• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers "Superman & Lois" Season 3

It’s going to take me awhile to get used to the new actor playing Johnathan. He didn’t quite click with me yet.

It's early yet.

Come to think of it, it's kind of a tradition for main characters to be recast in Superman productions. The Superman radio series went through a couple of prototype Lois actresses before settling on Joan Alexander, and recast both Superman and Jimmy in 1950, as well as having several different actors for Batman and Inspector Henderson. In Adventures of Superman, Noel Neill replaced Phyllis Coates as Lois. In the '88 Superboy, at the start of season 2, Gerard Christopher replaced John Haymes Newton as Superboy, and Sherman Howard replaced Scott Wells as Lex Luthor. (Oddly, they did a whole convoluted story to explain Luthor getting plastic surgery, but just pretended Superboy was unchanged.) Lois and Clark replaced Michael Landes with Justin Whalen as Jimmy Olsen, and recast some recurring characters, like Beverly Garland replacing Phyllis Coates (again) as Lois's mother, and Inspector Henderson being played by Mel Winkler once, Brent Jennings once, and Richard Belzer after that. The DC Animated Universe Superman changed from Tim Daly in Superman: The Animated Series to George Newbern in Justice League. Smallville replaced Terence Stamp as the voice of Jor-El with Julian Sands when he finally appeared onscreen, and also recast Morgan Edge from Rutger Hauer to Patrick Bergin (another plastic surgery handwave). Supergirl also didn't recast any lead characters, but it replaced Laura Benanti with Erica Durance as Alura and Robert Gant with Jason Behr as Zor-El.

Plus S&L recast Sam Lane and Morgan Edge from Supergirl, but those don't really count because they were pre- and post-Crisis and in separate shows, and it turned out to be in a different reality anyway.

Anyway, as Super-recastings go, results have varied. On radio, Michael Fitzmaurice was a vastly inferior Superman to Bud Collyer. I liked both Coates and Neill as Lois, in different ways. Gerard Christopher was somewhat of an improvement over Newton, and Howard was an immense improvement over Wells. Conversely, Whalen was a much worse Jimmy than Landes, and I never warmed to him in three years. Newbern was okay as Superman, but not quite as good as Daly.
 
Superman and Lois
Season 3 - Episode 2 - "Uncontrollable Forces"

SM/Clark / Lois / Dr. Irons:
After undergoing a battery of tests, Lois receives a diagnosis...but does not immediately share the information with her family. The tip-off that something was troubling was her referring to the pregnancy as a "fantasy".

Lois and Clark travel to Metropolis to confront up-and-coming, aggressive Judge Tara Regan about her release of Henry Miller (aka Atom Man); the Judge is smug and evasive, then presents with a tick caused by some strange sound. Lois presses Regan for answers, but the Kents are escorted from the office by two strange, threatening men...

As Clark tracks the men, Lois finds Regan on her rooftop, preparing to jump, noting that the moment she was asked about Henry Miller, she knew it was the day she was going to die. Regan provides an information dump about why she became a judge--that she would make a change, but learned that was not possible...

Lois continues to try to talk Regan down, and in sharing experiences of surviving adversity, she admits she has aggressive, inflammatory breast cancer (SEE NOTES)--with Superman (after leaving Manheim) hearing the entire revelation.

Back in Smallville, Lois breaks down. not wanting Clark to look at her as if she's sick, but Clark promises he will support her (obviously) all the way. She shares the news with her stunned twins, with Jordan taking it harder than his brother.

Irons / Natalie:
Natalie works on a project for the D.O.D., but Sarah entices her to go the party of a cute guy...in Metropolis. Irons--being the concerned father--is not too thrilled about Natalie attending the party, but reluctantly allows her to go...

In the wake of George's murder, Irons informs Lana that Sarah attended the party...which Lana did not approve of. Irons invites Lana in to join him for dinner...(SEE NOTES). Later, Lana discusses George's call, how he wanted to be remembered as "the pride of Smallville"--which is slogan on the town seal in her office. Curious, the two head to the office. Finding a flash drive behind the seal, the second Lana inserts in into her laptop, the duo are subjected to the same loud noise and rumbling which preceded George's death. Onomatopoeia attack the two, steals the flash drive , leaving Irons and Lana gripping their heads in pain.

That evening, as Sarah and Natalie return to Lana's house, Irons sets up a security system (SEE NOTES) for an increasingly grateful Lana.

Manheim / Onomatopoeia / Intergang: Superman tracks Manheim's man (Mr. Orr) back to the man himself. Manheim dodges Superman's questions, instead, accusing him of destroying things he's "built for his community" (SEE NOTES). He adds in Metropolis, he's the hero--not Superman. He recalls Luthor and Edge became billionaires while his community suffered, prompting him to become his people's symbol of hope. He charges Superman with never changing a thing since he's been on earth; SM says he saves lives, but Manheim counters with his failure to save anyone in his city. He warns SM never to set foot into his house again.

Onomatopoeia demands Manheim end his experiments on Henry, as the man he thought he killed--Irons--is alive and well in Smallville...

Lana / Kyle / Sarah: A frantic George Dean calls Lana, saying he made " ...a big mistake..", but a moment before he can explain himself, he's overwhelmed and murdered after an attack by Onomatopoeia.

Lana arrives at the crime scene and wonders how she will brake the news to Sarah, as George jr. and Sarah were so close. Despite the reality of the divorce, Kyle has that longing gleam in his eyes for his ex...

Jordan / Jonathan II: Jonathan convinces Jordan to attend the Metropolis party, in an attempt to move on from Sarah. Little does Jordan know that Sarah is at the party...

Sarah tries to introduce Natalie to guys, finally dragging teen named Matteo to her. Matteo had spotted her before, and wanted to get to know her. The two hit it off, but the party drama pulls her away.

Later, Jordan flies his brother to the party, where Eliza spirits Jonathan away to apologize for breaking up with him, wanting to reconcile. Jonathan pushes back, admitting he has a girlfriend, and did not travel to Metropolis to be with her (SEE NOTES).

Jordan--awkward as ever--fails to mingle, but eventually runs into Sarah. Sarah explains that she did not mean to make Jordan feel as if he has to walk on eggshells around her, adding he's the first boyfriend she also considered a friend. The two end up enjoying themselves, until the host of the party targets the two with slurs. Through it all, Jordan does not use his powers...until he freezes the host's jeep.


NOTES:

So, it turns out Lois has an aggressive form of cancer. One wonders how Sam will process this, and if he will use any alien tech to enhance Lois, believing it would eradicate cancer. Since the teaser shows Lois still on the job despite her illness, audiences should expect her to gradually decline as she places herself in (or is forced into) danger. Lois has plot armor, so I'm not worried she will die. Suffer? Obviously, but she will recover to some degree.

Just as Kyle--still heartbroken over his divorce--looks for any sign of hope, Lana would appear to be warming up to Irons. Enter the soap opera zone. While I was in favor of Kyle and Lana getting back together, the idea of Irons and Lana becoming an item is somewhat intriguing--only if its not another one-and-done arc for the season, or Lana is used to lure Irons into a trap by Manheim & Onomatopoeia.

Okay, here we go: Manheim touches on his poor upbringing and the struggles of his people--and despite all he's done for his community, he's still viewed as a criminal. Sound familiar? It should, as it was astoundingly close to one of the many arguments Tobias Whale made (to Jefferson Pierce) about his own reputation and "service" to the black community. The difference between the villains is that Black Lightning's staff had a deep, personal experience / awareness of the infinite details about suffering in racially impoverished cities and layered their series with those realities in often brutal fashion from the pilot until the series finale. It was never an accent or Very Special Episode, but ingrained in the structure and messages of the series.

Yes, Manheim briefly touched on his past, but so serious ans sensitive a subject demands knowledgeable writers, so i'm very curious about the backgrounds of the writing staff who contributed to the Manheim history side of things, and how their plans develop.

Eliza appeared to be more than bitter after Jonathan's rejection. This sub-plot might end here, but I would not be too surprised if she returns to harass Jonathan at the worst time of his life.

As I still suspect, Manheim will now be drawn to Smallville, where Irons will be a target--only Manheim does not know Irons has a double life. That, and I also believe he will either recruit Luthor, or will be approached by Lex--possibly in the mid-season finale.

GRADE: A.
 
The latter portion of the episode was somewhat…difficult to watch. My wife was diagnosed with breast cancer last summer and the conversation between Lois and Clark, then sitting the children down to explain things hit rather closer to home than TV shows or movies usually do. So far, things have gone well for my wife and her illness, thankfully. Just wasn’t expecting such a callback from an escapist form of entertainment.
 
^ You mentioned your wife's diagnosis uptopic, and though I failed to say anything then (not knowing quite what to say), I'm glad to hear she's doing well so far. And yes, I can definitely see how this storyline could be a painful one when it hits too close to home. Hell, I expect it to be plenty painful for me to watch, even though I (thankfully) don't have the same personal experience.

I think the writers are taking a chance here, tackling a subject like this in the context of a comic-book superhero show. It's guaranteed Lois won't die, and there are countless ways they could techno-magically cure her. But they have to be very careful not to trivialize the subject, or make viewers feel their emotions were unfairly manipulated in the process. It's going to be a tricky thing to handle, and I can only hope they do it justice.

I did think tonight's episode was a good start, however, and was a very strong episode overall, with great moments for almost all the characters, and intriguing and rapid advancement of the season's plot threads. I didn't want the hour to end, and I'm eager to see where things go from here.
 
Ugh, just as I feared. Everything has to be dark and somber and grim and foreboding in this show. This is not what I want from a Superman show. Why the hell do people today want Superman stories to be dark? That's missing the whole point. I mean, yeah, the show gets Clark's optimism and enthusiasm right, but everything around him is so grim and there are all these somber slow-motion scenes with sad music and everything.

And of course when they do a scene with talking someone down from a ledge, they have to quote the line from All-Star Superman. They even named the judge Regan, after the character from the iconic scene. Nice touch having Lois be the one to say it, but the line didn't fit this context as well as the original, so it felt pro forma and artificial. "You're much stronger than you think you are" works far better for a teenager struggling with depression than for a judge being threatened with assassination, a threat that has little to do with her own strength. (I seriously expected those cops who escorted the judge off the roof to be on Mannheim's payroll and to kill her shortly thereafter.)

Not sure how I feel about them working in a racial angle with Mannheim. I mean, having a black gangster claiming to fight for his community be the bad guy facing off against the show's noble white heroes runs the risk of sending the wrong message or being condescending. And I can't believe Mannheim's claim that Superman ignored Hob's Bay, or Superman's silence implying that he couldn't refute it. I mean, the very earliest Superman comics made him a champion of the working classes standing up against the wealthy and powerful. And he was raised on a farm. He wouldn't neglect the little guy.

Mannheim's the first character to name Henry Miller onscreen as Atom Man. But that name doesn't make sense for his non-powered arsonist version here, and Mannheim claimed to be unaware that he'd gained powers.

The teen-party stuff did little for me. Why would Jon even think an environment like that would be any good for an introvert like Jordan? I'm an introvert too, and yeah, I would've liked more opportunities to socialize with girls in high school, but parties were not my speed and they obviously aren't Jordan's. Jon should know his brother better than to think that setting would've been helpful for him.

They're obviously setting up a romance between Lana and John Henry, because of course all your main characters have to be paired off with someone. I guess it's not quite as labored as setting up Kyle and Chrissie, but can't we have a wider range of relationships between adults of opposite sexes than just romantic plots?

Also, they just walked away from the table and did nothing to save the tortellini that John Henry put so much work into. It's a quirk of mine that it drives me crazy to see characters leaving whole plates of food just sitting there uneaten, as they routinely do in TV and movies. I was raised never to let food go to waste, and I'm a bit compulsive about cleaning my plate. And that tortellini did look good, though I don't like mushrooms.

I noticed that Lana was identified as "Lana Lang" on the ex-mayor's phone. Does that mean she's officially gone back to her maiden name now that the divorce is final? Although I wouldn't have thought the ex-mayor would be so diligent about updating his contact entries.
 
The latter portion of the episode was somewhat…difficult to watch. My wife was diagnosed with breast cancer last summer and the conversation between Lois and Clark, then sitting the children down to explain things hit rather closer to home than TV shows or movies usually do. So far, things have gone well for my wife and her illness, thankfully. Just wasn’t expecting such a callback from an escapist form of entertainment.

I'm so sorry about your wife's illness, but if it means anything, I'm happy things are going well for her.

About Lois: Well, I predicted she will be cured by some tech--either D.O.D. or from the Fortress, and thinking about it again, if she should be cured by some fantasy element, it would make the writers seem sort of callous and unthinking, as they must know there's a possibility that some of the viewers (or someone they know) is dealing with cancer, only there will be no magical Kryptonian / D.O.D. cure (or even aid from a super-tech-empowered villain) that pops into existence.
 
Onomatopoeia speaking doesn't work for me. She loses her creepy factor if she doesn't just respond with sound effects.
 
Onomatopoeia speaking doesn't work for me. She loses her creepy factor if she doesn't just respond with sound effects.

She? The character is male in the comics, and their performer is unidentified in the show so far.

Anyway, I see your point, but it seems logical that a person with the power to generate any desired sound could produce the sound of human speech as well. Refusing to do so would have to be an affectation.

Unless Gerald McBoingBoing grew up to become a supervillain...
 
Well she has has a smaller figure and has boobs. She’s a female here. :)
Correct.

After last week's premiere, I read a couple of interviews with the showrunners. In one interview they seemed to be deliberately talking around the character's gender, but in the other, one of them (perhaps inadvertently) referred to her as "she."

Personally, my theory is that she's
Dr. Irons.
 
Correct.

After last week's premiere, I read a couple of interviews with the showrunners. In one interview they seemed to be deliberately talking around the character's gender, but in the other, one of them (perhaps inadvertently) referred to her as "she."

Personally, my theory is that she's
Dr. Irons.

I can see that happening--and it adds a darker wrinkle that she's the one who informed Manheim about Irons still being among the living, which means she must have had it in for the earth 1 version, and will not care if Manheim goes after Irons.
 
The latter portion of the episode was somewhat…difficult to watch. My wife was diagnosed with breast cancer last summer and the conversation between Lois and Clark, then sitting the children down to explain things hit rather closer to home than TV shows or movies usually do. So far, things have gone well for my wife and her illness, thankfully. Just wasn’t expecting such a callback from an escapist form of entertainment.
I'm glad to hear she's doing well and I hope that continues. *HUGS*
 
Superman and Lois
Season 3 - Episode 3 - "In Cold Blood"

SM/Clark / Lois / Dr. Irons:
Clark's having rather destructive nightmares about Lois calling for him (including Lois crushed by the Daily Planet building), yet he--as Superman--fails to save her. Clearly, he--of all people--now feels powerless to help Lois when it matters most.

In the wake of Lois' cancer diagnosis, she shares this news with her friends, all floored by the gravity of her situation. Logically, Sam (SEE NOTES) asks if there's some Kryptonian tech that would help, only to learn Clark's already explored that avenue...with no solutions. He barks at Clark for "allowing" Lois to miss her first chemo treatment to investigate one of Manheim's abandoned locations.

On the day Lois finally shows up for her 1st appointment--with Clark called away to a disaster in Nepal--she texts with Chrissy, and soon leaves to join Chrissy's investigation at one of Manheim's warehouses, where his men are spotted loading trucks. Despite Chrissy's pleas for Lois to prioritize her health, Lois insists on chasing after Manheim.

Forced to hide in a freezer filled with blood packs, Lois tries to signal Superman, but some element in the freezer prevents the signal from reaching him. As the henchmen open the freezer, Lois acts as a distraction long enough for Chrissy to Signal Superman, who rescues the duo--but SM is subsequently attacked by a henchman with Kryptonite energy weapons; he's saved by the timely arrival of Irons, but the henchman--activating a detonator--cryptically promises "You two are next" (SEE NOTES) as he's destroyed in a massive explosion.

SM & Irons escape the factory, with both--each with unique interests in Lois--observe her.

Back at the farm, Clark chastises Lois for her decisions, saying she's not taking her condition seriously. Lois breaks down over the likely consequences of treatment, and how others will treat her during the process, but is interrupted by a call from Sam (from the Manheim warehouse), telling her the packs she found contained Clark's blood....

The teens finally present the watch to a grateful Lois, who is--at last--leaving for the first stage of her cancer treatment.

Jordan / Jonathan II / Natalie: The Teen Brigade (whatever, Marvel) discuss doing something special for Lois; Nat considers giving her mother's watch to Lois with the names of all of her loved ones engraved on the back, but a very irritated Irons first reminds her that this world's Lois is not her mother, then brushes off his daughter, telling her she can do whatever she wants, as its her watch...

Jonathan drives Candace home, only for the couple to be harassed by her drunk father, who pauses as he learns Jonathan's new truck was a gift....

When Jonathan's truck is stolen (along with Natalie's watch), he mentions the interest Candace's father took in the truck, pissing off the girl, who marches off, accusing Jonathan of thinking her father's a suspect because he's poor...

The Teen Brigade learn Jonathan's truck was taken to a chop shop and work together to retrieve the truck--but the watch was missing. Well, that is until Candace walks to the farm to return it, as it had been stolen by her father's crew. While Candace feels guilt over what she's put Johnathan through, he comes clean about running into his ex-girlfriend.

Irons apologizes for his reaction to Natalie's watch idea, admitting his frustration stems from a concern for a friend rather than believing Natalie was trying to see Lois as a surrogate for her late mother.

Lana / Kyle / Sarah: Lana and Irons continue to bond, and note that he sort of cuts off her assumption that he would be especially bothered by Lois' situation by reminding her that Lois is not his wife. Later, Kyle is a bit incensed to learn (from Sarah) that Irons installed a new security system at Lana's....

Lana has to admonish Kyle for prying into her business--namely all things Irons, accusing her ex husband of suffering from a fragile ego. Kyle is both hurt and angered by Lana's tone...

Later, Sarah becomes mouthy to Lana when she's instructed to be discreet about what she shares with her father (Irons). Sarah accuses Lana of being bossy and suggests that's the reason Kyle cheated on her, prompting Lana to slap Sarah....

Lana tries to apologize, expressing her love for her daughter, but is met with silence--and an empty bedroom.

At the diner, Chrissy runs into Kyle, blabbing about Lois' personal matters. Kyle recalls how his father died from liver cancer...and was stubborn until the end. Chrissy wants to spend time with Kyle, which he's open to--until Sarah walks in, breaking down in her father's arms, leaving Chrissy feeling lonelier than ever...

NOTES:

Understandably, Lois would not wish to slow down or feel as if she's simply a "victim" of the disease, but would reaffirm her professional "call to action" by running headlong into a kind of danger she's underestimating; I expected Clark to suggest she takes a step back, and his frustration with her purposely ignoring her health crisis was realistic.

Meanwhile, on Days of Our Lives, Kyle is pissed that Lana is defensive over her personal life, and now that she's slapped Sarah--who takes comfort with her father--one can see Kyle and Sarah erecting walls of ice against Lana. Feeling as if she has nowhere to turn, Lana might turn to Irons, but I have a feeling that in the grand scheme of things, they will not become a couple (not for long, anyway). No matter how the Lana / Kyle saga ends up, I maintain my hope that Kyle--in his angry state-- is not turned into some sort of patsy for an observant user (think about it), or crosses a darker line with Irons.

Manheim's suicidal thug promised SM & Irons that they were "next"; now that its known Manheim has been experimenting with a supply of SM's blood--and is looking for another Guinea Pig, I'm suspecting said Guinea Pig might be someone close to Superman.

Sam learning there's no alien tech that can help Lois pours water on the theory that she will just get by / receive a miracle cure--she will take the same journey as everyone else in the world, which was the right choice from the writers, as no one one watching would ever relate to (or support) insta-cures from magical Kryptonian technology.

GRADE: A.
 
I had my concerns about the cancer storyline, and I guess I still do -- it just seems fraught with opportunities for mishandling, and I feel like it's a week-to-week proposition as to how well they manage to deal with this very sensitive narrative. But if this episode is any indication, things are on the best possible track. It was emotional and involving, and felt real and true to character. Far from Lois's condition sidelining or weakening her, I'm not sure she's ever felt more Lois Lane than in this episode -- it's a series high for a version of the character the writers and Tulloch have already made an all-time best. For me, these last couple of weeks feel like the show is revitalized, the strongest it's been since season one.
 
This was a fairly good one. It did feel pretty sensitive about what Lois is going through. I'm relieved that image from the trailer of Lois getting crushed under the Daily Planet globe was just a dream sequence -- a recurring dream, so they could get their money's worth out of that very elaborate CGI sequence. I could've done without the reminder of Man of Steel's disaster porn, but while that was completely gratuitous and could've mostly been cut out of the movie with zero impact on the plot, this was symbolic of Clark feeling his world collapsing around him, so it actually served a purpose.

I wasn't so fond of the plot between Lana and Sarah, which felt like the kind of storytelling where characters are forced to act dysfunctionally to create artificial conflict, rather than something more natural like Lois's fears.

So are we supposed to believe that transfusions of Superman's blood give superpowers now? Come to think of it, I think they did a story like that in the early years of the '40s radio series, where Superman donated his blood to heal someone who couldn't be healed any other way. (I remember Superman having to insert the needle himself so it would penetrate his superstrong skin, but it didn't address why the needle didn't break.) But it just had a healing effect and didn't induce superpowers, at least not as far as I recall.
 
My favorite line from the episode was Chrissy's: "Are you trying to get Superman mad at me?"


Question is, how did they get some much blood from him? Is it cloned blood? Can you clone blood cells?

You can clone any kind of cells, in principle, though I think what you'd want is to clone the stem cells that produce blood cells. As for how they got Superman's, it was probably at some point that he was badly hurt by a supervillain or weakened by kryptonite or something.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top