• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

Given they have similar hairstyles, and there's really not that much of a time separation in an evolutionary sense between Vulcans and Romulans, here's something I've wondered ...

Are Romulans capable of doing a mind meld? And do they have to experience Pon Farr every 7 years too?
 
Given they have similar hairstyles, and there's really not that much of a time separation in an evolutionary sense between Vulcans and Romulans, here's something I've wondered ...

Are Romulans capable of doing a mind meld? And do they have to experience Pon Farr every 7 years too?

I wonder that too. They can't be that far off
 
Given they have similar hairstyles, and there's really not that much of a time separation in an evolutionary sense between Vulcans and Romulans, here's something I've wondered ...

Are Romulans capable of doing a mind meld? And do they have to experience Pon Farr every 7 years too?

Given that pon farr is a consequence of Vulcan emotional suppression, it stands to reason that Romulans would not experience it.

As for psionics, since Romulans are basically pre-Refirnation Vulcans, it's reasonable to infer that they could do mind melds, if taught. From Star Trek: Enterprise episode "The Forge:"

AREV: Surak tells us it is the heritage of every Vulcan. Even those who don't believe in the practice.
 
Controversial opinion:

Patrick Stewart slowly gaining control over what Picard would and would not do on screen changed the character for the worse.
Twice.
Oh I agree with that, great actors are not automatically great writers or show runners. And I do think it changed Picard for the worse.

There was only one hair salon available in the whole Empire, and the owner was a secret fan of the House of Surak fashions.
Wasn't that what the senate was debating in Nemesis before they were vaporized? Whether they should officially allow a second hair style for the empire?

More the mindset of "We are the People's Republic, all the people must look alike!" than trying to look like the Chinese.
According to a documentary I once saw North Korea actually does have (or did at the time have) a set number of "approved" hair styles.
 
If the Remans are also descended from the ancient Vulcans they carry a telepathic/mental manipulation gene.
No. Remans are native to Remus, the third planet in the Romulan star system. (Romulus is the second)
The Romulans subjugated the Remans after arriving from their pilgrimage from Vulcan.
 
Given they have similar hairstyles, and there's really not that much of a time separation in an evolutionary sense between Vulcans and Romulans, here's something I've wondered ...

Are Romulans capable of doing a mind meld? And do they have to experience Pon Farr every 7 years too?

From an evolutionary point of view, its likely that there just wasn't enough time for them to evolve past that (I mean, 2000 years is virtually nothing on an evolutionary scale)... but its also possible the Romulans are just Vulcans who spent a lot of time in a different region of the planet Vulcan in the past (prior to the separation) that has the right conditions in place which did not instigate Pon Farr (epigenetics at play).

Or they could have been something the Vulcans experimented with prior to the teachings of Surak... so genetic manipulation perhaps? Their version of Augments that didn't develop Pon Farr perhaps?

Alternatively, its possible that Romulus itself affected their biology via epigenetics so they wouldn't develop Pon Farr - 2000 years could certainly be enough time for this to happen, and epigenetic changes can happen in a single generation... plus within the context of Trek, it wouldn't be the first time a planet could affect humanoids very quickly and permanently.

Also, I wonder if the Vulcan Pon Farr might be connected to the Vulcan's self control (and not strictly part of biological evolution).
Since Romulans do not practice meditation or emotional control like Vulcans, its possible they never developed either telepathy or Pon Farr.
And the differences could be passed on via genetic expression perhaps.

Sure, the potential for Romulans to develop both is there, but otherwise, because they don't meditate, those never manifested.
We know that Vulcan brains are rather powerful, so maybe it has more to do with the effects of meditation and/or extreme emotional control and desire for logic and how it changes the biochemicals in the Vulcan body.
 
Last edited:
Where did this come from?

From the fact we know that Romulans are Vulcans who separated from the others about 2000 years ago (from their point of view) and the fact that Remans were the native species in the Romulus star system (who were subjugated by Vulcan separatists as slave labour).

This is pretty much covered in Enterprise which explains in more detail how the teaching of Surak changed the planet and some who rejected Surak teachings... some of which left the planet and became Romulans.
 
Patrick Stewart slowly gaining control over what Picard would and would not do on screen changed the character for the worse.
My understanding is that the actress chosen to play Vash was already Stewart's girlfriend and was chosen for the part at his insistence. Personally I liked her portrayal.
 
My understanding is that the actress chosen to play Vash was already Stewart's girlfriend and was chosen for the part at his insistence. Personally I liked her portrayal.

I never was a fan of la Vache. But by that I mean the character. I have no opinion on the actress.
 
Centuries of radiation exposure and cell mutation could produce the Remans. Dilithium mining isn't exactly the safest job in any quadrant and NEM revealed how toxic and dangerous continuous exposure to dilithium ore is.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top