• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Poll Is Star Trek: Khan khanon?

Should Star Trek: Khan be considered khanon?


  • Total voters
    38
On the original question - I really want Q to appear at least one more time. Break the fourth wall by directly looking into the camera and saying “Everything is Canon!” and a wink. No context or further explanation.

If James Gunn introduces Mxyzptlk as I hope he does. The very same thing.

😈😉
 
I had a polydactyl, and she worked her extra front claws like thumbs. I would find her in the lower kitchen cabinets because she could grip the handle and pull it open, and then it would slam shut behind her.

The polydactyl gene is actually the dominant gene. In time, all cats will have thumbs. And then humanity is doomed. Doomed!
Yeah, I think cats are probably the one animal I would not want to see develop thumbs...
 
If I recall correctly it was a good joke until the point where a character went, "You know, like CATS!" for those of us who didn't get it.
 
I do wonder why later works have always based Caitians on housecats when M'Ress was obviously based on a lion (albeit a male one, oddly, given the mane). But then, Majel Barrett gave her a "purring" voice in one episode, so that may have influenced it.
 
M'Ress was obviously based on a lion (albeit a male one, oddly, given the mane)
Odd, I never got that vibe at all. And not just one appearance; to the best of my recollection, Majel voiced her consistently that way.

I remember a "B-plot" that ADF gave to one of his "Star Trek Log" books, involving all Caitans on board going into heat at the same time, and running amuck.

At any rate, T'Ana's potty-mouth certainly rings true.
 
Odd, I never got that vibe at all. And not just one appearance; to the best of my recollection, Majel voiced her consistently that way.

Tawny fur. Rounded ears. A tail with a tuft at the end. A mane. All leonine attributes.

And no, there was only one episode where M'Ress "purred" her R's.


I remember a "B-plot" that ADF gave to one of his "Star Trek Log" books, involving all Caitans on board going into heat at the same time, and running amuck.

That was from Log Ten, Foster's version of what was happening back on the Enterprise during the events of "The Slaver Weapon." One of the three original plots Foster added to the adaptation, respectively taking place before, during, and after the episode.
 
I was pretty sure it was "Slaver Weapon." Because it had to have been an episode where Spock, and the main action, were at a considerable distance from the ship.
 
Doyle's third Challenger novel was utter garbage. I deliberately ignored it when I wrote my Challenger story for A Cry of Hounds, having it take place after both The Lost World and The Poison Belt, but before The Land of Mist, so I could ignore it. It was, as @Allyn Gibson said, full of spiritualist gobbledygook that is completely antithetical to the rationalist scientist Challenger, who's barely recognizable in the book.

Inspired by this thread, I've just finished reading The Lost World and The Poison Belt for the first time. I thought TLW was a lot of fun and quite well-written, but TPB was much less successful (and it seems like Doyle was already becoming occupied with thoughts about mortality and the afterlife when he wrote it). Now I'm debating whether I'm enough of a completist to read The Land of Mist out of morbid curiosity. There are also the two short stories that were written last, but that Wikipedia's "biography" of Challenger places before TLoM, so I may read them first.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top