• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

News Seth MacFarlane’s The Orville

And again, I'll point out, that the original statement was that anything SM creates has that kind of humor. I pretty much negated that.
You "negated" a statement of any comedy by seth macfarlane being crude with examples of things that weren't comedies.
 
You "negated" a statement of any comedy by seth macfarlane being crude with examples of things that weren't comedies.

Your exact quote was:

"If you don't want fart and dick jokes don't watch anything by Seth Mcfarlane"

You didn't say "comedy".
 
And again, I'll point out, that the original statement was that anything SM creates has that kind of humor. I pretty much negated that.

You're just being pedantic for no good reason. Pretty much everyone here knew what the original statement meant.
 
Your exact quote was:

"If you don't want fart and dick jokes don't watch anything by Seth Mcfarlane"

You didn't say "comedy".
Did you know that The Orville was a show with jokes that was written by Seth McFarlane?
Seems like both of you are arguing from an extreme caricature. Real life is neither the lofty TNG style nor the inexplicably FCC-approved pornographic humor of Seth's sandbox.
Saying the word sperm does not make something pornographic. Honestly, that clip is actually pretty tame compared to some of the stuff on his shows. And going outside of McFarlane, I've seen worse stuff on shows like 2 Broke Girls. I'm honestly pretty amazed at times some of the stuff they've gotten away with on that one.
 
Nope. Because like I've learned in the Abrams forums, examples never change anyones minds. They just go on like nothing was posted.

Abrams forums? Aren't you sure we didn't learn that lesson the first time anyone has ever stated a opinion and another person disagreed with it?:)

Jason
 
Did you know that The Orville was a show with jokes that was written by Seth McFarlane?

Saying the word sperm does not make something pornographic. Honestly, that clip is actually pretty tame compared to some of the stuff on his shows. And going outside of McFarlane, I've seen worse stuff on shows like 2 Broke Girls. I'm honestly pretty amazed at times some of the stuff they've gotten away with on that one.
It's not even recent tv that has put out some pretty shocking stuff. I've recently been watching Married with Children and I'm constantly surprised with some of the things they got away with especially at that time.
 
You know reading this thread, I kinda want to see the first episode again. While I wasn't a fan of the dick jokes, I have to admit the stuff they were talking about made them feel like down to earth guys, people you would want to shoot the shit with or something. As the episode went on, these characters felt relate-able.


Yeah...among other things I'm just pretty sick and bored these days with people playing "Space Navy" in media. "Yes sir / No sir / Permission to speak freely sir" blah-de-blah....

Unlike half a century ago we live in a culture where fifty year old men wear cargo pants and sandals to...everything. And then turn on the tube and fetishize actors with sticks up their Method butts mimicking the formality of a military culture that not one in ten of them have ever been within hailing distance of in their lives (well, unless they live below the Mason-Dixon Line. One out of two, then. ;)).

One of the things The Orville has in common with Farscape and Firefly is throwing that stolid attitude out the window. The show can do that in a supposed "25th century military" precisely because it's coming at it all from a comic angle. That has got to be tremendously freeing for everyone involved, and I loved it immediately.
 
Yeah...among other things I'm just pretty sick and bored these days with people playing "Space Navy" in media. "Yes sir / No sir / Permission to speak freely sir" blah-de-blah....

Unlike half a century ago we live in a culture where fifty year old men wear cargo pants and sandals to...everything. And then turn on the tube and fetishize actors with sticks up their Method butts mimicking the formality of a military culture that not one in ten of them have ever been within hailing distance of in their lives (well, unless they live below the Mason-Dixon Line. One out of two, then. ;)).

One of the things The Orville has in common with Farscape and Firefly is throwing that stolid attitude out the window. The show can do that in a supposed "25th century military" precisely because it's coming at it all from a comic angle. That has got to be tremendously freeing for everyone involved, and I loved it immediately.
Well, to be fair, there's more to the Navy than "yes sir / no sir / permission to speak freely, sir." As I mentioned earlier, one of things that appealed to me the most about The Orville was the banter between Malloy and LaMarr because they remind me of the Navy, particularly how actual sailors talk and where their mindsets are at.
 
I liked the pilot. I think though it still needs a little time for the characters to really gel together, but that is a normal problem many pilots have. Some more fine-tuning and time for it to find its stride and we have a winner on our hands. The potential for a really entertaining series is definitely there!

I absolutely love the look of the series though already. The ship, the futuristic cities, the aliens, just everything. Optically this is a really pretty series. The special effects look really great. The series is worth watching just for this already, just for seeing the universe they are creating.
 
Your exact quote was:

"If you don't want fart and dick jokes don't watch anything by Seth Mcfarlane"

You didn't say "comedy".

Sorry, neither I nor anyone else here will take you seriously. You can't possibly believe that you're making a clever argument.
 
Sorry, I just can't take you seriously. You can't possibly believe that you're making a clever argument.

One thing I teach my kids, and because I have to speak live on my toes, is to speak clearly and what you mean. It's as simple as that. I also minored in English. I'm very particular about using words correctly. Sorry if that offends you. Maybe I should have made my argument into a dick joke?

Also, I build sets. So, when someone asks for, or describes something, they have to be particular, or someone falls off a bridge.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top