• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Year One: Feh

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
Year One

Rated PG-13 for crude and sexual content throughout, brief strong language and comic violence.

My Grade: C

-----------

Year One, Life of Brian or History of the World it is not and it very much could've been. Harold Ramis is capable of it.

But in this movie he succumbs to mainstream poop, sex, and dick humor.

Year One chronociles the adventures of "hunter" Zed, played by Jack Black, and "gatherer" Oh, played by Michael Cera (both play their "usual characters.") Zed gets a piece of fruit from the Tree of Konwledge of Good and Evil and takes a bite in a desire to become a better hunter and even leader of his tribe. He is eventualy cast out after eating the Forbidden Fruit and Oh tags along.

Together they stumble through various Biblical tales and meet various Biblical figures, they meet Cain and set-off his battle-to-the-death with Abel, run into Abraham when he decides to start circumcising people ("This look is going to catch on, trust me.") and end up in Sodom ("What happens in Sodom, stays in Sodom.") driving them through most of this journey is to save two women from their old tribe who've been sold as slaves.

Year One works when it's being this Biblical parodlical farce. It's that kind of stuff Harold Ramis is pretty good at.

It's less good when it's making jokes about poop, farts, and having Cera's character being forced to give an oil-massage to a Sodom priest.

If they had stuck to Biblical tales jokes this movie would've been a whole lot better as these moments are when the movie shines and certainly could've done a lot more with them. (They coud've ran into the Good Samaritan, for example.)

This movie isn't worth seeing in the theaters and *might* be worth a rental. I really wonder what made Harold Ramis so suddenly obsessed with poop. :(

I will say though, that Olivia Wilde -as a Sodom princess- .... :drool:
 
Would an R rating have helped it?

No, but frankly I'm sort-of surprised it isn't R-rated.

A lot less toilet and sex humor (though I guess some sex humor is expected when talking about Sodom) and a lot more Bible Fable humor would've helped this movie. That's where some of the best stuff is in this movie.

Anyone can do jokes about eating poop or sticking things in asses. It takes a bit more to make jokes about Bible tales like Cain's slaying of Abel.
 
I had been considering seeing this, Michael Cera seemed funnily out-of-place in the old days (like Woody Allen maybe), but I kind of suspected it might be a dud. Might still be worth a couple of cheap laughs sometime...
 
Hopefully Harold Ramis hasn't lost his touch, especially if he's directing Ghostbusters III.
 
What a colossal waste of talent all around.

One of the worst movies I've seen in a long time. I'm sitting there ... "Okay, it'll be funny soon. Soon ... I know it'll get going ... I know that ... it's over?"

I'm SO tired of spoken subtext where instead of letting a reaction do the job, they start TALKING about it with faux rationalism and calm, thinking they're in the league of Woody Allen dialogue.

--Ted
 
I've never seen a Woody Allen movie I liked, I'll be honest. I don't hate every one I've seen, but I'll tell you that if he himself is acting in the movie I'm likely to hate it just a little bit more.... Just one of those things I'll never "get" I guess.

I was excited for Year One, and I like Black and Cera, but the reviews have been terrible. If you're desperate for a comedy this weekend go see The Hangover again, you'll probably laugh a lot more.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top