People would still complain because it wasn't the original effects (and thats a perfectly valid opinion)
I'd love to see a whole episode like that though. The whole series in fact. It might be too weird though. Youd have to see over 30 seconds worth.
If a whole episode were done, next thing someone would say the costumes look too cheap and old-fashioned. So you re-dress everybody in cool new uniforms. And boy, those short hemlines have to go! Then Spock's eyebrows are inconsistent. Then it's Kirk's weight. Then the communicator has to be a smart phone.
And if all of those original things can go, next comes the moments of un-woke dialogue: the mechanical rice picker, "the girl," the "losing an officer" if she gets married, the "some things men must do to remain men" (gasp!), the "You're a Vulcanian, aren't you?" and "You green-blooded..." (tossed as racism), the "Women professionals do tend to overcompensate" nonsense that place the show in our history as much as our future. Toss it all out and make the original into a spin-off. Open the floodgates too much, and the show becomes something else.
The brief clip does look great, though.