• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Why is the "feel" of the show so different compared to TNG/DS9/VOY?

Of Brent Spiner in bad make-up killing himself because reasons?

I think PIC's anti-ageing VFX (plus lighting/make up) is pretty hit 'n miss, like they were learning as they went along - it looked good enough with Data's death and chess game, rather iffy when Data was painting his daughter (with a hobbyiest doing better with deep fakes), and near miraculously flawless with Q introduced as looking like he was in his late 30s/early 40s (likely deep fake too).
 
Having 20 years to come up with your own stories and also having 20 years of books where Picard & Co. are still on the Enterprise aren't doing the writers any favors. There's almost nothing they could have done except reuniting the whole TNG cast for a starship adventure that could have pleased everybody. But it looks like we're finally getting there to wrap the show up.

I always hear that Trek is supposed to be optimistic and utopian, but every series has had some kind of big battle or an all out war and there are conflicts every week. If every series was just a character checking their email and then discussing it in a lounge, not many people would watch.
 
LG0XQav.jpg
 
It’s not either/or. The utopian flavor is there but just barely. There’s way more war and conflict than any of the wonders of utopia explored. That’s a failing. As is the idea that utopia is dull. What kind of utopia is that?
 
I think PIC's anti-ageing VFX (plus lighting/make up) is pretty hit 'n miss, like they were learning as they went along - it looked good enough with Data's death and chess game, rather iffy when Data was painting his daughter (with a hobbyiest doing better with deep fakes), and near miraculously flawless with Q introduced as looking like he was in his late 30s/early 40s (likely deep fake too).
To be fair, de-aged Q was standing still for thirty seconds or so, which likely simplified the process a great deal.
 
Don’t we all? :nyah:
Maybe? Some remain fixated, stuck in a place rather than continuing on.

Utopia is not something I've found enjoyable in fiction. I've read, studied, and explored a lot of stories, and genres. The main takeaway is that utopia means different things to different people and few of those appeal to me from an entertainment idea.
 
Maybe? Some remain fixated, stuck in a place rather than continuing on.

Utopia is not something I've found enjoyable in fiction. I've read, studied, and explored a lot of stories, and genres. The main takeaway is that utopia means different things to different people and few of those appeal to me from an entertainment idea.
All the more reason as an artist to try something new and more appealing to a broader audience. Utopia is by definition appealing — it’s only in its presentation that is becomes not so.

But, hey, whatever floats your boat. The weekly Trek Zoom meeting is in about 40 minutes — link will be posted in General Discussion at that time. Why don’t you (and/or anyone) join a handful of diverse fellow Trek/sci-fi fans then, and we can discuss this and/or lots of completely different things?
 
All the more reason as an artist to try something new and more appealing to a broader audience. Utopia is by definition appealing — it’s only in its presentation that is becomes not so.

But, hey, whatever floats your boat. The weekly Trek Zoom meeting is in about 40 minutes — link will be posted in General Discussion at that time. Why don’t you (and/or anyone) join a handful of diverse fellow Trek/sci-fi fans then, and we can discuss this and/or lots of completely different things?
I appreciate the invitation; sincerely. Unfortunately, my living situation is not conducive to Zoom meetings at the moment.
 
The invitation is always open. To all. Nothing is ever recorded and you don’t even need to be on camera if that’s problematic. Meeting also last hours and people come and go all the time, no need to stay for the duration. Usually we discuss the new Trek that week and/or homework episodes we choose, but there’s no pressure to watch any of that either. And the discussions go all over the place (thematically) among our diverse international group.
 
The invitation is always open. To all. Nothing is ever recorded and you don’t even need to be on camera if that’s problematic. Meeting also last hours and people come and go all the time, no need to stay for the duration. Usually we discuss the new Trek that week and/or homework episodes we choose, but there’s no pressure to watch any of that either. And the discussions go all over the place (thematically) among our diverse international group.
Camera isn't problematic. It's the kids loudness. :rofl:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top