• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Russell T. Davies Returns to Doctor Who as New Showrunner

I mean, that is actually fair, but it also means that the opinion that one should share is one of a pliable fan who doesn't mind this era. I'm not such a fan. Moreover, as a place I like coming to frequently to talk about DW, I would prefer, let's say, if I was invested and positive about an upcoming episode instead of counting the days for it to leave the airwaves already.

Also, I was not asking for pity. These kind of comments are usually hyperbolic, and I had the impression that most of you understand that I mean them in the stingiest of means (like, basically, I just wish the RTD2 era was here already). Ah, well.

Not asking for pity, just insulting people who like something you don't. Not to worry, no pity here.
 
Perhaps I misread your comment. Are all people who enjoy the current era to any degree "pliable fans"? Pliable meaning impressionable, easily influenced, controlled by others?
 
As to Tate, back when BBC America was more Anglocentric they used to air The Catherine Tate Show, quite possibly at the same time they were showing Doctor Who, so being on the same channel there's at least a decent chance someone might be familiar with both.
 
Eddie Redmayne has been practically auditioning for the role with his turn in the Fantastic Beasts movies.

I don't think it's that so much as David Yates is making the Doctor Who movie he wanted to make. Naturally, if you're making a Doctor Who movie, but calling it Fantastic Beasts, you need a Doctor-not-Doctor character.

One actor that I think was auditioning with a role for Doctor Who was Santiago Cabrera with CBS's asteroid drama, Salvation. The final episode, especially, he had a very Doctor-ish take on his Elon-Musk-tech-bro-turned-United-States-president lead character. And Star Trek: Picard has wrapped on its final season, so he's available...
 
I don't think it's that so much as David Yates is making the Doctor Who movie he wanted to make. Naturally, if you're making a Doctor Who movie, but calling it Fantastic Beasts, you need a Doctor-not-Doctor character.

One actor that I think was auditioning with a role for Doctor Who was Santiago Cabrera with CBS's asteroid drama, Salvation. The final episode, especially, he had a very Doctor-ish take on his Elon-Musk-tech-bro-turned-United-States-president lead character. And Star Trek: Picard has wrapped on its final season, so he's available...

Well now there's someone who never occurred to me as the Doctor but now you've pointed him out, crikey he'd be awesome! He's great as Rios and I loved him as Aramis. There'd be a definite devil may care Third Doctor vibe to him, he can do serious and silly, has great screen presence and would have global appeal. Plus even as a straight guy I can see he's easy on the eye!

That said I was kinda hoping for a Rios/Stargazer series!
 
Well now there's someone who never occurred to me as the Doctor but now you've pointed him out, crikey he'd be awesome! He's great as Rios and I loved him as Aramis. There'd be a definite devil may care Third Doctor vibe to him, he can do serious and silly, has great screen presence and would have global appeal. Plus even as a straight guy I can see he's easy on the eye!

That said I was kinda hoping for a Rios/Stargazer series!

This is a great suggestion. I never thought of him either. And while I watched Salvation, I kinda forgot he was that guy. LOL
 
Well now there's someone who never occurred to me as the Doctor but now you've pointed him out, crikey he'd be awesome! He's great as Rios and I loved him as Aramis. There'd be a definite devil may care Third Doctor vibe to him, he can do serious and silly, has great screen presence and would have global appeal. Plus even as a straight guy I can see he's easy on the eye!

That said I was kinda hoping for a Rios/Stargazer series!

Yeah, like a lot of people, I hope they just roll forward from Picard with a Stargazer series, assuming Picard ends in such a way that Rios and the 'Gazer are still boldly going.

But if CBS doesn't, for whatever reason... :)

This is a great suggestion. I never thought of him either. And while I watched Salvation, I kinda forgot he was that guy. LOL

Salvation was such an awful, relentlessly stupid show that I couldn't stop watching. (No offense if you loved it, or even just liked it!) But it was watchable for the cast, almost all of whom were pretty people, some of whom seemed to realize how silly it all was, and, like I said, Cabrera seemed to treat it like his Doctor Who audition tape, sometimes playing Darius Tanz more Pertwee, sometimes (especially the final episode, where he's just come out of a three month coma and he's out of his mind) more Smith.

So, yeah, Cabrera for the Doctor, and reunite him with Jennifer Finnigan as his companion/partner-in-crime. :)
 
No one is arguing that its possible to find info about people over the internet, especially people who make TV shows. But that doesn't mean you'd be bothered to do it, and I'm sorry but Catherine Tate is a fairly obscure British comedian to people outside of the UK. That is not a knock on her abilities, I've never seen her comedy and don't plan to, but its the reality of the situation. Her biggest mainstream US "break" was probably the guest role on the US version of The Office. Mention her name to 100 Americans and 99 won't know her, and most of the time the remaining will only know her from Doctor Who or The Office, not her British comedy stuff.

To be fair, being on The Office at all would probably make her recognizable to more people in the US (who don't watch Doctor Who) then basically any other NuWho companion, but that isn't saying much. Which, again, is not a knock against her as a person/comedian/actor, its just how things are.
People who watch Doctor Who would have a fair idea. Folks who watch British TV in the US would have a fair chance to know. The US is not the world however much their delusion imagines themselves so.
 
Well... looks like it's not Lydia West.

https://deadline.com/2022/04/its-a-...ia-clarkson-espionage-series-gray-1234996243/

That's a shame.

On the positive side that puts Kris Marshall back in the running.
ZBDvOFPmQgNwxFXLpuoD.gif
 
Last edited:
I tend to flip flop with regard to Lydia in the role. She was awesome in It's a Sin, great in Dracula and Years and Years, but sometimes I can see her as the Doctor and sometimes I can't, as opposed to some actors I can very definitely see in the role.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top