_______
55th Anniversary Event Viewing
The Ed Sullivan Show
Season 16, episode 19
Originally aired February 9, 1964
As represented in The Beatles: The First U.S. Visit and The Best of the Ed Sullivan Show
I've been watching but not regularly covering Best of installments from this era in 55th anniversary sync, and couldn't let the opportunity pass to cover this, probably the most historically significant episode of the long-running series. Best of gives us an episode consisting entirely of performances from this date, including one of the Beatles' numbers; and The First U.S. Visit, which I've still got on VHS, fills in most of the gaps by offering more of the Beatles' performances. Here I present the performances in the order that online sources indicate the original broadcast used, rather than deferring to the Best of edit.
The Fab Four make their American performance debut with "All My Loving" from the U.K.'s With the Beatles and its rough American counterpart, Meet the Beatles! Following that things get gentler with Paul's cover of "Till There Was You," also found on those albums. This is the segment in which the picture darkens briefly to display each of their names onscreen, with each Fab getting his own share of screams...culminating with John getting some laughter and applause when his name is accompanied by that iconic blurb, "SORRY GIRLS, HE'S MARRIED:" Finishing this set, the boys bring the energy back up with "She Loves You"--currently a single on the Swan label in the U.S. that's at #3 on Billboard. It was an interesting choice to lead with two Paul songs--I wonder if the Sullivan people were doing what George Martin says he tried to do at first in the studio, attempting to single out a lead singer rather than accepting them as an ensemble. For the third number, with John on lead, the camera stays mainly on Paul and George at first.
Now we switch to DVD for some of the other performers on that legendary broadcast.
The cast's next performance, which is on Best of--and which Ed is introducing in the clip above--has Worf's future mom singing "As Long as He Needs Me," with no future Monkees in sight.
Given what they describe, I think the routine came off remarkably well.
Back to VHS....
Sources indicate that the Beatles did not close the show. Rather, the anticlimax that millions of Americans likely weren't paying attention to is the acrobatic troupe Wells & the Four Fays, who are in the middle of the Best of edit. Apparently they're close relations of Toni Basil, and this video apparently shows an earlier appearance followed by the full version of their performance on the night being spotlighted here (4:01).
_______

55th Anniversary Event Viewing
The Ed Sullivan Show
Season 16, episode 19
Originally aired February 9, 1964
As represented in The Beatles: The First U.S. Visit and The Best of the Ed Sullivan Show
I've been watching but not regularly covering Best of installments from this era in 55th anniversary sync, and couldn't let the opportunity pass to cover this, probably the most historically significant episode of the long-running series. Best of gives us an episode consisting entirely of performances from this date, including one of the Beatles' numbers; and The First U.S. Visit, which I've still got on VHS, fills in most of the gaps by offering more of the Beatles' performances. Here I present the performances in the order that online sources indicate the original broadcast used, rather than deferring to the Best of edit.
Ed famously said:Now yesterday and today our theater's been jammed with newspapermen and hundreds of photographers from all over the nation, and these veterans agree with me that the city never has witnessed the excitement stirred by these youngsters from Liverpool who call themselves the Beatles. Now tonight you're going to twice be entertained by them, right now and again in the second half of our show. Ladies and gentlemen...the Beatles!
The Fab Four make their American performance debut with "All My Loving" from the U.K.'s With the Beatles and its rough American counterpart, Meet the Beatles! Following that things get gentler with Paul's cover of "Till There Was You," also found on those albums. This is the segment in which the picture darkens briefly to display each of their names onscreen, with each Fab getting his own share of screams...culminating with John getting some laughter and applause when his name is accompanied by that iconic blurb, "SORRY GIRLS, HE'S MARRIED:" Finishing this set, the boys bring the energy back up with "She Loves You"--currently a single on the Swan label in the U.S. that's at #3 on Billboard. It was an interesting choice to lead with two Paul songs--I wonder if the Sullivan people were doing what George Martin says he tried to do at first in the studio, attempting to single out a lead singer rather than accepting them as an ensemble. For the third number, with John on lead, the camera stays mainly on Paul and George at first.
This is where The First U.S. Visit places this bit of business, though some sources indicate that Ed actually opened with it.Ed said:Y'know something very nice happened and the Beatles got a great kick out of it. We just received a wire, they did, from Elvis Presley and Colonel Tom Parker wishing them a tremendous success in our country, and I think that is very, very nice of them.
Now we switch to DVD for some of the other performers on that legendary broadcast.
The part of the Dutch magician's routine that's shown on Best of involves him trying to show the audience a card trick and repeatedly seeming to get flustered as the cards change. The preview at the beginning of Best of also showed him doing a trick that involved pouring salt into his fist. The clip below appears to show his entire performance (and also demonstrates how much Best of edits Ed's intros):Edited Ed said:From Europe also, we saw this very amusing trickster, tall Fred Kaps!
There's an obvious edit here in the Best of cut. Sources indicate that the first number performed by the Broadway show's cast is the better-known one that wasn't shown on Best of--Davy Jones as the Artful Dodger singing "I'd Do Anything":Edited Ed said:At the Schubert Theater here in our town, Lionel Bart's Oliver! is in it second roaring year. Now here's the English singing star Georgia Brown....
The cast's next performance, which is on Best of--and which Ed is introducing in the clip above--has Worf's future mom singing "As Long as He Needs Me," with no future Monkees in sight.
The future Gotham Arch-Villain and Trek guest does a prescient routine about Hollywood stars running for office. First up is Brando:Ed may have said:Right now from Hollywood, the brilliant young impressionist Frank Gorshin!
He promptly switches to Burt Lancaster, then Kirk Douglas. I get the impression that there was probably originally more to this performance as well...as shown on Best of, it seems pretty brief.For years now, year after year after year, there have been just two major parties: one at Frank Sinatra's house and the other at Dean Martin's.
Best of only showed the last number from this medley, "Two Ton Tessie". I don't know where they got Ed's intro from.Edited Ed said:Now let's have an explosive hand for England's nuclear bomb, Tessie O’Shea!
Mitzi and Charlie (the latter of whom will also be a Trek guest) do a routine in which he's playing a producer and she plays his secretary, who shows in a number of aspiring actresses (all played by Mitzi, and likely also edited on Best of) before he realizes that the secretary is the one he's been looking for, once he's removed her glasses...then he puts them on himself and declares her to be the ugliest girl he's ever seen. I wasn't able to find a clip of this, but here's a radio clip of the duo retrospectively explaining the extenuating circumstances of their appearance that night (skip to "Take My Break, Please" on the linked page)--how the Sullivan people demanded they change their routine at the last minute, and how their attempts to rehearse it were interrupted by a noteworthy visitor...as partially related in the video below:Ed allegedly said:A team of real daffy American youngsters...McCall & Brill!
Given what they describe, I think the routine came off remarkably well.
Back to VHS....
Sources indicate that the Beatles' second set starts with "I Saw Her Standing There," but this isn't shown on The First U.S. Visit...possibly because there's another performance of it on one of the upcoming two consecutive Sullivan appearances also featured in that home video release. Rather, it goes straight into their debut American hit, currently at the top of the chart for the third of seven weeks, "I Want to Hold Your Hand"...which is also the only Beatles number shown in the Best of installment:Ed said:Introducing the Beatles again, may I point out that they'll be on our show, as I told our audience, for the next two Sundays--next Sunday from the Deauville Hotel in Miami Beach, a show starring Hollywood's exciting Mitzi Gaynor. Now ladies and gentlemen, once again...!
Sources indicate that the Beatles did not close the show. Rather, the anticlimax that millions of Americans likely weren't paying attention to is the acrobatic troupe Wells & the Four Fays, who are in the middle of the Best of edit. Apparently they're close relations of Toni Basil, and this video apparently shows an earlier appearance followed by the full version of their performance on the night being spotlighted here (4:01).
_______
I'll stop you at that point.This was sort of a whiner song

I think I agree with this.Forget "Happy Together". This moody piece is their best work.
"Kicks" and "Hungry" were '66. I'd argue that the Raiders were still in good form for "Good Thing" ('66) and "Him or Me, What's It Gonna Be?" ('67); and while they're definitely in a slump by this point (early '69), I'm always cautious about making declarations of their demise, as their biggest hit is still ahead of them.The group's last hurrah was 1965's "Hungry" (in a year arguably recognized as their strongest, with "Just Like Me" and "Kicks" also hitting the charts).
You're just giving me another excuse to say how much I freakin' love this song. But on the Motown side, what do you think of what the Temptations are doing at this point?So evocative of the changing sound of black music at the end of the 60s--leaving the "traditional" Motown-esque sounds behind in favor a grittier, funkier arrangement.
Last edited: