• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Superman

All this talk of older Supes series reminds me of this Superboy clip:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Could somebody please explain to me how one simple act...

Superboy killing Luthor

could cause such a collapse of society? I don't remember the episode ever explaining how that happened. :confused:

I mean, at one point, Superboy just says

"This is what would happen if I did kill him."

But WHY? It never explains why or how that happened. It doesn't make any sense.
 
Last edited:
I think another line from that clip -- "It's all hopeless" -- is a big part of the answer. When Superboy betrays the heroic ideal he represents by committing murder, the idea is that it shakes the world that has come to believe in him to its core.

Is it "realistic" that the effect would be so devastating? Probably not. But realism is wildly overrated as a goal in these kinds of stories. Think of it more as a parable, where what the character represents morally is more important than any logical cause-and-effect.
 
The brief moments of journalism are even more laughable on Supergirl. In one episode, she files her story in a college report binder. Like whut?




And then she wins a journalism award,

...because there was no way that was not going to be used to give insta-credit as a real journalist without doing anything to earn the distinction. Supergirl is not alone in depicting journalism as some banging-the-typwriter-during-the-1940s profession, or the most honorable, heroic profession on earth. It does not fit with either perception.

yet we never see her doing any reporting? Also what the hell does CatCo exactly do... is it a magazine, a cable news network, a radio station?

I see Berlanti productions answer to that question as a collective shoulder shrug.
 
All this talk of older Supes series reminds me of this Superboy clip:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Could somebody please explain to me how one simple act...

Superboy killing Luthor

could cause such a collapse of society? I don't remember the episode ever explaining how that happened. :confused:

I mean, at one point, Superboy just says

"This is what would happen if I did kill him."

But WHY? It never explains why or how that happened. It doesn't make any sense.
Superboy is all that's pure and good in the world. Seeing him do something unforgivable broke everyone's spirit, all at once.

Like is somehow everyone got irrefutable proof that Jesus was a douchebag.
 
...because there was no way that was not going to be used to give insta-credit as a real journalist without doing anything to earn the distinction. Supergirl is not alone in depicting journalism as some banging-the-typwriter-during-the-1940s profession, or the most honorable, heroic profession on earth. It does not fit with either perception.



I see Berlanti productions answer to that question as a collective shoulder shrug.
As much as I love Supergirl, even I'll admit they never seemed to really put any real effort into anything the characters did as reporters. The few times they did focus on them being journalists, it was pretty clear they didn't put even didn't bother trying to makng it realistic.
I'm not sure which is worse ther Arrowvere's handeling of journalism, or trials.
 
As much as I love Supergirl, even I'll admit they never seemed to really put any real effort into anything the characters did as reporters. The few times they did focus on them being journalists, it was pretty clear they didn't put even didn't bother trying to makng it realistic.
I'm not sure which is worse ther Arrowvere's handeling of journalism, or trials.

Superman and Lois has done the best job of portraying the journalism I've seen in any incarnation.
 
As much as I love Supergirl, even I'll admit they never seemed to really put any real effort into anything the characters did as reporters. The few times they did focus on them being journalists, it was pretty clear they didn't put even didn't bother trying to makng it realistic.

I'm not sure which is worse ther Arrowvere's handeling of journalism, or trials.

Journalism, as its clear the writers approach the profession from a wildly unrealistic "champions of truth" fantasy-land sold as the standard behavior, while their ideas on methodology are just cartoonish.
 
All this talk of older Supes series reminds me of this Superboy clip:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Could somebody please explain to me how one simple act...

Superboy killing Luthor

could cause such a collapse of society? I don't remember the episode ever explaining how that happened. :confused:

I haven't seen the episode, but I can see people putting on their brown pants if some one that powerful started going off the rails at all.
 
In my head canon the first Zod was killed by the Christopher Reeve Superman since the deleted scenes from the Fortress of Solitude show him destroying the Fortress on top of the bodies of the three supervillains. Maybe they weren't dead when they first fell or were thrown or knocked into the bowels of the Fortress but they were dead afterwards.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top