• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Poll How positive are you about Discovery now?

What is your view on Discovery?

  • Very positive

    Votes: 81 24.1%
  • Positive

    Votes: 90 26.8%
  • Somewhat positive but hesitant

    Votes: 56 16.7%
  • Neutral

    Votes: 24 7.1%
  • Somewhat negative but hopeful

    Votes: 33 9.8%
  • Negative

    Votes: 34 10.1%
  • Very negative

    Votes: 18 5.4%

  • Total voters
    336
the problem with STD is that it is a prequel. You are tied in what you can do with ST canon material. If it was set in the future after voyager, it could have changed the Klingon anyway they want and use any explanation.

TNG was set in the future so, they could do anything they wanted.
TMP changes the Klingons
 
TMP changes the Klingons

and TMP isn't a prequel. It is positive that they didn't use 'Black face make up' on white males and change nothing else than the appearance,

Evolution doesn't change this drastically in a short period of time. and the sarcophagus shows a klingon with hair. STD is revamping everything Klingon that is a bit much if it is in line with the time line
 
and TMP isn't a prequel. It is positive that they didn't use 'Black face make up' on white males and change nothing else than the appearance,

Evolution doesn't change this drastically in a short period of time. and the sarcophagus shows a klingon with hair. STD is revamping everything Klingon that is a bit much if it is in line with the time line
Then explain Kor, Koloth and Kang in DS9.
 
Cosmetic surgery, I'm not even going to look the same 12 months from now, I imagine 200 years of life gives you options on that shit. Especially with magic...sorry, 24th century "technology".
Now I'm picturing the three of them waiting in a surgeon's waiting room, saying they're looking too old and add those ridges the younger Klingons have now!
 
Now I'm picturing the three of them waiting in a surgeon's waiting room, saying they're looking too old and add those ridges the younger Klingons have now!

1. They always looked like that (budget!)
2. Cosmetics
3. They were Augment-born and later when that became extremely unfashionable, changed to look like "normal" Klingons. Which could explain why they lived so long.
 
and TMP isn't a prequel. It is positive that they didn't use 'Black face make up' on white males and change nothing else than the appearance,

Evolution doesn't change this drastically in a short period of time. and the sarcophagus shows a klingon with hair. STD is revamping everything Klingon that is a bit much if it is in line with the time line

It really sounds like they are going to go deeper into the klingons then we have before with having them speak klingon and having multiple houses with different characteristics. I'm excited to see what they do with them
 
Well i can only accept that if we see the Human 'black face' Klingons and Hairy ones in it as house, then it is a deepening of the culture and not just a revamp of Klingon genetics

If it is just cultural characteristics then i would love to see one that is not using a House styled political system Klingons and a more democratic styled Klingons or klingon that doesn't use the honour system But something else.
 
I doubt the smooth headed would be limited to one house since it was a virus that caused the mutation, rather than it being a natural thing.
 
^^^
You mean like every other Star Trek series (including TOS itself) did? ;)

I should clairify I mean they won't do anything drastic like kill one of the TOS main characters or destroy a ship we know exists later.

Nothing that would cause big ripples
 
I should clairify I mean they won't do anything drastic like kill one of the TOS main characters or destroy a ship we know exists later.

Nothing that would cause big ripples

Then they'll spend their time nipping around the edges of TOS. Never doing anything that impacts anything more than the characters we see.

"You see, these are a different house of Klingons, one we didn't see in TOS and will never see again."

"We will be out in an unexplored region of space with these Klingons. So we won't conflict with anything going on."

It will be like TNG, Deep Space Nine and Voyager. They all ran side-by-side, with the occasional wink-nod at each other but had nothing to do with one another beyond that.
 
There was an idea somewhere that ships in the Klingon feudal system tended to be operated by members of the same house. So in some cases, the infection could have spread among a particular house as they didn't deal much with Klingons from other houses.

Kor
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top