• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Wars Past EU Officially Decanonized by Lucasfilm

Although I'm not a Canon head either, I am guessing that this means LFL had also reversed its decision on the status of The Force Unleashed video games. ... at least the first TFU game which I know was designated as official Canon in the SW universe. The only SW video game to have that distinction.

Ah well, it's not like it bothers me. I don't want the more film writers to be constrained by EU materials or extraneous stuff either. The EU is what it is. ... and for me the EU is a PU. (Parallel universe. ... not a stinker :) )
 
Placing the A-wings in Rebels is big departure from the Old EU where the A-wings were created in response to the X and Y-wings lack of straight line speed that led to the Rebels (almost) losing at the Battle of Yavin.
 
The A-Wings were used back in the '80s Droids cartoons (which were chronologically set even prior to Rebels), so this isn't entirely inconsistent with what's gone before, to be sure. It was the later '90s EU that actually deviated from this, to a certain extent.
 
Having the A-Wings appear in Rebels does raise a question: If the A-wings are the fastest starfighter in the Rebel fleet why weren't they used against the Death Star?
 
Having the A-Wings appear in Rebels does raise a question: If the A-wings are the fastest starfighter in the Rebel fleet why weren't they used against the Death Star?
Maybe the A-Wings in Rebels are only just new and not numerous yet. Or maybe the A-Wings do not yet have that kind of speed.
 
Having the A-Wings appear in Rebels does raise a question: If the A-wings are the fastest starfighter in the Rebel fleet why weren't they used against the Death Star?

Because they weren't stationed on Yavin IV?

That may have been their main base of operations but I don't think anyone believes those two squadrons of fighters were the sum-total of the Alliance's military assets.
If nothing else then all those medical frigates, Mon Cal cruisers and blockade runners scattered across the galaxy would need some fighter support and A-Wings seem best suited for interception.
 
Having the A-Wings appear in Rebels does raise a question: If the A-wings are the fastest starfighter in the Rebel fleet why weren't they used against the Death Star?
Maybe the A-Wings in Rebels are only just new and not numerous yet. Or maybe the A-Wings do not yet have that kind of speed.

It is also possible that the Rebels thought their attack would be so quick and unexpected that they wouldn't have to worry about dealing with opposing TIE fighters.

The idea that A-wings aren't as fast is also a reasonable supposition.
 
Although I'm not a Canon head either, I am guessing that this means LFL had also reversed its decision on the status of The Force Unleashed video games. ... at least the first TFU game which I know was designated as official Canon in the SW universe. The only SW video game to have that distinction.

The Force Unleashed was at the same level of canon as Knights of the Old Republic and Battlefront, as well as the various novels. They were all officially canon at C-level, below the films and The Clone Wars.
 
Having the A-Wings appear in Rebels does raise a question: If the A-wings are the fastest starfighter in the Rebel fleet why weren't they used against the Death Star?

Because they weren't stationed on Yavin IV?

Simplest answer is the best.

Yavin base only had X-Wings and Y-Wings, while the A-Wings and various other ships were elsewhere.
 
Having the A-Wings appear in Rebels does raise a question: If the A-wings are the fastest starfighter in the Rebel fleet why weren't they used against the Death Star?

Because they weren't stationed on Yavin IV?

Simplest answer is the best.

Yavin base only had X-Wings and Y-Wings, while the A-Wings and various other ships were elsewhere.
Return of the Jedi showed that Leia, Han and Luke weren't really leaders in the Rebellion. Mon Mothma and her people were running the whole thing and they were just part of that. It's possible that they were the underfunded part of the Rebellion and just scrapping by with what they could get.
 
The A-Wing (lack of armaments and shielding) and B-Wings (too big) are probably the worst fighter classes for going up against the Death Star and its defensive scream. There is a reason the X-Wing was the workhorse of the rebellion.
 
It's probably still a cell-thing as well. There SHOULD have been larger transport ships stationed on Yavin, but they are neither seen nor mentioned. OTOH, nor is evacuation mentioned as a real option, so perhaps they were taking the Death Star on with whatever ships they had on hand while a bunch of transports and cruisers (and A-Wings!) were off on some other mission.

Mark
 
The Force Unleashed was at the same level of canon as Knights of the Old Republic and Battlefront, as well as the various novels. They were all officially canon at C-level, below the films and The Clone Wars.

You have no idea how silly this sounds to me.
 
We know the B-wing will show itself in Rebels as well just from the season two trailer, though it may be a prototype (it is painted in orange similar to the X-1 rocket plane, and Lucasfilm loves doing homages to airplanes.) The B-wing may have appeared in Droids as well in the 80s.

Also the weapon pod on the other end of the fighter looks like it could be manned in Rebels, while it isn't normally.
 
Although I'm not a Canon head either, I am guessing that this means LFL had also reversed its decision on the status of The Force Unleashed video games. ... at least the first TFU game which I know was designated as official Canon in the SW universe. The only SW video game to have that distinction.

The Force Unleashed was at the same level of canon as Knights of the Old Republic and Battlefront, as well as the various novels. They were all officially canon at C-level, below the films and The Clone Wars.

Not quite. From the way they promoted it, it seems that The Force Unleashed game was given a status more akin to the whole 'Shadows of the Empire' multimedia project. Mostly because Lucas was said to have had "some" input at the conceptual phase.
But that's all just marketing. As far as I'm aware nothing else canon has ever made reference to the characters or events and Rebels seems set to outright contradict the whole thing sooner or later.

Mind you, as I've often said that whole tiered canon system was utterly meaningless at best. Mostly it only seemed to serve to keep the consumers happy knowing that their comics and games "mattered" in some abstract way.

Personally, it never bothered me that Kyle Katarn or Ace Azzameen might not "really" exist as far as the movies were concerned.

Just in the early days of reading the Star Wars novels & Dark Horse comics it became quickly evident that the projects often had only a passing relation to one another with each author more or less doing their own thing.
I remember reading the Zahn Trilogy followed by Dark Empire (that went unfinished for years seemingly) and then the Academy trilogy and being at a loss as to how they even related. I mean sure, they do reference the previous entries, but then go off on massive tangents, totally redefining characters and often ditching the previous author's supporting cast in favor of their own, who's were in turn also ditched by the next guy and so on.
It wasn't until the X-Wing novels that things started to get at least a little coherent, but that's also when the mediocrity began to set in.
Because they weren't stationed on Yavin IV?

Simplest answer is the best.

Yavin base only had X-Wings and Y-Wings, while the A-Wings and various other ships were elsewhere.
Return of the Jedi showed that Leia, Han and Luke weren't really leaders in the Rebellion. Mon Mothma and her people were running the whole thing and they were just part of that. It's possible that they were the underfunded part of the Rebellion and just scrapping by with what they could get.

Leia at least was clearly a leader in the rebellion as we saw in both ANH and TESB. Luke on the other had certainly became a leadership figure in the sense that he held the rank of commander and led a squadron. I think it's fair to assume that both of them took a leave of absence during the year or so they spent trying to get Han back, which accounts for why Leia wasn't involved in the planning of the Endor mission.

I think it's fair to assume that Mon Mothma's absence in ANH probably has something to do with the senate having recently been dissolved. Odds are she was either arrested and later broken out by the Alliance, or already on the run when Alderaan was destroyed. By TESB I would speculate that she was probably either with the fleet or being smuggled from system to system, talking to wavering planetary leaders and recruiting worlds into the Alliance.
 
Wasn't Shadows of the Empire supposed to be canon too - a film project with all the tie-in novels, comics, toys, games, a soundtrack C.D. etc. but without the actual film.

Binned too I presume ?
 
Most older projects are binned until farther notice. They might get back in depending on the whims of the various authors and marketing people.

Leia seems to be a top official and operative, but also seems to be one of their combat commander given her running things at Echo Base on Hoth. Mon Mothma would be more a leader of the shadow government that the Alliance has in place...sort of the Republic in exile. She could have been on Hoth as well, but gotten out with one of the transports. Or Echo Base was not as important as we generally assume it to be. It just is the base where our heroes went. Leia's cell.
 
Insane clones with double vowels in their names... best idea ever to come out of the SW EU.

Kor
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top