it was abysmal.

Discovery lost me in the third season but not because of any specific thing, it just felt like it wasn't made for people like me on any level, like virtually everything about it from the plots they chose to explore, to the tone of the writing, to the attitude of the characters was almost the opposite of what appeals to me in fiction.

Never dropped a pre-Enterprise show, though came very close with DS9. If I'd known where it was going I'd have probably stopped in the fourth season.
 
This is a funny story: Back when I was going to the Kubert School (If you don't know what it is, it's an art school for comic books & cartooning), we had an assignment to draw a two-page comics adaptation of a television show. I decided to be cheeky and start out doing a TOS adaptation, and then halfway through the page, I revealed it was really a Quantum Leap adaptation when Sam Beckett leapt into Captain Kirk. At the bottom of the page Sam saw Spock with his pointed ears and said, "Oh, boy." (Al entered on page two to brief Sam.)

Now here's the weird part; I drew this assignment around 1996 or 1997, at least four years before Scott Bakula was cast in Enterprise. It was pretty surprising when I found out that Scott Bakula was actually going to be the lead on a Star Trek series! :lol::lol::lol:


He was. He even guest starred on an episode of Enterprise that year.
Joe Kubert?

Nice
 
I watched the beginning of each season of Picard, but its crapsack version of the Federation was so dull that I can't even remember where I left off in the first 2 seasons. The third season drop off point was the reveal of yet another umpteenth big borg cube. I just skipped to the end to say goodbye at that point.

With Discovery, I started with the storyline after the time jump. I should have surgically cut Discovery off but it was a miserably slow death of just skipping forward here and there to watch Saru before stopping altogether. I later went back and started Season 2 but stopped after about 15 minutes. Never watched season 1.

I've never watched VOY consistently but one episode turned me off of it for a while. I'll give you a hint: salamanders. :wtf:
 
Last edited:
I have definitely given up on some Treks along the way. (TAS, VOY, ENT.) I came back later though and watched them all.

Others I kind of gave up on mentally even though I kept watching just in case they got güd. (DSC, PIC.)
 
Picard. I engaged with all the characters except Picard himself, funnily enough (and Raffi, to a certain extent), and made it all the way through S1, but it was becoming a slog. "Nepenthe" and the death of Hugh (:wah:) was when I mentally gave up on it, although I watched the last three episodes for completeness (interdimensional robot space tentacles?? :rolleyes:). I tried S2 but only got about halfway through (can't remember the episode where I gave up), and just about managed to finish the first episode of S3 before calling it a day. (I have since seen clips & snippets of other S3 eps but they do not instill me with the need to watch any more.)

As for Discovery, giving up on it was helped by the move from Netflix to P+. I liked the new look and style but the bizarre & awkward Klingons, the death of Georgiou, and the Mirror Universe stuff were big turn offs - and I never connected with the main characters except for Lorca, Saru and Tilly (I wanted more of Airiam, Owo, Bryce et al). Pike & crew showing up for S2 kept my interest through all the dreadful Red Angel, Mirror Georgiou and Section 31 malarkey but, as with Picard, I mentally switched off when my favourite character, Airiam, was killed off :wah:. I had high hopes for the move to the 32nd Century but was disappointed because other than the setting, nothing else had changed (which is unsurprising in retrospect), and got through the season in fits and starts. I have not, and probably will not watch seasons 4, 5 and Section 31.

I tried Prodigy but realised pretty quickly that despite the gorgeous artwork and entertaining characters, I'm just not the audience for this child-friendly Star Trek.

Finally, I haven't given up on TOS, but there are many episodes I haven't seen. I've watched a handful over the years - from a few repeats/re-runs when I was a kid, to one or two eps that happened to be on telly as I was flicking through the channels as an adult - but they're a product of their time, one that I find difficult to connect with. I do like reading the episode summaries on Memory Alpha though, and feel like I've watched them all! :D
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top