• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Andor season one

You must be confusing it with the regular useless outpost. This one had tons of money lying in it, enough to fund the rebelion. 80 million is not a small sum, specially when they took only small portion of the vault. Only 40 personal for such an important supply outpost? Clearly Empire is just beeing set up for failure by the writers. Cause it just makes no sense.
The Empire likely expected the locals to be cowed by the reputation of Imperial Might into thinking they couldn't successfully steal from them. As it is, Vel's group had to take advantage of a very specific set of circumstances, and there were those in the group who still had doubts they could succeed even then.
 
When it comes to money what exactly is 80 million of a type a currency I don't even know they use, actually worth. They clearly are not using American dollars or any earth currency so exactly what kind of money do they have?

Imperial credits with an artificially created value, most likely. The successor to the Republic credit that some star systems(including Tatooine in the Outer Rim) wouldn't accept as legal tender in the Prequel Era.
 
One cam cross-reference the first season of Rebels to see what another part of the Rebellion was doing during this same year. Freeing Wookiee slaves, destroying illegal weapons the Empire were still using. thieft of Imperial supplies. Delivering food to the neglected. Blowing up Imperial weapons shipments. Stealing a TIE Fighter. Impersonating Imperial troopers and students. And destruction of Imperial property, up to and including Star Destroyers.
 
Look at the Imperial bunker complex on Endor. Two doors to breach and then you're inside. The Rebels do need a stolen Imperial shuttle to land there but once in the forests they don't have all that much trouble getting near the Imperial facilities and then trying to attack them.
 
The Empire seems to rule using brute force, ruthlessness and bureaucracy. This somehow gives the illusion of competency and efficiency.
 
The Empire is extremely overconfident. They (well the Republic) won the war against the Separatists, and those have all been crushed. The Jedi are "gone". There aren't any "real" threats to the Empire. So they are very laxed in everything, because who would challenge them? The Rebellion won't be a real threat for several more years, but from now until the Battle of Scariff, they will become a serious irritation. Grand Admiral Thrawn will take them seriously in about three years. Darth Vader will be after the remaining Jedi, but that will be what he's concerned with. Grand Moff Tarkin finds them an annoyance, but he doesn't take them all that seriously. Other Moffs, Generals, and Admirals will have a scale of interest in the rebels.
 
I would write it down as the Empire being overconfident but also it's a tv show so sometimes that requires some suspension of disbelief.
 
. They also should have had at least few Cruisers up in Orbit monitoring the trafic. It just makes no sense, why such important outpost was not defended at all.

I thought they were clear on the how and why of it all? It's in the middle of nowhere with only unarmed indigenous locals. As far as they knew, there wasn't a single blaster available to use against them.

And a frontal attack would not work, they were ready for that. They didn't think a group would just waltz on in.
 
But in Star Wars they spread through out the galaxy, limiting threat assestment to just locals, doesn't fits with the concept of space tavel. They also should have had at least few Cruisers up in Orbit monitoring the trafic. It just makes no sense, why such important outpost was not defended at all.
Just makes me sad that they potray Empire as such weak and incompetent power.
But it's not an important outpost, it's in the middle of nowhere far removed from civilization and the only presence for lightyears being the primitive locals who are expected to cower before Imperial Might and indeed, most do exactly that. Star Destroyers and cruisers are likely sent to more important places, places where the local population are probably a bit more advanced and need an extra show of force to be intimidated, and places the rest of the galaxy know about where this show of force will be noticed.

The Empire and how it defends itself is more about spectacle than anything else. Up until now, that spectacle had for the most part been working to keep the rest of the galaxy in line.
 
Last edited:
Another quirk of this kind of massive inefficient bureaucracy that was briefly touched on earlier in the show is that some facilities (namely the shipyards in that instance) would never admit to a theft if one even occurred for fear of exactly the kind of Imperial crackdown and takeover Preox-Morlana suffered because of Ferrix. Those few still operating under Imperial contract rather than being fully nationalised would rather eat the cost of a robbery than admit one ever took place.
How is this relevant to Aldhani given that it's a military installation? Simple: security arrangements are usually determined by assessments based on precedent. If there's a systemic unwillingness to admit failure and thus communicate inherent weaknesses to the wider organisation, then operational security will be habitually overestimated, while external threats will be habitually underestimated. The result is cluelessly lax security...until something that can't be ignored gets nicked then everyone runs around like headless chickens, which is what we're seeing now.

As for the money; let's keep things in perspective. 80 million may sound a lot, but it's not enough to fully finance the wider rebellion. It's a massive boost to be sure, but it will only go so far.
Yeah, you can buy a ship for around 10-20k. But in Star Wars "buying a ship" is like buying a car. The rebellion doesn't just need any old ships, it need military grade ships. Fighters. Frigates. Fleet tenders. Corvettes. You can bet those go for a LOT more than just 10-20k on the black market. Like if a second-hand civvy R-22 goes for anything less than half a million a-piece, I'd be very surprised. And that's before they could even get into building their own X-Wings & B-Wings. One can only get so far stealing from breakers yards after all.

They also need weapons. That means everything from proton bombs, to heavy blaster cannons, to small-arms. On top of that you have consumables like food, ammo, all environment combat clothing, battlefield comm-gear, replacement parts, tools, droids, bacta, and a million other logistical needs. And all of that would just be for just a relatively small group about the size of the Phoenix cell.

All of that is just to supply a fighting force; What about the intelligence network? They need money for much more specialized covert equipment. Concealed weapons. Forged documents. Surveillance gear. Underworld slicers. And probably most expensive of all: bribes. You think a frustrated mid-level Imperial bureaucrat is going to hand over classified intel, or look the other way on suspicious shipment manifests for anything less than five figures? Multiply that across the whole theatre of operation and suddenly that 80 million looks like it would struggle to even get Base One up and running for more than 6 months.
 
Last edited:
312887866-10160598726084954-8564789834655856883-n.jpg
 
Here's a video explaining just how much they can get with that $80 million.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

And a just posted follow-up.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Another quirk of this kind of massive inefficient bureaucracy that was briefly touched on earlier in the show is that some facilities (namely the shipyards in that instance) would never admit to a theft if one even occurred for fear of exactly the kind of Imperial crackdown and takeover Preox-Morlana suffered because of Ferrix.

Well, the shipyards (and other facilities) did indeed admit to thefts, which is how and why Dedra Meero learned about the starpath Cassian stole and all of the other incidents of theft and missing property that formed the backbone of her investigation and theorizing about rebel activity.

So, not every Imperial is just sweeping things under the rug and covering their own asses.
 
"Ten thousand? We could almost buy our own ship for that!"

It seems strange to say it, but you have to remember the purchasing power of a dollar in 1977. a brand new Corvette stingray was about $8000 US. I doubt today's writers equate the value of an Imperial credit with what they imagined in was in '77. Although no direct comparison between real and imaginary currency is given anywhere, the lack of it probably makes people mentally assign a 1:1 value, dollars/pounds/euros to Imperial Credits.
 
Here's a video explaining just how much they can get with that $80 million.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

And a just posted follow-up.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Well it helps when the Rebellions frontline fighter was built by a company that apparently made tis parts interchangeable with civilian spacecraft.
 
Re: Aldani

The vault is out of the way, far away from whatever major population center is on Aldani where there's a actual air wing and stormtroopers. Stormtroopers. The Aldani garrison is smaller than the Alkenzi one, and I bet Alkenzi has possibly a hundred or so more just to maintain the handful of TIEs and look over the most major concentration of the Aldani population. Tamayrn and Gorn are betting on the Aldani garrison not knowing everyone at the Alkenzi one. That works if there's a lotttt more troopers over there plus a lack of travel and comms between the two on the regular.

The rebel cell on it was intentionally out in the woods, the Eye of Aldani ritual site is far away from the Aldani population center - the Imperials put up many comfort stations and inns on the way so maybe its like three days away or something like, 100 miles - would you really put most of your troops in a vault in the middle of nowhere, or where the people are?

Since the locals are prims who couldn't even dream of the tech of the Empire, and in the middle of nowhere, ironically that is a good place to put a vault for payroll as anywhere else in some circles. Security via obfuscation. The Ties and whatever brought the Imperials to the world would be enough to both protect it from, say, maybe Pirates or anything they could expect or at least long enough to get a call out to some regional dispatch command.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top