• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Drop the S31 show for a Captain Pike show?

Drop the Section 31 show for a the Pike show?

  • Yes, I want a Pike show, and do not want a Section 31 show.

    Votes: 124 55.9%
  • No, I want a Section 31 show, and do not want a show with Pike.

    Votes: 9 4.1%
  • I want a show that feature both Pike and crew on the Enterprise and Section 31 with Georgiou.

    Votes: 23 10.4%
  • I trust CBS to give me something I will like!

    Votes: 12 5.4%
  • I want to see both! as separate shows.

    Votes: 54 24.3%

  • Total voters
    222
Actually, overseas this weird streaming business can be an isse: Like, in Germany, DIS is shown exclusively on Netflix. Wheras PIC will be shown exclusivelx on Amazon Prime.

Which is... baffling... to say the least. Splitting your one IP up over multiple paid streamijg services - meaning if you have to pay for two(!) services if you want to watch all currently produced Star Trek! That is extremely stupid. And I guess the situation will become even worse once All Access tries to enter new markets where the Trek license(s) have already been sold. All in all, a big clusterfuck
The plan is not to build up one competitor too strongly, hence splitting Trek up internationally. The big draw when CBS-AA finally goes global will be Trek "coming home" under one roof.
 
The plan is not to build up one competitor too strongly, hence splitting Trek up internationally. The big draw when CBS-AA finally goes global will be Trek "coming home" under one roof.

I think "the plan" breaks down to "Netflix don't wanna' pay more"/"Amazon offers much more money".

They could have put both shows on both channels of try wanted to play the long game. Splitting up your own audience between multiple services is the most stupid business plan long term, because it guarantees your fan base splintering.

They wouldn't do that for some weird "competition avoidance plan". That's something only done if either no other options are available, or to much cash being offered to refuse. None of which speaks to a strong negotiation position.
 
Last edited:
I'd prefer a Pikespockterprise series, but I don't think Mount is willing to commit so... :shrug:

I just met Anson at Shore Leave's con in MD. He was so touched by the petition and Star Trek is his dream job if we can help convince the powers that be to make it happen...
These people started the petition: https://www.facebook.com/StarTrekPi...f_id=1563462922094732&notif_t=comment_mention

With Ash Tyler on board (as the S2 finale implies) and the softening of Georgiou, I'm more eager for the S31 show than I was.
I agree with you, heartily.
 
I agree with you, heartily.

But why does it seem like nobody wants to be astonished by a show they never even considered? Why prefer more of something named and palatable to new categories of risk? Is it that people no longer believe in these showrunners’ ability to deliver, so they prefer to have them elaborate upon known quantities?

For me the answer is simple: I’ll watch anything Star Trek once (at least) for lore, but I don’t want to ask for a particular kind of show. Surprise me.
 
But why does it seem like nobody wants to be astonished by a show they never even considered? Why prefer more of something named and palatable to new categories of risk?
People prefer comfort, safe and familiar. In a time of uncertainty (as the world is) safe and familiar is desired.
 
Last edited:
Discovery has already been uglier than I would prefer, and the Section 31 show only distills uglier aspects I dislike. I hope it will surprise me, but I understand why people are hesitant.
 
Last edited:
Are any people posting here aware of the online petition to have a Pike-led series? A quick google search of "star trek" with "petition" will bring it right up. I hope it isn't offensive to share this information here.
 
Are any people posting here aware of the online petition to have a Pike-led series? A quick google search of "star trek" with "petition" will bring it right up. I hope it isn't offensive to share this information here.
Not offensive at all. It's been shared and talked about several hundred times on here. Pike is great!
 
Kurtzman teased hell out of this at SDCC.

Yeah. I suspect there really will be a Pike Enterprise series. I mean they even make two Short Treks with them, too. It would make sense as even without special promotion there is already a hype around it.
 
Yeah. I suspect there really will be a Pike Enterprise series. I mean they even make two Short Treks with them, too. It would make sense as even without special promotion there is already a hype around it.
It would be wonderful to have both. Maybe there could even be a... crossover *dramatic music plays*
 
Just saw this:

https://trekmovie.com/2019/07/20/comic-con-2019-star-trek-discovery-season-3-and-short-treks-news/
As we found out last month, there was at least one Short Treks coming with the Enterprise crew. Today during the Discovery section of the Star Trek Universe panel Alex Kurtzman revealed that of the 6 new shorts coming, and three will feature the Pike-era crew of the USS Enterprise! One has Spock and Number One stuck in a turbolift, and is written by Michael Chabon. Another of the shorts set on the Pike-era Enterprise has tribbles and guest star H. Jon Benjamin (Archer, Bob’s Burgers). Another stars Anson Mount as Captain Pike.

So even 3 Short Treks with the Pike Enterprise characters. :)
 
It would be wonderful to have both. Maybe there could even be a... crossover *dramatic music plays*
They could even go beyond simple guest characters and do interwoven plots like CBS has done before on their crime shows. CSI had a three-parter once centering on Laurence Fishburne's character with each part being in a different CSI series. I'd love to see something like this with Section 31's current plot getting out of control in a way that forces Starfleet to officially get involved, and the Pike series would take up the thread from there.
 
https://trekmovie.com/2019/07/21/sd...possible-pike-spock-enterprise-series-teased/

Pike, Spock and the USS Enterprise were well-received parts of the second season of Discovery, and they even inspired a popular petition. Kurtzman acknowledged this and made it clear the idea of giving the Enterprise crew their own show is on their radar:

"There is speculation about Pike and Spock and Number One getting their own show. So, I guess the question for you guys is do you want them to get their own show? [crowd roars with a positive affirmation] Okay, we will think about it… [with a smile]."
 
Or drop section 31 and Discovery, and make a Pike and Lost Era show :)
And Picard too, please. That way we got all Pike all the time, since we are wishing for unrealistic things.

"There is speculation about Pike and Spock and Number One getting their own show. So, I guess the question for you guys is do you want them to get their own show? [crowd roars with a positive affirmation] Okay, we will think about it… [with a smile]."
Given that they are doing a short Trek (or two) with the crew then they still have the assets to make this show happen. I think they will gauge such a show based upon reception of the Short Trek.
 
If the Pike petition is based on the safest possible “don’t touch anything, that looks fine right there, give us more of that” approach to “boldly going”, why not add the slightest amount of risk and ask for April in 2245 (or decades earlier if we go by TAS)?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top