• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Series and Sonequa Martin Green Win Saturn Awards

There's a distinct difference from being merely a stilted cardboard cutout, and being a "Professional" when on the bridge of a ship, You can still be life like and professional. Something the old writers could pull off. Bellana Tores was a great example of both disregard, and yet professionalism. Tilley's attitude is one that left me with she really doesn't care too much about professionalism and protocol. fine, but annoying having been in a Military family and seen first hand command decks with professionalism all the time at play. I think of that F-Bomb scene with Tilley, and transpose it with the opening of the Wrath of Khan and the Kobiashi Maru simulation. No, still think there's something lacking there.
That is why it was badly done. I've been part of a military family too, Dad in Army and husband in Navy. If there is swearing to be done it is done with every second word, lol. Not some stupid forced drop.
 
That is why it was badly done. I've been part of a military family too, Dad in Army and husband in Navy. If there is swearing to be done it is done with every second word, lol. Not some stupid forced drop.
"That's fucking so fucking cool" doen't work as well.
 
That is why it was badly done. I've been part of a military family too, Dad in Army and husband in Navy. If there is swearing to be done it is done with every second word, lol. Not some stupid forced drop.

How funny: Because I’m a military brat. And my sister has (amongst many, many other things) the word ‘fucking’ tattooed on her back.

Meaning she planned it out ahead, lay still for hours to get it done, and has to turn around and take her shirt off for it to be communicated.

But yeah...one slip and an apology for swearing without permission whilst on duty (in front of a superior officer, no less) is ’forced.’

Also, you know what’s always really, really effortless and ‘natural?’ Television productions. Especially ones that require actors to say words like ‘Starfleet,’ and phrases like “To boldly go where no man has gone before!”
 
Last edited:
We've debated this endlessly before, but I still think the "fucking cool" moment was charming and refreshing. And let's not forget the context: it came after a rather massive dose of technobabble and exposition. That particular scene desperately need something to humanize it and bring it back to down to Earth. "Fucking cool" got the job done and provided a nice bonding moment for Tilly and Stamets as well.

Nicely done.
 
How funny: Because I’m a military brat. And my sister has (amongst many, many other things) the word ‘fucking’ tattooed on her back.

Meaning she planned it out ahead, lay still for hours to get it done, and has to turn around and take her shirt off for it to be communicated.

But yeah...one slip and an apology for swearing without permission whilst on duty (in front of a superior officer, no less) is ’forced.’

Also, you know what’s always really, really effortless and ‘natural?’ Television productions. Especially ones that require actors to say words like ‘Starfleet,’ and phrases like “To boldly go where no man has gone before!”
While we were in High School a buddy of mine quit to join the Navy. He left a fairly polite, soft spoken fellow and after basic came back swearing every other word. :lol:
 
Oh yeah. If I wasn’t afraid of her seeing this and hitting me for it, I’d say she swears like a sailor.

Although she did officially get in trouble for her language back in the day. Not so much because she cussed, but because she said it in front of the wrong person at the wrong time.

Namely: Whilst she was in the process of being busted for not wearing the right uniform for that area.
 
When hubby was going away for eight months I was supposed to stay in Navy housing. Lovely people invited us for a meal to show us around and everything. She cooked an amazing roast dinner and I did appreciate it. But did she swear! The language was insane and I found out who was having it off with whoever - cheating on their partners. Like everyone was. It was depressing. Not fucking cool that's for sure.
 
Maybe I am imuned by watching to much HBO,AMC etc but someone saying Fuck didn't seem like much of a big deal. If anything I am shocked that the characters don't have a more salty language all of the time.

Jason
Not overly realistic then is it to just force the scene in. Ticked the box though.
 
What definition? You mean -
laboured, unnatural, artificial, false, feigned, simulated, contrived, stilted, studied, mannered, self-conscious, overdone,

I suppose I do ;)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top