• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Do people still believe in Hell?

I don't know if there's a God or Heaven or Hell? I won't know until that time comes. I like surprises.

But it seems like Christianity has been screwing things up since the very beginning. With their religion reading like a manual for controlling the human race written by a dictator.
 
I don't know if there's a God or Heaven or Hell? I won't know until that time comes. I like surprises.

But it seems like Christianity has been screwing things up since the very beginning. With their religion reading like a manual for controlling the human race written by a dictator.
Considering Nicea, it pretty much was.
 
Seriously, I can buy God's allowing it to happen up to a point better than I can buy it being a test. But even that bothers me, because it allows Isaac to be traumatized for the sake of teaching his father a lesson. I understand that there have been midrashim written about the affect on Isaac, but I haven't gone in search of them yet.

I'd advise to hunt down some of those texts about the Akedah, for example some of the stuff in the Jewish Virtual Library. The strength (and sometimes weakness) of Judaism is that the Torah isn't really the be all and end all, and quite a lot of rabbinic thought and discussion of the Torah forms a bigger part of how Jews see it. Often it's kinda like the Marvel Universe - sure, you can just read and enjoy the main comic of the latest crossover event, but there's always other side comics that contain details of the story the main one missed out...
 
One could lament that it has been easy to psychologicalize sin out of existence--leaving folks off the hook. The idea of sin--especially in treating folks badly--can be a useful one.

In theory, he could be there playing shuffleboard with Jesus, Einstein and Judas Iscariot as described in Happy Birthday, Wanda June.

Naw--it's Jesus, Lincoln, and Doctor Zaius

American Christians always playing the victim. :lol: They have had this country by the short hairs for Centuries and still act like they're being oppressed if their grip slips just a little.

Sad that atheists don't get a hell of their own for Salem witch trial leaders, Westboro weirdoes, Hypatia killers.--nicer that way.

You don't get to call yourself a loving god with the idea of infinite punishment for finite sin.
http://www.patheos.com/blogs/daylightatheism/essays/infinite-punishment-for-finite-sins/

Now, there was something interesting in the movie WHAT DREAMS MAY COME.

There, suicides found a way to hell--not because some kind of divine ogre put them there--but because that was their last frame of mind, if you will. The concept of sin as waveform.

If we are part of a simulation, to see which of us deserves to "go on" as in the Riverworld saga of Farmer--then it makes sense to omit more unsavory elements. It just may be that the folks who thump Korans and bibles and whatever are those who actually wind up being "left behind."

We don't need that loose in the multi-verse.
 
Last edited:
I'd advise to hunt down some of those texts about the Akedah, for example some of the stuff in the Jewish Virtual Library. The strength (and sometimes weakness) of Judaism is that the Torah isn't really the be all and end all, and quite a lot of rabbinic thought and discussion of the Torah forms a bigger part of how Jews see it. Often it's kinda like the Marvel Universe - sure, you can just read and enjoy the main comic of the latest crossover event, but there's always other side comics that contain details of the story the main one missed out...
:lol: I like your style! And I definitely intend to look up the midrashim sometime before Rosh Hashana, when I'll have to actually listen to (or at least read) that #%^ story.

Just curious, what movement/denomination do you belong to, if any?
 
:lol: I like your style! And I definitely intend to look up the midrashim sometime before Rosh Hashana, when I'll have to actually listen to (or at least read) that #%^ story.

Just curious, what movement/denomination do you belong to, if any?
He belongs to the denomination of adorable. :adore:
Seriously, when it comes to religion, Lemons is about the smartest guy, and the sweetest, you'll see around here.
 
I don't know much about them but they do tell of a younger Jesus using his powers in public.
Walking on water, turning water into wine, raising the dead, feeding a multitude with very little food, healing the sick, catching huge numbers of fish, becoming radiant in glory, calming the storm, finding a coin in the mouth of a fish, or cursing a fig tree so that it withers? Some of those powers are quite esoteric and specialised.

Apparently, the Infancy Gospel of Thomas reports the following miracles from Jesus' childhood:
  • Water controlled and purified
  • Made birds of clay and brought them to life
  • Resurrected dead playmate Zeno
  • Healed a woodcutter's foot
  • Held water in his cloak
  • Harvested 100 bushels of wheat from a single seed
  • Stretched a board that was short for carpentry
  • Resurrected a teacher he earlier struck down
  • Healed James' viper bite
  • Resurrected a dead child
  • Resurrected a dead man
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracles_of_Jesus#List_of_miracles_found_outside_the_New_Testament
 
Last edited:
I don't know much about them but they do tell of a younger Jesus using his powers in public.

So in actual fact prequels to successful franchises have been with us much longer than the current prequel/reboot mania...

Just curious, what movement/denomination do you belong to, if any?

Conservative Judaism. Although somewhat ironically, many Conservative Jews I know are Democrats...
 
Walking on water, turning water into wine, raising the dead, feeding a multitude with very little food, healing the sick, catching huge numbers of fish, becoming radiant in glory, calming the storm, finding a coin in the mouth of a fish, or cursing a fig tree so that it withers? Some of those powers are quite esoteric and specialised.

Apparently, the Infancy Gospel of Thomas reports the following miracles from Jesus' childhood:
  • Water controlled and purified
  • Made birds of clay and brought them to life
  • Resurrected dead playmate Zeno
  • Healed a woodcutter's foot
  • Held water in his cloak
  • Harvested 100 bushels of wheat from a single seed
  • Stretched a board that was short for carpentry
  • Resurrected a teacher he earlier struck down
  • Healed James' viper bite
  • Resurrected a dead child
  • Resurrected a dead man
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracles_of_Jesus#List_of_miracles_found_outside_the_New_Testament


Well the infancy gospels make him look like Jewish Harry Potter
 
Conservative Judaism.
:bolian:
Although somewhat ironically, many Conservative Jews I know are Democrats...
Doesn't seem particularly ironic to me, because I'm aware that, historically, most US Jews from all movements have been Dems. It's only recently (last few decades) that there's been a substantial number of Jewish Republicans. The synagogue that I am in the process of joining is also Conservative. Part of what I love there is the combination of traditional liturgy and progressive social action.
 
Last edited:
Walking on water, turning water into wine, raising the dead, feeding a multitude with very little food, healing the sick, catching huge numbers of fish, becoming radiant in glory, calming the storm, finding a coin in the mouth of a fish, or cursing a fig tree so that it withers? Some of those powers are quite esoteric and specialised.

Apparently, the Infancy Gospel of Thomas reports the following miracles from Jesus' childhood:
  • Water controlled and purified
  • Made birds of clay and brought them to life
  • Resurrected dead playmate Zeno
  • Healed a woodcutter's foot
  • Held water in his cloak
  • Harvested 100 bushels of wheat from a single seed
  • Stretched a board that was short for carpentry
  • Resurrected a teacher he earlier struck down
  • Healed James' viper bite
  • Resurrected a dead child
  • Resurrected a dead man
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracles_of_Jesus#List_of_miracles_found_outside_the_New_Testament
dJAeCys.jpg
 
Just point out the TOS episodes that are pro-Christianity (ie. "Bread and Circuses").

Nice idea. Probably wouldn't even have worked when he was in one of those moods, though. He simply would have said something to the effect that 'the Holy Spirit clearly had shown him so' and that would have been the end of the discussion for him.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top