• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Marvel Cinematic Universe spoiler-heavy speculation thread

What grade would you give the Marvel Cinematic Universe? (Ever-Changing Question)


  • Total voters
    185
Why rebooted???
As far as I know, for contractual reasons with Netflix, Marvel can revive the characters from those in another medium or format but can't simply do a continuation of the Netflix versions on a different provider. I'm subject to correction, though.

In general terms, the show doesn’t need rebooted, if that’s why you’re asking - I’d love to see the original cast and crew return for a revival.
 
Last edited:
As far as I know, that's not the case. There was an embargo on when they could make new productions, but that's about it. The reasons for a reboot would be practical - they don't want to say "go to Netflix for Seasons One and Two." My guess is they'll either do a total reboot (with a re-cast) or, more likely, do a soft reboot where it could fit in continuity with what came before but nothing that came before would be required to understand the current situation. With the blip, there's a lot of flexibility there. As long as they make Luke Cage an established hero, everything necessary to get him from where he was at the end of the Netflix show to where they want him could have occurred in the five-year time gap.
 
My guess is they'll either do a total reboot (with a re-cast) or, more likely, do a soft reboot where it could fit in continuity with what came before but nothing that came before would be required to understand the current situation. With the blip, there's a lot of flexibility there. As long as they make Luke Cage an established hero, everything necessary to get him from where he was at the end of the Netflix show to where they want him could have occurred in the five-year time gap.

So basically what the Arrowverse has done with John Constantine. There are enough subtle links to the NBC series to make it clearly the same continuity (e.g. Astra Logue is African-American rather than white and English, and the original actress made a voice cameo before the role was recast due to age differences), but there are no explicit mentions of anything from the show that wasn't originally from the comics.

Really, though, if there are no legal restrictions on using story elements, there's no reason not to. People often talk about what previous viewing is "required" to understand a new installment in a series, but ideally, it should never be required. Anything you need to know to understand one installment in a series should be explained right there in the story itself. After all, every story depends on prior information, whether the audience saw it or not. The plot of the very first Star Trek pilot, "The Cage," was shaped by the aftermath of a prior, unseen battle on Rigel VII. Hamlet is entirely about the aftermath of a murder that happened before the play started. The parts we haven't seen are explained for us right then and there, and that's all that should ever be required. Actually seeing the prior events is a nice bonus, but it shouldn't be an absolute requirement. You're not telling a story right if you create hurdles in your audience's path rather than ramps to ease their entry.

So if you're reintroducing story elements from a prior season, then you should do it the exact same way you'd introduce backstory for the first time. You explain it in the current story. You have a character who knows about it explain it to a new character who wasn't there for it, or you have two or more returning characters talk/argue about it in retrospect. Of course, it's best to do that in a way that isn't clumsily expository, that feels like organic dialogue rather than an infodump, but that's true for any backstory exposition.
 
Last edited:
As far as I know, that's not the case. There was an embargo on when they could make new productions, but that's about it. The reasons for a reboot would be practical - they don't want to say "go to Netflix for Seasons One and Two." My guess is they'll either do a total reboot (with a re-cast) or, more likely, do a soft reboot where it could fit in continuity with what came before but nothing that came before would be required to understand the current situation. With the blip, there's a lot of flexibility there. As long as they make Luke Cage an established hero, everything necessary to get him from where he was at the end of the Netflix show to where they want him could have occurred in the five-year time gap.
Personally I'm rooting for a 'Daughters of the Dragon' show over a Luke Cage reboot, but I wouldn't object to a 'Heroes for Hire'. Indeed I think a lot of the flaws of Luke Cage and Iron Fist could be fixed simply by having those two partner up.
While I'd like to see 'Jessica Jones' and 'Daredevil' just straight up get new shows, I think a similar hybrid show could work well. I mean their interactions was one for the few highlights of 'The Defenders'. That or make Jessica the third "Daughter of the Dragon" and promote Daredevil to movie status.
 
As long as they completely recast and reboot Iron Fist, Elektra and Bullseye, I'd be fine with the rest of the Marvel netflix casts showing up in the MCU. I'd especially like to see Cox as Daredevil again, he feels like he'd fit the best and he's easily the best actor of the Marvel netflix show leads.
 
Somebody referred to the X-Men upthread. Earlier I mentioned I would love to see a WWII Invaders movie, but I am thinking that a real Defenders movie would be a great way to introduce Namor.
 
Wow, I'm kind of surprised they managed to start without us seeing some evidence before this. Usually we hear about the actors being spotted arriving there or something like that.
Everybody involved was either spotted arriving Down Under, or even posted about going there when they getting ready to film Love & Thunder.
 
Wow, I'm kind of surprised they managed to start without us seeing some evidence before this. Usually we hear about the actors being spotted arriving there or something like that.

I suppose that's no guarantee that the main cast are involved (yet). Looking at photos of Cappadocia online if you point the camera in the right direction you could be on another planet (or in the quantum realm).
 
With the exception of wanting resolution to Luke Cage's hanging plot threads, I agree.
I'll be honest, I kinda don't care what happens next with Luke. Something about that second season just left me cold on the character. If he shows up again (assuming it's the same actor & continuity) I'll be happy if they just handwave away the cliffhanger with "he got blipped". That or Jessica showed up and dragged him off the The Raft too.
 
I haven't seen any of the stuff she's worked on, but she's got a hell of a resume.
 
I'll be honest, I kinda don't care what happens next with Luke. Something about that second season just left me cold on the character. If he shows up again (assuming it's the same actor & continuity) I'll be happy if they just handwave away the cliffhanger with "he got blipped". That or Jessica showed up and dragged him off the The Raft too.

Really though, it wasn't much of a cliffhanger. You could start a new show with Luke in a different situation and he decided to give up the club or it wasn't his gig and done. On with the new story.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top