• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 1x09 - "Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 1"

Rate Star Trek: Picard 1x09 - "Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 1"


  • Total voters
    244
[...]The synths will activate the beacon (we see that in the trailer). Soji will sacrifice herself to stop the threat. Picard dies but transfers his mind into a synth body.
@KennyB. Just curious, but what's the policy re $poilers for unreleased episode trailers? I only come into these topics once I've seen the episode in question, this can't be spoiled on it, but I do not watch the trailers, but, as above, people here discuss those, too.
 
I am disappointed by lack of mention of Data's neurons. They made a big deal about it in the first episode, indicating all the new androids are made from Data's neurons. I thought that was one of the reasons Picard was looking for Maddox, to ask him where he got the neurons from. But when he had the chance he didn't ask Maddox. And now he doesn't ask Soong either. WTF? Maybe Soong got them from his dad.

I think that's why Jurati is going to be in charge of the "golem". She's supposed to transfer Soong, but will resurrect Data instead. That mention in episode 1 was too clear for them to just drop it later when you have a new android body that looks like Data just waiting for a new brain.
 
So the crew is now friendly and jokey with Agnes after she murdered a man in cold blood? What? Have they forgiven her or something? Why aren't they keeping her in the brig?

Does Sirena even HAVE a brig?

I think that's why Jurati is going to be in charge of the "golem". She's supposed to transfer Soong, but will resurrect Data instead. That mention in episode 1 was too clear for them to just drop it later when you have a new android body that looks like Data just waiting for a new brain.

Perhaps that's Picard's endgame: resurrecting Data.
 
My guess is that a prisoner would be watched at gunpoint, confined behind a force field or locked inside a storage compartment or room. Runabouts aren't much smaller or are roughly the same size and you really couldn't do much with prisoners other than watch them.
 
Perhaps that's Picard's endgame: resurrecting Data.

Transferring Data's mind into a new body would've resolved the issue that Spiner declines to play him anymore since he gets old. A new and younger Data would've ensured his future in the Trek-verse for decades to come ;):beer:
 
I see a lot of posts talking about Picard’s mind being transferred to an android. What a horrible idea, I am hoping the writers are better than that.

Picard being played by someone other than sir Patrick, when he is still available, is idiotic. And if the android looks like him it is just as bad, and I doubt if PS would agree to play an android version of his character.

so this is not happening. Of course I was similarly sure that the terrible idea of Lorca being from the mirror universe was not happening either.
 
Last edited:
What I took from this episode was that Sutra executed a perfect false flag operation and that the Romulans are now the good guys.

Though I know it won't happen, I would really hope that the Romulans would win and destroy all these synths. I have no sympathy for them.

And, the reason for the hostility between organics and synthetics is absurd to me. Organics yearn perfection so they build machines which are close to perfection. These machines don't age, like organics, so organics come to fear them and, driven by fear, come to destroy them. Nothing about slavery, nothing about exploitation.
 
Last edited:
A following that the production can't control is different from how the show is framed by directors/writers though. Dukat was always depicted as a Bad Guy (TM), complete with basically sending him to a pit of fire in the series finale.

Dukat was an ally, and on relatively good terms with most of the station's crew, throughout S4 and S5. He definitely wasn't depicted as a "Bad Guy".
 
Agree. I think the chances of Stewart headlining season 2 and beyond as RoboPicard are close to zero.

He doesn't have to be inside the robot. maybe you put the synth brain inside of him. transfer all his marbles in there, plug him in and bam, hope it works out better than that whole Vedek Bareil thing
 
Dukat was an ally, and on relatively good terms with most of the station's crew, throughout S4 and S5. He definitely wasn't depicted as a "Bad Guy".
Even at his most "allied" they showed him as moustache twirling evil, like blowing up the Klingons when his Klingon holoprojector wasn't working in Apocalypse Rising. Right in Season 5.
 
P.S. So, how about all that constant lightning on the planet they identified because it has two red moons and continuous lightning storms? ;)

Sunny day
Sweeping the clouds away...

I did see some dark clouds in the corner of the sky at a couple points in the episode.
 
Can't rate it except as an expository episode, which it did quite well, I suppose 8 worthy. Part II better build to a crescendo though, or the season might end on a flat note.
 
Sexy Soji learns how to do a mind meld?
bllMHrJ.gif
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top