Like I said, I find it to be a very accurate depiction of the original character.Okay, all kidding aside, in Legends, Thrawn made plenty of magical deductions from paintings. The farther down you go, the more magical they become, to the point where he was more or less a Mary Sue of observation and planning. Having seen the episode in question, Thrawn's actions and chains of reasoning are actually a lot more rational than some of the stuff he was doing in Legends.
I completely disagree. Thrawn was never a "Mary Sue" character, and his deductions made more sense then the clips I've seen of the Rebels "Thrawn". But, you seem to have your own thoughts about Thrawn that seem unflattering, so it could be we just have opinions about the character that are too different. I think he's the single greatest villain in the Star Wars series. That's my basis for judging what Rebels has done to him. If someone was...less then impressed, lets say, by the original version, then they're coming at the adaptation from a completely different way. I judge it as a huge fan of the original character.
The show is also resolving a lot of unanswered questions left over from The Clone Wars.
If by answer questions, you mean stuff like killing off fan favorite characters and showing what the daughter of an obscure character from season 1 are doing, I guessthey are. It also makes several supporting characters (Rex and friends) into complete idiots. Oh, and the villain brought back to life because the writers are morons is now interacting with Angsty Aladdin. Besides that, not much connection, and outside of the death and (arguably) the returning villain, nothing important. To be fair, TCW didn't really leave any unanswered questions outside of the location and final fates of some characters.
A few of the episodes tie into the Death Star's construction, making them part of the build-up to Rogue One that can be picked out of the franchise ("The Honorable Ones" also retroactively foreshadows Vader's trip to Geonosis in the Darth Vader comic series). The Servants of the Empire series has massive ties to Rebels, with Zare Leonis appearing in a couple Rebels episodes (that advance his book's story), and the Ghost's crew appearing in the final novel. Lothal has factored into the Adventures in Wild Space series. Lothal's Imperial Academy is mentioned in Lost Stars. Ezra Bridger's role in sending off the message in "A Call to Action" was referred to in the Beware the Dark Side! novelization of ROTJ. The novel Ahsoka has ties to the series with the Inquisitors becoming involved (as well as acting as an origin story for some bits of the TV show). Hondo Onaka's appearance on Freemaker Adventures owed more to his Rebels apperances than his Clone Wars ones (if I recall correctly). The Lasat massacre even slipped into the Legends book Imperial Handbook!
On top of that, there have been several tie-in books and series; There was the New Dawn prequel novel (which also affected some of the short stories in that Rise of the Empire omnibus). Kanan had a comic series. Ezra starred in his own book, Ezra's Gamble. There have been replica journals for both Sabine and Ezra, a la the Survival Guide and Flight Log tie-ins Rey and Poe got. There's an official magazine with short comic stories. The entirety of season one has been novelized.
Beyond print, part of Star Wars's online materials included an entire Holonet "news" broadcast that tied into the show. Some of the Rebels characters have been given action figures in the Star Wars Black toy line. Rebels characters were among the very few Star Wars characters to be represented in the late Disney Infinity video game and got their own DLC bonus content for the Lego Star Wars: The Force Awakens game (not to mention their own Lego toys).
So, no, it's actually having a pretty big impact for a couple-years-old show and has had a stronger reception from the fanbase than Clone Wars did when it first started out.
Most of that stuff you mentioned is little kid books and reference material. I think a few of the books you mentioned are literally the 3-5 year old "first time reader" books. Servants of the Empire I had to look up, and that "massively connected to Rebels" book series is literally for 8-9 years olds. It doesn't really count, no important SW stuff is going to be done in books for kids, especially 10 and under stuff. The comics don't count if they're actually designed as a tie in to Rebels (like the Kanan comic), and obviously the Rebels tie in novel A New Dawn has a connection to the show. Toys and video games don't count, almost every SW character gets a action figure eventually (to a ridiculous degree), and most end up in the Lego Star Wars games. Also, you're really stretching with the Death Star stuff. Tarkin effects that more. The Darth Vader comic connection I don't think is even remotely an actual thing.
Libel is never a valid tool for reasoning, debate, or discussion.
I think calling into question a person's motivation for saying what they said, and talking about how truthful they're being, is a valid discussiontool. Also, I didn't libel anyone. I was, admittedly, insulting people while legitimately questioning their ability/trustworthiness, that's different then libel (libel is stuff you get sued for and doesn't apply to conversations like this, you can insult someone as much as you want without it being "libel").
Has it ever occurred to you that A). he might be a better judge of the accuracy of Rebels Thrawn than any of us are and B.) that he could be conceivably telling the truth as he sees it?
I've seen Thrawn in Rebels. Zahn is either lying, or is very easily impressed. I'd say its probably the first one, but as 65 year old he'd probably be more used to cartoons from the 50s-60s, so Rebels might seem impressive if that's the bar Zahn uses to judge a cartoon and its characters.
Last edited: