• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

WOW! signal - Likely just a comet and/or its hydrogen cloud

B.J.

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
I've always thought the WOW! signal was a natural phenomenon, although I didn't expect its likely origin to be a comet.

http://planetary-science.org/research/the-wow-signal/
ABSTRACT
In 2016, the Center for Planetary Science proposed a hypothesis arguing a comet and/or its hydrogen cloud were a strong candidate for the source of the “Wow!” Signal. From 27 November 2016 to 24 February 2017, the Center for Planetary Science conducted 200 observations in the radio spectrum to validate the hypothesis. The investigation discovered that comet 266/P Christensen emitted a radio signal at 1420.25 MHz. All radio emissions detected were within 1° (60 arcminutes) of the known celestial coordinates of the comet as it transited the neighborhood of the “Wow!” Signal. During observations of the comet, a series of experiments determined that known celestial sources at 1420 MHz (i.e., pulsars and/or active galactic nuclei) were not within 15° of comet 266/P Christensen. To dismiss the source of the signal as emission from comet 266/P Christensen, the position of the 10-meter radio telescope was moved 1° (60 arcminutes) away from comet 266/P Christensen. During this experiment, the 1420.25 MHz signal disappeared. When the radio telescope was repositioned back to comet 266/P Christensen, a radio signal at 1420.25 MHz reappeared. Furthermore, to determine if comets other than comet 266/P Christensen emit a radio signal at 1420 MHz, we observed three comets that were selected randomly from the JPL Small Bodies database: P/2013 EW90 (Tenagra), P/2016 J1-A (PANSTARRS), and 237P/LINEAR. During observations of these comets, we detected a radio signal at 1420 MHz. The results of this investigation, therefore, conclude that cometary spectra are detectable at 1420 MHz and, more importantly, that the 1977 “Wow!” Signal was a natural phenomenon from a Solar System body.
 
I never thought it was a signal from ET, but I would have never thought they'd find it's origin in our solar system. I thought they'd find something further into deep space. As to discovering life out there, we'll probably never knowingly intercept their signals and interpret them as alien signals, unless it's totally obvious like a pattern in the transmission. Take a WWII radioman, and his equipment back then, and send him a scrambled signal from a modern satellite and he'll just think it's static. We aren't going to interpret alien broadcasts or probably even know if we receive one.

We'll find ET by spectrographic analysis of the atmosphere on their planet long before we can ever listen to them, or even know HOW to listen.
 
And so if that's not an ET signal, where are the ET signals which we should be picking? (That's a rhetorical question.) Did we just run out of candidates for the job?
 
Some further study:
https://interestingengineering.com/...omer-may-have-pinpointed-alien-signals-origin

"I found specifically one sun-like star," Caballero said, referring to a star called 2MASS 19281982-2640123 about 1,800 light-years away that has a temperature, diameter, and luminosity that strongly resembles the Sun.

https://phys.org/news/2022-06-weeks-wow.html
In this work, the authors argue that the source could be some kind of stochastic repeater.
Several years ago it was proposed that the signal might have been caused by comets that were near the observed area of the sky, but this has since been disproven.

More
https://www.inverse.com/science/using-math-to-tackle-a-45-year-old-extraterrestrial-mystery
 
Last edited:
And so if that's not an ET signal, where are the ET signals which we should be picking? (That's a rhetorical question.) Did we just run out of candidates for the job?
I have been of the opinion for years that we fall into the range of some of the first, not necessarily THE first civilizations to achieve spaceflight. The universe is still very young. We probably are not the only other civilization out there to reach this point, but within our own galaxy, I think we would have found some evidence if there'd been anyone else who'd been around for a million years or so.

If by some incredible odds there's another civilization just a few thousand years near our development stage, we would never have found on contact, anyway, most likely. I don't take this as a negative at all. The galaxy shows every sign of being unclaimed real estate, and humanity charts its course in the future, it may very well needs much of it to engineer on a galactic or even inter-galactic scale for how it will spend the rest of near-eternity. They might find it optimum to abort any planetary biomes that are on the verge of developing sentient life capable of offering a challenge or else pick and choose long term partners for the future, which is something I would not really understand, but have to leave room for in my head.

Whether culling the chances for other worlds to create competitors would be morally wrong, I cannot say. But anthropic principle aside, it hasn't happened to us (yet), which leaves us either alone or well in the running to be so.


To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
as usual Isaac Arthur sums it up far better than I could have.
 
Robert Gray, who wrote a book on the Wow! signal passed away recently
https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2023/01/19/an-appreciation-of-setis-robert-gray-1948-2021/

He seemed to think a leak from power beaming may have been a candidate:

The power beaming explanation for the Wow! accounts for all four of the Wow! parameters: the power density received, the duration of the signal, its frequency, and the reason why the Wow! has not occurred again. The Wow! power beam leakage hypothesis gets stronger the longer that listening for the Wow! to recur doesn’t observe it repeat.

Other thoughts
http://www.bigear.org/Wow30th/wow30th.htm

I think the signal may have been focused by this star:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2MASS_19281982-2640123
--and we just happened to be in its focal line.

At any rate the Pentagons ATIP program is still on:
https://www.unexplained-mysteries.c...fice-has-secured-another-full-year-of-funding
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top