• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Shannara Chronicles

Sparkle Fabulosa

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
I'm excited (somewhat) but also a little apprehensive. I don't care for the post-apocalyptic genre but I'll give it a try.


[yt]https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XDR8b1SpoSc[/yt]
 
I read the original trilogy 30 years ago. I'd forgotten those were in a post-apocalyptic world.

I do remember liking the books a great deal.
 
I read the books too and am curious. I'm going to watch just to see what they do with the story.
 
I'm reading the book right now and so far I'm enjoying, and it's definitely making me look forward to the show. I was little surprised that I'm 4 or 5 chapters into it and there is no sign of the three main characters they've been promoting for the show. I wonder if they'll change that for the show, because that could be at least one or two episodes based of off how these kinds of adaptations have gone in the past, and I find it hard to believe they'd wait that long to introduce the main heroes.
 
I'm reading the book right now and so far I'm enjoying, and it's definitely making me look forward to the show. I was little surprised that I'm 4 or 5 chapters into it and there is no sign of the three main characters they've been promoting for the show. I wonder if they'll change that for the show, because that could be at least one or two episodes based of off how these kinds of adaptations have gone in the past, and I find it hard to believe they'd wait that long to introduce the main heroes.

The TV series is adapting the second book The Elfstones Of Shannara not the first.
 
I'm excited (somewhat) but also a little apprehensive. I don't care for the post-apocalyptic genre but I'll give it a try.

I gather it's not really a post-apocalyptic story in the Mad Max or Walking Dead vein, more a Tolkien-knockoff high-fantasy series in which the post-apocalyptic nature of the fantasy world is an incidental detail. Tolkien claimed that Middle-Earth was the distant past of our world, so Brooks reversed that and made Shannara a distant future.
 
Not to forget there have been prequels to Sword written, at least one of them dealing with the war/apocalypse itself.

Many shows like this end up being an amalgamation of storylines.

I haven't re-read the books since the 80's, so I can go in without too many expectations.
 
Christopher, I've never seen either of them. It's more The Hunger Games-type stuff I don't like. The fact that this is set in the future but yet in a Middle Ages world, makes me hopeful.
 
I am apprehensive as well, mostly because of the network it is on. It reminds me of The 100 and Revolution where somehow trendy clothes, washing machines and shampoo all survived the apocalypse.
 
I am apprehensive as well, mostly because of the network it is on. It reminds me of The 100 and Revolution where somehow trendy clothes, washing machines and shampoo all survived the apocalypse.

I am giving it a try simply because MTV is the same network bringing us Teen Wolf, which is a surprisingly good show. It keeps the teen angst to a minimum. I am hoping the same approach is taken here.
 
I made it through the first hour.

While it's visually stunning! My eyes hurt from all the pretty, and I don't mean the actors.

It's not for me.

But I'm curious to see what everyone else thought of it.
 
The first hour was very much "popular kids at the prom". The whole thing seemed to drag on forever.(and not in a good way) I found myself amazed by how much time was left each time I hit fastfoward to dvr through the commercials.
 
I love the novels and was quite excited for the series (even if I would've personally picked a different novel than Elfstones to adapt), and it didn't disappoint.

A few observations/notes on the series:
* The creators changed the timeline of events so that the War of the Races took place 30 years before the events of the series rather than 50 years earlier as in the novel

* In the series, Wil is the SON of Shea Ohmsford (the protagonist of the novel The Sword of Shannara) rather than his GRANDSON as in the Elfstones novel

* The creators of the series deliberately chose to more overtly emphasize the fact that the Four Lands are a post-Apocalyptic version of Earth (the post-Apocalyptic element is present in the early novels in the series, including Elfstones, but as more of a historical background note)

* Manu Bennett's Allanon is very different, characterization-wise, than his literary counterpart

* The design of the Druid's Keep - Paranor - is much different than I was expecting, but is pretty neat nonetheless

* The design of the Ellcrys is really beautiful, and I wish we'd seen more of it in its healthy state

* I have a sneaking suspicion that Allanon's sword is meant to be the Sword of Shannara, and the collapsible/telescopic design they came up with is pretty cool
 
Last edited:
We'll see how much they just whitewash over the Sword, though. Flick mentioned that Shea used the elfstones and they caused him problems, may be that they're retconning those in place of the Sword as they skip the first book.
 
I'm only up through the moment where Will and the elf princess leave on their respective quests. I'm not too engaged with this so far. The writing is clunky, with characters delivering painfully expository lines to introduce themselves ("As your best friend and servant, I'm here to help" or "As king, it is my honor to..."). The casting of the leads is far too whitebread in more ways than one -- nice to look at, kind of boring to watch.

Also, how is it that the crowd of spectators didn't realize the princess was female until they took her blindfold off? Were they somehow unable to see her below the neck? Her figure isn't that boyish.

Also, judging from King John Rhys-Davies's speech, this is evidently thousands of years post-apocalypse at least -- maybe much longer, to allow the species differentiation of human descendants. So there's no way any ruins of our metal skyscrapers and Space Needles would survive aboveground. They would've been long since eroded away or buried in sediment. The only remaining visible ruins would be things like the Pyramids or maybe some broken dams. Granted, of course, this is a future where magic somehow exists, so it's not exactly trying for realism.
 
You can watch the 2-hour premier for free on both YouTube and iTunes.

Episodes 3 & 4 are now available to watch on MTV's website with cable authentication, or to download from iTunes after purchasing the season pass.
 
Yeah, I know they wanted to keep visual cues to remind us that it was our future, but it needs to be a few thousand years in the future, so definitely too much. Scene with Flick and Wil had a rusted out car sitting there, or at least a door in decent shape, with window glass intact. It was a catastrophe of the order that it physically reshaped the land, shouldn't be too much recognizable after that sort of thing plus thousands of years drift as well. I liked that the book series just kinda hints at a few bits of rusted out skyscraper or whatnot here and there, but mostly treats the old world as just a memory with a few bits clinging on here and there.

Until they get later into the series and they deal with corrupted mechanical things, AI gone rogue, that sorta stuff. Other thing that makes the car being there somewhat silly, as the global disaster/war/whatever was still decently in our future, because we don't yet have the needed tech.

Minor nit, but thought they overdid the remnants of the old world. Don't need a car laying around, or a space needle in decent shape, just use the opening to show us everything blew up and this is what came out of the ashes.

I've got a 1 year old at home, so only managed to stay up for the opening 30 min or so; will check out the rest tonight...
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top