Worst Episode of ENT: Season One Part One

[Kalen Archer]

Terra Nova
Rogue Planet
Oasis

 

[Flibble]

Rogue Planet
Oasis
Fallen Hero

 

[The Borgified Corpse]

Dane_Whitman said:

mythme said:
Oasis - I still can't believe Rene didn't read the script and tell the producers "You know, this sounds REALLY familiar. Oh yeah, its an Odo episode called "Shadowplay".

Well, it could be that it's just a job for Rene and he doesn't really care.

You know, it's not that "Oasis" is a particularly bad episode, it's just so derivative of "Shadowplay" it's not even funny anymore. And Auberjonois has a major role in both episodes. Episodes like this show exactly what was wrong with Trek during the first season of Enterprise.

DS9 sometimes has a reputation as the redheaded step-child of Star Trek. Yet usually when Enterprise did a blatant rip-off episode, it would be from a DS9 episode. As a die-hard Niner, I feel oddly vindicated by that.

"Oasis"="Shadowplay"
"Twilight"="The Visitor"
"E^2"="Children of Time"

I might have picked "Oasis" except that I never actually saw it. My picks...

"Terra Nova"
Stupid & doesn't make much sense.

"Dear Doctor"
Makes you really want to hate Dr. Phlox. At least I've heard that John Billingsley agrees with me on this one.

"Fusion"
Just overall kinda sucky.

DISHONORABLE MENTIONS: "Breaking the Ice," "Fortunate Son," "Sleeping Dogs," "Rogue Planet," "Acquisition"

 

[stj]

Very possibly. I can't match titles and episodes for Enterprise very well at all.

 

[JiNX-01]

stj said:
Very possibly. I can't match titles and episodes for Enterprise very well at all.

If you aren't sure, the Enterprise episode guide at the top of the page gives a short summary...

 

[Snapper]

Terra Nova - I kept wishing they'd go and shower!
Fortunate Son - did I care about that guy's feelings? erm...no.
Civilisation - started well, then deteriorated when the captain kissed the ABotW

 

[JiNX-01]

Snapper said:
Civilisation - started well, then deteriorated when the captain kissed the ABotW

Aww.... come on! It was the only action the poor guy got until season four!

 

[Reanok]

Terra Nova, Fortunate son, Rogue Planet

 

[Captain X]

JiNX-01 said:

Snapper said:
Civilisation - started well, then deteriorated when the captain kissed the ABotW

Aww.... come on! It was the only action the poor guy got until season four!

Not if you count that crazy chick from 2D2N. Or that shapeshifter chick from Rogue Planet.

 

[kalysto]

Terra Nova
Fallen Hero
Rogue Planet

 

[JiNX-01]

Captain X said:

JiNX-01 said:

Snapper said:
Civilisation - started well, then deteriorated when the captain kissed the ABotW

Aww.... come on! It was the only action the poor guy got until season four!

Not if you count that crazy chick from 2D2N. Or that shapeshifter chick from Rogue Planet.

I don't think

counts!

And he didn't get it on with the Rogue Planet slug, either.

 

[Captain X]

He didn't get past first base with the Civilization chick either.

 

[auntiehill]

Terra Nova--nearly put me off the series. Lord, was it bad!
Rogue Planet--she was a slug?? Really? A slug?
Fortunate Son--only because it was boring, and didn't have enough Trip!

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

Terra Nova
Acquisition
Strange New World

 

[JiNX-01]

Captain X said:
He didn't get past first base with the Civilization chick either.

How do you know?

 

[Captain X]

Because that's all they ever hinted at.

 

[DeafPoet]

Rogue Planet
Fortunate Son
Desert Crossing

I actually like this season a lot more than most Trek first seasons, so this was moderately difficult.

 

[Mallory]

Terra Nova, Rogue Planet and Oasis.

 

[JiNX-01]

Mallory said:
Terra Nova, Rogue Planet and Oasis.

That avatar is awesome!!

 

[Anna Yolei]

Once a worst from each season has been selected, a worst from the entire series will be voted on.

Gee, I wonder which episode will win that honor? :P