We could argue whether Disco was a successful show for CBS AA when it was first introduced. But we all should at least admit, that Disco S4 was not successful (at all). It ultimately lead to its cancellation. They could’ve axed SNW or even LD, but they canceled DISCO. Which btw is not my fault, i am just completely fine with them stopping the show.
I think they once claimed that each episode of Disco Season 1 had a budget of approx 8 million $ per episode, making it one of most expensive series ever.
DISCO is not a successful show, just accept it. A direct successor to a failed tv series is way more likely to fail than a follower of a successful one. Just place the Starfleet Academy show into the 23rd or 25th century. Make it an artistically and optically successor of SNW or Picard and the show could actually attract a sizable audience.
A loud minority of fans didn’t get the memo and still believes that:
- the more shows the better
- a successor to Discovery would be a good idea.
You have all right to voice this opinion, but it hasn’t anything to do with the general consensus about the best way moving forward for Trek.