• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

False Facts About Star Trek You Always Thought Were True

"Sisko is the first black captain"
"Janeway is the first female captain"
"Number One was dropped from the cast as the world wasn't yet ready for a woman in a command position"
"Spock is the first Vulcan in Starfleet"
 
Shatner had already kissed Barbara Luna in the second season anyway. But that never seems to count for anything in discussions of interracial kisses on TV. :(
As I've mentioned previously, Barbara Luna is of Italian, Hungarian, Spanish, Portuguese and Filipino heritage. When Americans think "interracial," it's almost always in terms of white/black or white/Asian.

It just shows how nebulous and indefinable the whole concept of "race" is anyway.
 
As I've mentioned previously, Barbara Luna is of Italian, Hungarian, Spanish, Portuguese and Filipino heritage. When Americans think "interracial," it's almost always in terms of white/black or white/Asian.

It just shows how nebulous and indefinable the whole concept of "race" is anyway.
In a feature article from before TOS, Luna was described as Hungarian-Filipino. So that's how the public saw her at the time. Being a Eurasian ethnic mixture myself, I recall almost never seeing anyone like me on TV when I was little. I felt like we didn't exist... then in TOS reruns I saw Barbara Luna as Marlena. :luvlove:
And there was Kwai Chang Caine in "Kung Fu," but of course the actor was full Caucasian. :lol:

Kor
 
When Americans think "interracial," it's almost always in terms of white/black or white/Asian.
If a Arab kissed a Native American, that would be a "inter-racial" kiss.

Black/White isn't by far the only definition of inter-racial, I doubt most Americans consider it so.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kor
I think NuKirk represents the popular conception of ShatKirk. He's having a conversation, a girl walks by, and he's like "Dayyummn, lookit that ayzzz"

Shatkirk had a failed love life. He kept falling in love but always put his duty first. He had to leave and go on to the next mission. Shatkirk was also mostly a gentleman. I could never see him two-timing anyone. And he doesn't seem the type to ever "kiss & tell."
 
I think NuKirk represents the popular conception of ShatKirk. He's having a conversation, a girl walks by, and he's like "Dayyummn, lookit that ayzzz"

Shatkirk had a failed love life. He kept falling in love but always put his duty first. He had to leave and go on to the next mission. Shatkirk was also mostly a gentleman. I could never see him two-timing anyone. And he doesn't seem the type to ever "kiss & tell."
Yes. I like the KT Kirk, but in ST09 and STID, he really embodies the public misconception of Kirk rather than how Kirk actually behaved in TOS.

EDIT: But to be fair, KT Kirk is significantly younger and less experienced in general than his TOS counterpart.
 
NuKirk also has the virtue of being relate-able to today's audiences as a "troubled" and "damaged" young person, which could increase the tendency toward reckless behavior.

Kor
 
NuKirk also has the virtue of being relate-able to today's audiences as a "troubled" and "damaged" young person, which could increase the tendency toward reckless behavior.

Kor
Which is why I found him so compelling.
 
Which is why I found him so compelling.
Yes, I found that it made him more like a real person and less "larger than life."

Pike described him as "the only genius-level repeat offender in the mid-west." Some fans complained about that aspect of NuKirk's character, as if Kirk absolutely had to be the "stack of book with legs" described in WNMHGB instead of going around getting in trouble. But I personally knew guys just like that in school... absolutely brilliant, but didn't get the right opportunities for that brilliance to be expressed, as they had rough upbringings and fell into the wrong crowd and kept getting into trouble. NuKirk happened to finally get the right opportunity with Starfleet. I can only hope the guys I knew eventually found such positive opportunities instead of winding up in jail.

Kor
 
Who said it's 25%? That sounds like exactly the kind of exaggeration I'm referring to.

It was in the video, I'm quoting directly, apparently that's what they call "not a horn dog"

To be fair, I'm not going to do a head count on the episodes.
 
Remember young Picard? He was super reckless.

Sadly, it cost him his hair.

I found him annoying too. My larger point is that I find him very real and identifiable as a person.

He's a hero who gets a second chance, instead of being given everything. That's what's appealing about him - gives him maybe more empathy for others who've messed up - makes it believable that he'd pay it forward.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kor
Sadly, it cost him his hair.



He's a hero who gets a second chance, instead of being given everything. That's what's appealing about him - gives him maybe more empathy for others who've messed up - makes it believable that he'd pay it forward.

Funny I saw it this way, he got everything because he was Pike's boy, even a third chance in STID. Spock gets moved to another ship, Kirk gets another go of the Enterprise. Sorry smacks of Terran privilege to me.
The end of ST09 gives the impression Kirk saved Enterprise, Earth and the Federation all by himself. Where were Spock's and Sulu's medal?
 
Last edited:
Wouldn't you like to have someone who'll fight for you and believe in you when nobody else would? Yeah, eventually they have to let you fly and make your own mistakes and face the consequences, but a leg-up at the right time can make a big difference between languishing and soaring.
Where were Spock's and Sulu's medal?
They received them afterwards or before; but the movie was about how Kirk got the Enterprise and surrounded himself with his crew family. It's the triumphant moment all were waiting for.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top