• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers ST Picard - Starships and Technology Season Two Discussion

Krash, (as Kirk Thatcher named the punk on the bus), seems to have learned a lesson about belligerence, but he may have learned it from Confederation Spock, definitely a time travelling guy with a goatee. Who went on to steal some whales but also ended up blasting the volleyball-log probe when the whales wouldn't cooperate. Maybe.
I think so. To my mind the probe is something that would make the Confed forces struggle a bit, largely because it was so devastating even before it fully arrives. I can see them trying but ultimately failing despite their efforts, so they finally, begrudgingly, did time travel.
 
Why would the Spock of that universe help the Confederacy to save Earth?

Plus, the time travel discovery may never have happened in the Confederacy. A more likely result is on the day the whale probe came to Earth, there were countless starships sacrificed to destroy it.
 
Why would Spock exist in that universe?
Why not? Not to sound flippant, but this is the way Star Trek treats alternative timelines (and Dr. Who to some extent, and Back to the Future, and The One). People still exist even if the timeline is altered.
 
Why not? Not to sound flippant, but this is the way Star Trek treats alternative timelines (and Dr. Who to some extent, and Back to the Future, and The One). People still exist even if the timeline is altered.

That still doesn’t answer my question as to why Spock would help the Confederacy save Earth.
 
Trekcore recently tweeted a screenshot where the photographs behind Guinan in her bar include a t-shirt featuring the Enterprise-D with Guinan's own 2360's face and Picard's. If their timeline is so fractured that it has 1990's VINTAGE ST:TNG MERCHANDISE IN IT, then the punk on the bus might just as easily be the Kirk Thatcher from our dimension. I'm going to have to shrug and settle for "A Q did it."
 
He was part of the Empire and second in command of the Enterprise. The Terran Empire is not the same thing as the Confederacy.
All I saying is I see the potential, either by coercion or by a sense of loyalty to the state, that Spock would act in favor of the Confederation.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
Renaming a battery as something else doesn't really help the situation & adds unnecessary confusion.
 
She doesn't rename the battery, she simply described the battery in its simplest terms. It's no different to asking someone to "step out of the vehicle."

Sorry, I don't know how it creates unnecessary confusion, so can't answer that point.


dJE
 
Renaming a battery as something else doesn't really help the situation & adds unnecessary confusion.
How so? It's just a terminology that we use and came to mean something different.

The only people confused by it are people of our time. And Star Trek is supposed to be "THE FUTURE" (trademark pending).
 
2x05:

- Evil Samsung tricoders can be configured to emit an (EM?) pulse that can disable large busses and large bus drivers. Presumably this means that the tricorders of 2400 prime Starfleet can do the same? And didn't Raffi have an evil, glass-destroying phaser she could've used on the driver, or does it not have a stun setting on account of being evil?

- I forgot to point out last week that the evil La Sirena's cloak uses the same sound effect as the TOS movies' Klingon Bird of Prey, and not the TNG SFX. We hear it again this week.

- The power cell of the evil combadge is visible from the front when removed / reapplied. Is there any reason for this other than as a visual indication? We've had internal batteries on darn near everything since they were invented. Maybe it's directly linked to the antenna array, which are those horizontal lines on the front?

- Okay, so not-Laris is of the same group of empowered humans (?) as Gary Seven, and uses the same sort of tech. How does this explain a bank vault in her apartment, though? You could sorta get away with it in Gary's office, but here? Or is this one of those loft apartments that used to be a bank..?

- Great to hear that Renee's French accent is from the same region of France as Jean-Luc. The policeman obviously came from elsewhere. And speaking as a francophone, the Queen's French was atrocious, which is attributable to the actor, but the Borg themselves not able to replicate proper French? I guess it's kinda par for Trek anyway - thanks Marc Alaimo.

- Those shield drones don't really look just two years more advanced than what we have here (and is clearly a visual hint to the evil 2400 planetary shields). I know we're trying to subtly indicate that this is the Trek timeline here, which means there SHOULD'VE been a series of horrible wars around thirty years prior, but should there be more advanced stuff out there? One guy in the hallway that Soong was trying to convince (who holds board meetings in a hallway?) was using a Microsoft Surface.

Mark

Mark
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top