• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

News Seth MacFarlane’s The Orville

Actually, I am now picturing Picard reclining in his ready room chair holding a cup of tea and saying quite casually "Admiral, he's drawn a lot of penises on a lot of things" and it strangely enough works.

HANSON: Please. Shelby would make you a hell of a first officer.
PICARD: I already have a hell of a first officer.
HANSON: Really? Word at Starfleet Command is that he drew a penis on the viewscreen in spacedock.
PICARD: Admiral...Commander Riker has drawn a great many penises on a great many things...
 
HANSON: Please. Shelby would make you a hell of a first officer.
PICARD: I already have a hell of a first officer.
HANSON: Really? Word at Starfleet Command is that he drew a penis on the viewscreen in spacedock.
PICARD: Admiral...Commander Riker has drawn a great many penises on a great many things...
coffee....spit...everywhere:guffaw:
 
Isn't being a special one a cliche at this point. I mean you had Starbucks who was special, Kira from Orphan Black who was special, Peter from Gaurdians who is special, Clara and now The recent companion from doctor who are special. What happened to the regular humans or people.

Didn't you learn in school that everyone is special? :)

I appreciate this show having someone drinking soda on the bridge. Most space travel I would think is really boring.

I have nothing against that either! It's like a long road trip. A really, really long road trip!
 
In any event it'll be interesting to see what the ratings were like. Fox is rerunning the pilot rhis evening, I imagine partly over concerns about Hurricane Irma.

Rotten Tomatoes has a 91% "Liked It" rating on the show based on about 750 votes.
 
I couldn't help but feel that the jokes are only there to justify a "We're only parodying Star Trek, not ripping it off!" approach. SOme of the lighter humor worked okay for me, (the same kind of character based stuff regular Trek does) but the "gags" were so-so at best.

That's exactly it. Some worked and others felt horribly forced. Overall, I did enjoy it. But, I hope they figure out this humor thing. Humor. It is a difficult concept!
 
Last edited:
That's exactly it. Some worked and others felt horribly forced. Overall, I did enjoy it. But, I hope they figure out this humor thing. It is difficult!
It's telling that my two favorite bits of humor were two things excluded from the trailers and TV spots, namely Justin the holographic "buddy ogre" being all soft-voiced and supportive and saying how "blessed" they must feel, and Mercer and his ex-wife including the Krill bad guy in their discussion about making a marriage work. It could be that since I hadn't seen those before the surprise made them funnier, but they also felt more organic and less like an obvious forced joke. They were just fun little bits of unexpected dialogue that won you over based on playing against expectations.

I do want to see more of Norm MacDonald as Lt. Jell-O (I don't know what his name is, so that'll have to do for now) though. I see a lot of potential for laughs from a sarcastic gelatinous mass.
 
Isn't being a special one a cliche at this point. I mean you had Starbucks who was special, Kira from Orphan Black who was special, Peter from Gaurdians who is special, Clara and now The recent companion from doctor who are special.

Everyone from People of Earth, too.

I appreciate this show having someone drinking soda on the bridge. Most space travel I would think is really boring.

That really cracked me up. That was his main concern.

:lol:
 
I don't like the look of the "loops" at the back of the ship. I know it's hard to come up with an original spaceship, but this one doesn't do anything for me.

The rank system follows the U.S. Navy pretty much (and I picked up on that last night as I was watching, hearing their rank mentioned and then looking at the epaulettes).

For the division emblems on the chest, I'm gathering Blue uniform/Union Ship emblem = Command/Operations, Orange uniform/Orange Gears emblem = Support Services/Engineering, Red uniform/Red Shield and Wings emblem = Security?

I know the Green uniform = Medical, but didn't catch the insignia.

I thought the colors looked great. The gears badge looks a little "engineery" for helm/nav, but no big deal. IIRC orange was the color for Eagle pilots on Space 1999, not that that has anything to do with it. I really like the shoulder boards for the rank. Good visibility from different angles, good with short sleeves and different collar styles. The Love Boat understood this. The captain and admiral had a different, thicker border to their boards, with some kind of lettering on the forward side.

They set it up earlier by talking about how it was engineered to thrive in literally any environment.

Yeah, they tried to disguise the telegraphing with the joke about eating the seeds as a snack, but I knew when they laid all that out that some giant redwood would be growing somewhere unexpected. It was fine.
 
I don't like the look of the "loops" at the back of the ship. I know it's hard to come up with an original spaceship, but this one doesn't do anything for me.



I thought the colors looked great. The gears badge looks a little "engineery" for helm/nav, but no big deal. IIRC orange was the color for Eagle pilots on Space 1999, not that that has anything to do with it. I really like the shoulder boards for the rank. Good visibility from different angles, good with short sleeves and different collar styles. The Love Boat understood this. The captain and admiral had a different, thicker border to their boards, with some kind of lettering on the forward side.
I read somewhere that the engines on the back have some basis in an acceleration curve. Something where if you look at the waveform for it in 3D, you'll see the curves similar to Orville's engines.

For the uniforms, I did like one detail: when Mercer is with Halsey, his rank is Commander. When he gets to Orville later, he's got the Captain's rank.
 
I don't like the look of the "loops" at the back of the ship. I know it's hard to come up with an original spaceship, but this one doesn't do anything for me.
I liked the loops. It screams, "This is designed this way, because <insert technobabble here>."

----

Speaking of technobabble, about the tree. My post from yesterday, now with more technobabble:

The accelerated growth in the beamed area pushed out the parts that had already grown. The growth was fed by whatever Amazing Process it was that would have allowed the seed to grow in inhospitable environments. At the point that I realized that technobabble could explain it that made more sense than stuff I'd suspended disbelief over in Star Trek, I no longer needed to explain it.

addendum -- But it's kinda fun for me to, nonetheless. One could probably make an argument that the quantum bubble expands to surround anything in reactive contact with what's in the bubble, at least to a certain limit. This is supported by dialog, when after examination of the dead woman scientist (Janice Lee) it was said that she was over 125 instead of just her head, and also supported in how the tree looked (normal) when it broke out of the Krill ship. This sort of hand-wavy-ness, again, isn't more than we've put up with in Star Trek. See for example TNG "The Next Phase" and ask yourself why Geordi and Roe don't just fall through the floors of the ship and then out into space. So, yeah, technobabble, fuck yeah!​
 
It would be so great if The Orville did a parallel universe episode where they cross over to the real TNG universe. Patrick Stewart, Brent Spiner or Jonathan Frakes could guess star. Imagine the possibilities!
 
I appreciate this show having someone drinking soda on the bridge. Most space travel I would think is really boring.

I wonder if Seth read the Star Wreck books from the early 90's. I remeber Lt. "Dacron" kept a can of Dr. Pepper hidden inside his console to drink when he was watching soap operas on his monitor.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top