• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 2x07 - "Monsters"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    218
Never even heard of him until today.

Not gonna check him out, neither. My tolerance for YouTube and social media Trek cheerleaders or gadflies is pretty minimal. Basically I watch a couple of people for my Trek content and disagree with both frequently.
The days of Trek podcasts are long behind me. Limited interactivity, often times disagree with them, and don't find it very enjoyable. My opinions don't move frequently.
 
When I agree with one of the people I watch I usually couldn't agree more strongly. When I don't it's night and day and bridging the difference isn't likely. But they entertain me so I stick around.
 
Star Trek AoD is not a random nitpicker and not a troll.

That’s correct. What he actually is is some asshole on the internet who, instead of bitching about Star Trek on a Star Trek internet bulletin board like the rest of us assholes do, bitches to Matalas’s Twitter account directly. Now, one could say that if Matalas didn’t want people bitching to him on his own personal Twitter account, he shouldn’t have made the Twitter account in the first place. But that’s like saying that if I didn’t want to go to work and make money, I shouldn’t have bought a car to get me to said workplace.
 
I can't really see this at all. It doesn't have anything like the same fit or fabrics.
I watched that Trekyards video today too. I was mistaken. It's almost like a VOY variant that could have been the precursor to the FC uniform. I do like it. Except for the black striping in the V neck line.
 
I do what I've always done: Watch Star Trek and make up my own mind.

I watch some YouTubers talk about Star Trek or react to it, but it's really just comparing their take to my take. 99.999% of the time, I don't use someone else's stance to back up mine.

And unlike certain other people, I don't do the lazy thing and just coast off what someone else said and think that alone will do the work for me.
 
...And his surname is Singh, and particularly during TOS: "Space Seed" Montalban was made up to look decidedly south Asian. Which is, from a modern perspective, just a tiny bit cringe.
The kid who played Alexander in TNG was also darkened with makeup.

I think its Ducane. And Ducane is very much a Q.

Yeah I got the sense that faux-Ducane is more than he appears to be. It's like he timed his entrance to the bottle opening.
The trailer for the next episode has a flashback to the character as a kid running into Vulcans in a forest.
 
I don't think James Callis looks like Alexander Siddig at all. It also seem strange saying someone else looks like Alxander Siddig, considering Alexander Siddig himself looks exactly like his uncle with a tan.

When I first started Battlestar Galactica, I thought Baltar was played by Siddig. But, after watching both shows, I can tell the difference between Siddig and Callis. I just take it as another example of the SNL sketch "Dylan McDermot or Dermot Mulroney?". They look similar and are easily confused at first glance.

Other examples:

Tobey Maguire/Jake Gyllenhaal
Jai Courtney/Sam Worthington
Hilary Swank/Jolene Blalock
 
Farewell, Star Trek.


NegativeShallowAnemonecrab-max-1mb.gif
 
Star Trek AoD is...
Certainly, irrelevant.

The show provides the story, the rest is all up to the person watching. The opinions of random Youtubers are seldom more than sources for confirmation bias and imagined support for fragile egos needing validation for their own opinions.

Picard's managed to be enjoyable enough to spend time on each week. While not much more than that, it's better than spending time on the maundering nonsense spouted by Youtube critics.
 
I get that you're talking about those haters, not the people with valid reasons to be disappointed with Picard. But I just watched TOS, TNG, Voyager and Enterprise seasons 1-3 simultaneously, for the very first time in some cases. I watched all the season 4s alongside season 4 of Discovery. I know what they're like when directly compared, without any 'franchise fatigue' or concern about how they'll destroy canon, and I can tell you that people had plenty of valid reasons to dislike TNG and Enterprise when they first aired. Those first seasons were terrible then and they're still terrible now, to me anyway. The series improved a lot afterwards, and I think that's what really won people over. Season 3-6 TNG is the 'holy grail of Trek', season 3 of Enterprise is 'serialisation done right'. If Picard is remembered fondly years from now, it'll be because it recovered from this slump.

Personally I like Picard season 2, I think I like it more than most in fact. But I can't defend the storytelling because they've really dropped the ball on it after episode 3, and everyone can see it. We've all been left hoping that there's some kind of payoff at the end that explains what the point of it all was, because it keeps kicking that can down the road while the characters continually deal with complications.
I often don't go back and rewatch shows for a loooong time. Mainly because I have plenty of other things to do. It'll often be at least 10 years before I get back to rewatch something.

However, I did rewatch some of Discovery's 2nd season recently. Mainly because of the excitement for SNW. And, man, I was absolutely blown away. What a fantastic season. And the final 2-parter, I'd give a 10, which I very rarely give.

It also showed me how much Discovery has lost since its 2nd season and Picard feels flat. I knew that I liked the 2nd season when I watched it back then, but it was an eye-opening contrast.
 
Guinan's cat pose is back, at least. :lol:
For one second, then sputters into nothingness. It doesn't do anything and is completely pointless :shrug:
I was really hoping to learn more about her being an imp and them social distance clawing at each other, but that is probably all we're getting.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top