• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

DC Movies - To Infinity and Beyond

I really like every live-action Supergirl to date with the partial exception of Vandervoort (I don't dislike her, she just didn't wow me). Holding out very high hopes for Alcock.

I actually liked Vandervoort a good deal (I like Smallville probably more then it deserves, especially in later seasons when it started adding more comic elements). Honestly, its Helen Slater who I find to be the weakest live action Supergirl. I don't think its Slater's fault, but in the Supergirl film she's written like a complete space cadet, just kind of wandering from scene to scene barely aware of whats going on. The Phantom Zone scene and the final fight with the Witch are where the character seems to finally be fully aware and active with the plot, but Supergirl spends too much of that movie as barely a character for me to rate her as anything but the bottom of the list.

I don't hate the film version of the character or anything, and I'm sure Slater could have done a good job in better circumstances, but the character as written is just not good, at least in my opinion.
 
No, but please. I'm just watching the first episode and it is really great! Plus, with a weekly release schedule I can keep up with a thread for a change.

My favourite line so far:

"Is he a nurse?"
"No, but he's got nurse-like qualities."
 
I'm personally waiting until they reveal his name is still Oswald Cobblepot before watching that Penguin show. Seriously, "The Penguin" isn't a goofy nickname, but Cobblepot is too "kiddie" a last name? The people making that show have their heads so far up their own asses they'll soon be complaining about Marvel Movies/Shows :lol:
 
Isn't that how the name always was? It was an insult that Oswald eventually owned.

Hmm, not quite. Looking at his debut story, at first we see Dick laughing at his appearance and Bruce chiding him before conceding that he does look like a penguin at that. Later, when he hooks up with the local gangsters, they ask him what his handle is, and he says, "Oh--ah--I have so many! Why not call me the Penguin? It does fit--hee--hee!"

So he is owning a nickname given him by others, but he seems to welcome it rather than feeling insulted. After all, as originally portrayed, he deliberately cultivates his comical, foppish appearance so that people won't take him seriously, which is the cover for his ruthless criminal intellect.
 
Found it on Wikipedia. This is his "Silver Age" origin:
Born Oswald Chesterfield Cobblepot, the Penguin was bullied as a child for his short stature, weight, way of walking, and beak-like nose. Several stories relate that he was forced, as a child, to always carry an umbrella by his overprotective mother due to his father dying of bronchial pneumonia from refusing to take one while going out in the rain. His parents owned a bird shop, where Cobblepot spent most of his time with the birds, seeing them as his only friends, and lavishing them with attention. His love of birds would eventually lead him to study ornithology in college – only to find out that he knew more about birds than most of his professors did. In some versions, Cobblepot turns to crime after his mother dies and the bird shop, along with all of her birds, is repossessed to pay her debts.
 
This discussion about Penguin's nickname reminds me of something I found a bit odd about the '66 TV series, they seemed to treat the villain's nicknames like those were their real names.
 
This discussion about Penguin's nickname reminds me of something I found a bit odd about the '66 TV series, they seemed to treat the villain's nicknames like those were their real names.
Most of them didn't have "real names" in the comics.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top