• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Everyday life on earth

I'm fine with mental gymnasting the economy issues, as long at said gymnastics actually try not ignore the spirit of the moneyless economy concept and paint several characters as liars and hypocrites. I certainly have a solid enough mental model how I can see it working and fitting most of the evidence seen on screen well enough.
Yes, I get that. I have a solid enough mental model on why starship designs might last as long as they do on screen.

Why one is OK and the other is not amuses me.
 
Yes, I get that. I have a solid enough mental model on why starship designs might last as long as they do on screen.

Why one is OK and the other is not amuses me.
Because different people have their disbelief suspensors calibrated differently and they find different things implausible? I'm not going to the detail on starship lifespan here, as we have separate thread for that.
 
It is not silly, it is a realistic result of effective post scarcity and and advanced automation.

Your altered dialogue shows exactly why this interpretation is disingenuous. This simply cannot be the case, it is clearly not the intent. Digital currency is nothing weird or revolutionary, Lily certainly would understand it just fine. No money means no money and that's that.

Those people work there because the ships need to be built so that 900 million lives can be saved! Now normally they'd have plenty of leaves etc, but they happen to be on tight schedule! Granted, It would be nice if someone had provided them with a better replicator. And people work at Sisko's restaurant because they like to socialise with people, want to gain experience because they want to open their own restaurant later or think that the work experience looks good on their CV.
Pretty much this. The 'big idea' that I always took away from Trek was that in a post-scarcity environment, people would still be motivated to work just to do something with themselves and/or better themselves. Not because they have to, but because they choose to. Even menial jobs. Remember that Trek generally highlights the best of humanity and we are supposed to have more or less overcome our worst instincts.

But if you still think that is completely unrealistic, consider the real life case of one Woody Widenhoffer. A former NFL defensive coach for a couple of decades, went to the Super Bowl 9 times. Left the NFL and became the head coach at Vanderbilt for about 5 years. He was eventually fired by Vandy, and he left coaching permanently and retired. He undoubtedly made millions just from his time at Vandy, and never had any need to work again if he so chose. He now works at a toll booth in Florida. I am sure it is often too hot in his booth, and he may or may not get to eat meals and such at his desired hours. His stated reason? He was bored and likes meeting people.
 
Clearly the need for humans to ingest alcohol as a means of relaxation demonstrates that we have strayed from Gene's vision of a evolved humanity.
 
Why not? It needs no explanation. Alcohol has been around since Scotty in TOS, at least. Nothing new to Star Trek.

No, certainly not. It means humanity has failed and we should be able to relax without a chemical influencing our bodies. We should just focus on altruistic concepts about the improvements of humanity.
 
Has anyone ever explained why Picard’s wine is allowed?

That's an odd question. There's no ban against intoxicating stimulants like alcoholic beverages in the Federation. Synthehol exists because some humans and aliens wanted options to getting drunk and the consequences of being hammered on the job or in front of their friends and loved ones.

Picard's wine is legal because it's not an inherently dangerous substance and is produced through peaceful and one might assume environmentally-sustainable means.
 
Drugs and Vasquez Rocks already have something of a checkered past.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top