• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Picard News & Reviews from Outside Sources

In my experence these statements are made when no facts can be brought regarding the comment made.

Can you provide facts that he has complete control over everything? Without any input from anyone? Because that’s what a dictator does. And you’ve yet to provide an iota of information.
 
In my experence these statements are made when no facts can be brought regarding the comment made.
Does your experience extend to offering facts to back up your opinions-based-upon-rumors regarding the leadership of the shows?

Because you've offered none. Just uninformed opinions.

And don't try to get by with "everyone knows/agrees" or second-and-third hand attributions. Or citation of bullshit YouTube bloviators.
 
And that shows Kurtzman is a dictator how?
Matalas was the co-showrunner, BTW.

S3 proved Matalas has better overall understanding of Star Trek than Kurtzman, s2 would have been perfect if Matalas was allowed to do what he wanted. My sources regarding Kurtman are industry dirt sheets
 
s2 would have been perfect if Matalas was allowed to do what he wanted.
He did do what he wanted. That is he wanted to do a time travel story set in modern day Earth. Maybe the stuff about Picard's mother wasn't his idea, but that came from Akiva Goldsman, who had veto powers being the show's co-creator. Kurtzman had nothing to do with this at all.
 
Okay, so you've got nothing. Just claims that you know stuff you can't cite or back up.

That pretty much settles this, doesn't it?
For more mainstream, search Google for "Alex Kurtsman hard to work with" There are many accounts. I can't cite industry dirtsheets on the discord server unelss you are a member of that server. It's for industry insiders.
 
S3 proved Matalas has better overall understanding of Star Trek than Kurtzman, s2 would have been perfect if Matalas was allowed to do what he wanted. My sources regarding Kurtman are industry dirt sheets
He's shown he's good at callbacks.
What was the level of Kurtzman involvement in S2?
What were the plans he wasn't allowed to do? You do recall he switched to working on S3 while S2 was being made right? Probably a call Kurtzman made.
So you can link to these "dirt sheets"?
 
S3 proved Matalas has better overall understanding of Star Trek than Kurtzman, s2 would have been perfect if Matalas was allowed to do what he wanted. My sources regarding Kurtman are industry dirt sheets

Matalas has said the Q story and the time travel season plot were his ideas. What exactly was he not able to do that he wanted...that were not caused by COVID issues?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top