• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What if "Call to arms - Sacrifice of angels" was a movie?

Inactive-Shapeshifter

Lieutenant Commander
Red Shirt
So, it would appear as we will have to wait a little more to get DS9 on Blu-ray, so, i though about making something new myself. I was thinking about re-edit the occupation arc in one 2 or more hours movie, in widescreen and with a little touch on the color correction.

So... you people think it could worth the try? :)
 
They are,perhaps, Trek's best run of episodes. I think it would be difficult to bring it all down to 2 hrs, even if you jettison the entirety of Sons and Daughters.
 
Oh man, the widescreen would look so much better if you were upping it from bluray. :( But yes, I would watch it! I'd love to take a crack at it myself, but these days time is the fire in which I burn. ;)
 
Nice idea. :) I've been tempted to try something like this with TV shows with strong story arcs in the past, do a sort of 'Renegade Edit' that crams as much of a major arc into a movie-length as possible...
 
A great idea. To get it to fit, you could easily omit most of A Time to Rocks and Daughters. There's a lot of fat there that would disrupt the narrative.
 
Don't forget you have plenty of episodes prior to piece together a nice little prologue too! :)
 
Good luck editing around/cropping the on-screen credits of each episode. :)
 
A great idea. To get it to fit, you could easily omit most of A Time to Rocks and Daughters. There's a lot of fat there that would disrupt the narrative.

There's fat in Rocks and Shoals? The motivations of significant characters are defined by that one episode.
 
I did say "most." As it is, the important bits of Rocks and Shoals could easily be cut down to less than five minutes.
 
Wouldn't that be like a 5 hour long movie. Even if you did take out Sons and Daughters, that is still really long.
 
I'd like to see a DS9 movie edited. I say go for it Shapeshifter.

Nice idea. :) I've been tempted to try something like this with TV shows with strong story arcs in the past, do a sort of 'Renegade Edit' that crams as much of a major arc into a movie-length as possible...

I was tempted too but decided not to care until DS9 is on bluray as well.

Good luck editing around/cropping the on-screen credits of each episode. :)

Nothing zooming and cropping wont fix. (See signature)

Wouldn't that be like a 5 hour long movie. Even if you did take out Sons and Daughters, that is still really long.

It's doable.
 
Good luck editing around/cropping the on-screen credits of each episode. :)
Nothing zooming and cropping wont fix. (See signature)
It can be tough on certain episodes. Some of it won't come out without actually removing content. I'm not saying it can't be done, I'm just saying good luck. It can be tough to do without the end result looking bad.
 
Don't forget you have plenty of episodes prior to piece together a nice little prologue too! :)

That would be nice! The only problem is that the uniform colors would change. :)

You'll probably have slight hair style changes within your movie too. But none of that will bother me. If you like the prologue idea, you can do a desaturated or close to desaturated effect to differentiate those scenes from the bulk of your movie. Just a suggestion! :bolian:

Good luck editing around/cropping the on-screen credits of each episode. :)
Nothing zooming and cropping wont fix. (See signature)
It can be tough on certain episodes. Some of it won't come out without actually removing content. I'm not saying it can't be done, I'm just saying good luck. It can be tough to do without the end result looking bad.

This. Ideally, you'll be lucky and most of those parts can be edited out. Since all we have is the DVD version, and then you have to rip it in order to edit it, and then you have to export it to some sort of compressed file to upload it where it will be compressed once again, the scaling will look really bad. But on top of that, you will already be scaling for widescreen. And then for the scenes with credits, you'll be doing even more scaling. Yuck. I did a re-edit of the first episode. Initially, I was planning to make a widescreen version. But it was those credits over the beginning scenes that changed my mind. I needed at least a couple of those scenes and it looked like poop when I did all of that scaling. So I reluctantly went with 4:3.

If you're planning to do the opening credits in widescreen, I've done that too. In addition to scaling you'll have to do some clever panning up and down between credits since the credits appear both at the top and bottom of the screen - and you'll have to do it after the credits go off the screen to make it less noticeable. But it will be noticeable regardless. It's sort of the opposite of pan and scan. :) The cool part is you get some really nice close-ups of the station that way. Too bad it's scaled up from SD though.

Having said all of that, I'll happily watch it anyway! Have fun!
 
Thanks a lot for the support and suggestions people! :)

One thing tough, i recently noticed that After Effects don't support the output video files from the episodes, with, in my case, is mkv (and several other formats i've experimented with).

I've downloaded MKV2Vob but it mixes the audio track with the video and After Effects can't separate, the result is a video without audio track.

The supported formats lose a lot of quality! Any suggestions?
 
They are,perhaps, Trek's best run of episodes. I think it would be difficult to bring it all down to 2 hrs, even if you jettison the entirety of Sons and Daughters.

I agree that Sons and Daughters doesn't belong there. What were they thinking?

Another problem with this is that they don't show Sisko's rescue from the planet! It's going to be a hard job to make sense of that wen i try to join the episodes....
 
^I haven't seen this arch in some time but it's not possible to leave out that planet completely?

...One thing tough, i recently noticed that After Effects don't support the output video files from the episodes, with, in my case, is mkv (and several other formats i've experimented with).

AVS Video Converter can convert them to AVI files with not much loss.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top