• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Too many chiefs, not enough braves... Enlisted crew in TOS

I generally sick to Anglophone navies when seeking RW comparasions so that I can understand the primary sources, in this case - as noted in my post above - I was referring to the Collins-class d-e boot operated by the Royal Australian Navy or RAN. As far as the article at your link, that's certainly interesting, however U-22 isn't operated by the Deutsch Marine any more and current Marine policy appears to be to assign command of u-boats to Korvettenkapitän (broadly Lt Cdr) rather than junior officers.

As far as PT boats go, I say you're at least partly right to compare them to shuttlepods, runabouts would probably be a little generous. I'd say a better comparison would probably be the Starfleet/Maquis fighter (Maquis or Preemptive Strike version, not the larger Raider from Caretaker) or possibly the Type-9 shuttle (Voyager's speedboat type) as PT boats are capable of anti-ship work, but in common with both have extremely limited solo endurance and therefore range.
 
As far as PT boats go, I say you're at least partly right to compare them to shuttlepods, runabouts would probably be a little generous. I'd say a better comparison would probably be the Starfleet/Maquis fighter (Maquis or Preemptive Strike version, not the larger Raider from Caretaker) or possibly the Type-9 shuttle (Voyager's speedboat type) as PT boats are capable of anti-ship work, but in common with both have extremely limited solo endurance and therefore range.

FWIW, the Pegasus class PHM's (intended to fill some of the same roles as the WW2 PT boats) had a crew of 23 (4 officers and 19 enlisted) and were typically commanded by a Commander (O-5) or a Lieutenant Commander (O-4). Unfortunately they turned out to be expensive and only six were built. Mostly the class was based in the Florida Keys and used in the drug interdiction role.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top