• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

50th Anniversary Rewatch Thread

I see what you're saying, but next time we see Kirk he's sleeping alone fully dressed.

Strangely enough for years the BBC cut Kirk's scene with Drusilla and it simply appeared that he'd been conveyed to a couch and fell asleep upon it! Although the romantic attraction music was raging in the background!
JB

Romulans were based on ancient Romans.

Yes, Paul Shneider wrote the story that way because his son had been reading books about the Romans for a history project at his school!
JB
 
It does seem more James Bond / James West than James Kirk, despite his reputation (which was certainly added to by this episode).
 
It does seem more James Bond / James West than James Kirk, despite his reputation (which was certainly added to by this episode).

Right. All told in all of TOS Kirk beds something like four women. But of course he hooks up with several more and we meet many former flames.
 
Well we don't know that, since everyone who's traveled back in time to conduct that experiment was immediately burned as a witch. :D

You are incorrect. The period of the witch trials lasted only a couple of centuries, and was almost over by 1766 in European culture.

Besides, if you have time travel it is just as easy to take people from 1766 to year 4825, or whenever time travel is invented, disarm them, and show modern technology to them, than it would be to send people from 18,246, or whenever time travel is invented, back to 1766 to display future technology.

Polteageist said:

I wonder why the official language of the Empire still isn't Latin. Or is it just because we needed to have the confusion between "sun" and "son", and "sol" and "filius" don't sound alike?

They say Rome had no sun worshippers, but they were pagan. Didn't they have a god of the sun? Apollo for instance?

So some of Merrik's men are still alive among the population of the Empire? And are we going to do anything about rescuing them?

Kirk looked pretty good in that slave shirt. I wonder if they sell those.

It was cool to see two moons in the sky when they beamed down and then see two moons when they showed the Enterprise orbiting the planet.

I feel like Spock should have been able to beat his opponent much sooner. He's had Starfleet training and superior strength.

"They threw me a few curves." Yes, she did have some.

It's actually not clear whether Kirk did sleep with the slave girl.

Shooting a jail cell lock with a machine gun seems really really dangerous for all involved to me. I'm not even sure it would work.

So the Empire in every way is like 1960's Earth, but they have no nukes. Is that because they didn't have a WWII and so no motivation to develop them?

I'm no historian, but they're making it sound like Christianity made the Roman Empire peaceful which doesn't seem to ring true to me.

Possibly Latin is the main language of the Empire and English is the language of this province. Roman soldiers and administrators would know Latin while locals would speak local languages like, for example, Greek and Aramaic in most of the near east. So most people in this province somehow speaks modern English.

Proconsul Claudius Marcus would seem to be the governor of the province, judging by his title, while first citizen Merickus would seem to be the first citizen of one of the cities in the province.

Ancient Rome did have sun worshipers. The Greek gods Apollo and Helios were worshiped by some provincals and Romans, while there was the ancient Roman god Sol "The Sun". Emperor Elababalus tried to make the Syrian sun god Elagabalus the main god of the empire, and later emperors did make Sol Invictus the principal imperial god before Christianity.
 
Last edited:
Right. All told in all of TOS Kirk beds something like four women. But of course he hooks up with several more and we meet many former flames.

For all we know, Picard went out with more women than Kirk, in his early days he even had dates with two women at the same time.
 
"Assignment: Earth", Episode 55, March 29th

Tonight's Episode: What if Doctor Who and James Bond had a love child?
 
Gary Seven displayed a lot of characteristics of The Doctor from the sixties and seventies and even had his own assistant in Roberta Lincoln!
JB
 
This episode has some issues (although I still like it), but that fight in the transporter room is IMO one of the series' best for Seven's badassery, Spock reacting with shock to getting hit after the nerve pinch fails, and Kirk choosing the better part of valor and using a phaser while making that nifty-cool jump off the transporter platform.
 
Once you realize that the Kirk and Spock bits are literally entirely separate from the Seven bits I think the episode suffers.
 
I've heard that this episode was meant as the pilot of another series that was never made.
You only heard that because it's true. :)

I wonder what The Cast felt about this. This wasn't like generating a spin-off from a successful show. This was Roddenberry abandoning ship and using an episode of said ship to do it.

As I mentioned above, if you look you can see that the episode is structured so that if needed (when it was picked up for series) all of the Star Trek parts could be stripped off of it. There is actually very little overlap between the Seven parts and the Star Trek parts.
 
Just rewatched Assignment Earth.

Spock scoffs at petting tribbles but has no problem petting a cat.

Should I wonder how Gary knew how to operate the Enterprise's transporter?

I was never that fond of episodes set in the 20th century. I lived in the 20th century. I watched Star Trek to see the future. I get that this was the pilot for a new series set in the 20th century.

How exactly does Gary's pen keep a wooden door with no electronics from opening?

Spock's holding Roberta's mouth until the last second. Um, Spock, neck pinch her!

Oh, it's the old "oops, we've accidentally beamed 20th century officers aboard" trick. What? They don't need to keep the cops on the ship until they've gone back in time and can then beam them back into their bodies before they ever saw Kirk and Spock?

So Kirk and Spock were able to look up the adventures of Gary and Roberta. Interesting. But if that's the case, then why all the confusion? Why couldn't they look up Gary when he first came aboard?

A light, entertaining episode. Too bad Gary Seven's series didn't get launched. I would have watched it.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top