• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 2x07 - "Monsters"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    218
It's a time travel story, there's no reason why Doctor Bashir can't be Picard's dad!

Except that if it was him, they would've just hired Alexander Siddig for the role.
 
One of the things I've been looking forward to this season is seeing interaction between Q and Guinan and finally finding out what the Hell that was all about between them in "Q Who?"

We got some hints by them saying there was a conflict between the Q and the El-Aurians, but I want to see another face-to-face between Q and Guinan. It seemed pretty personal between them. To the point where Guinan said that unlike DeLancie's Q, other Q are actually respectable. So there's something there. And it's not just the conflict Q and El-Auirians in general.
She mentioned that "they are not gods" so I wonder did he show up trying to do a Dravot/Kurtz on the El Aurians.
 
A couple of reflections on the “there is more” part…

1) we still don’t know what shattered the glass in the conservatory. I found it quite interesting that it was not shattered in the confederation timeline, also.
2) we know from “when no one has gone before” that Picard’s mother lived to very old age. Given that they hired an actor that resembles the one of that episode I don’t think the writers forgot about this.
 
I've seen Terry Matalas answering someone's question about this with "because Dr. Bashir isn't Picard's father". His tweet sounded a little exasperated, and I honestly can't blame him. It's one thing when people get confused at first, but a LOT of hate-watchers are deliberately refusing to understand what's going on and are insisting on their "alternative Trek facts" because they fit into their narrative of "this show is ruining Star Trek".

I loved this show until the previous episode and I thought it was Bashir through most of this ep, because every time you turn around it’s a legacy character or actor showing up. Dude shouldn’t get exasperated if you cast a medical character in a starfleet suit who looks just like Siddig in a show rife with fanwankery.
 
Plus his FC / DS9 uniform was pretty spot on.

I can't really see this at all. It doesn't have anything like the same fit or fabrics.

The tops of the First Contact style uniforms had quilted grey gabardine material with vertical stitches and batting to bulk them up. All that is is completely absent here.

It was kind of like a Voyager/early DS9 type uniform (poorly tailored!) with First Contact-esque colors?

ETA: I guess I can't post pictures, but that uniform was really a bizarre look, to me. Close enough to make you wonder if they were aiming for something and just missed, but different enough to make you think they might have been proposing a yet-unseen new design.

hFUNrE3

Tq5Z9OM
 
It's not the same.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I loved this show until the previous episode and I thought it was Bashir through most of this ep, because every time you turn around it’s a legacy character or actor showing up. Dude shouldn’t get exasperated if you cast a medical character in a starfleet suit who looks just like Siddig in a show rife with fanwankery.
You should've known better. Bashir is a DS9 character. This show only has TNG and VOY characters. ;)

I can see how you'd get confused, especially if you hadn't seen the 2000s Battlestar Galactica.

EDITED TO ADD: Before someone says, "But we saw alternate Martok's and Dukat's skulls!", if they're not in the flesh (literally!), it doesn't count. :p
 
Wait, it wasn’t an exact Bashir suit, so we should have known that the guy who looks and sounds a LOT like Siddig 30 years later couldn’t be he?

They kinda mess with uniforms a bit in this CBS era, y’know.

I get that it wasn’t Bashir now, and Bashir wasn’t a psychiatrist. But then 7 wasn’t a vigilante in VOY either. It was confusing to me. All I’m saying.
 
Wait, it wasn’t an exact Bashir suit, so we should have known that the guy who looks and sounds a LOT like Siddig 30 years later couldn’t be he?

They kinda mess with uniforms a bit in this CBS era, y’know.

I get that it wasn’t Bashir now, and Bashir wasn’t a psychiatrist. But then 7 wasn’t a vigilante in VOY either. It was confusing to me. All I’m saying.
Not where I was going with that. I was going more in the direction of "DS9 gets snubbed compared to its two sister series, and it's not going to stop now!", but I know what you're saying. It's all good.

TNG is Marcia ("Marcia! Marcia! Marcia!"), DS9 is Jan, and VOY is Cindy.
 
Wait, it wasn’t an exact Bashir suit, so we should have known that the guy who looks and sounds a LOT like Siddig 30 years later couldn’t be he?

They kinda mess with uniforms a bit in this CBS era, y’know.

I get that it wasn’t Bashir now, and Bashir wasn’t a psychiatrist. But then 7 wasn’t a vigilante in VOY either. It was confusing to me. All I’m saying.
They looked more alike when they were younger. Jawlines are a dead give away.
 
Not where I was going with that. I was going more in the direction of "DS9 gets snubbed compared to its two sister series, and it's not going to stop now!", but I know what you're saying. It's all good.
No I got you. It was someone above saying — I think — it was a differnt uni, so we should have known it wasn’t Bashir. But I’m not sure I understood that aright. Be well!
 
They looked more alike when they were younger. Jawlines are a dead give away.
(Double post, so shoot me.) If you have side by side pics sure, but just watching an ep with wine and cheese in 2022? Sure looked and sounded like a dude 30 years later. Eh, it’s all good.
 
(Double post, so shoot me.) If you have side by side pics sure, but just watching an ep with wine and cheese in 2022? Sure looked and sounded like a dude 30 years later. Eh, it’s all good.
Less wine. More cheese.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top