Will Star Trek 12 be good or bad?

I say good.

 

Good. Better than "good" actually.

The second movie is always the best. TWOK is the best TOS movie, FC is the best TNG movie. I think the pattern will hold.

 

I really liked the previous movie, have an optimistic nature and tend to be very forgiving as regards movies and TV anyhow - so will say good. Wait and see, to find out just how good.

 

I say yes.

 

I'll almost definitely enjoy it. I loved both Star Trek V and Nemesis.

 

It will be good if it is done well. And I will enjoy it. Err- because it is good.

Damn, am I doing it wrong?

 

Same here!

 

I'm going to go with a third option: cheeseburger

 

I say you did it right on, brotha.

 

It will start off good, then go very good, then go bad, then good again, then go off on a tangent, then lose that plot entirely and finally take away the number you first thought of.

 

I say good, because there'll be plot holes in it that the fanbois will be complaining about for years to come after it.

 

I say that no matter what, haters gonna hate and will pick this movie to death just because they feel it will have no right to excist since it's not Star Trek because.... well because they say so, and that means it's a fact because they are 'true fans' and know best no matter how good the movie really might be.

And yes, that was all sarcastic, just in case anyone didn't get it.


Seriously though, they haven't even begone shooting it yet. My opinion will be given after I've seen, since that's usually the appropriate time to judge a film.

 

Good? Bad? STXII will be the guy with the gun.

 

I want to say good but I don't want to jinx myself and get all excited about it being awesome and getting my hopes dashed a la Spider-man 3.

 

Good. No wait... Bad.

 

It will be beyond awesome.

I'm already preparing 10,000 brief, largely content-free, smug and supercilious messages which I'll post immediately in reply to any comments on TrekBBS during production or first-run release that suggest otherwise or that criticize any of the hundreds of whimsical, peculiar or apparently wrong-headed decisions of the producers and studio. Most of my posts will be unnecessarily personal and/or dismissive.

...Actually, the process is largely automated now.

 

... Kind of like movie-making in general.

 

Will Star Trek 12 be good or bad?

I'm gonna cover my ass and say maybe. But just between you and me, I'm think it's really probably.

 

Plot Hole City: Part 5
Plot Hole City: Part 6
Plot Hole City: Part 7
Plot Hole City: Part 8


I think it will be good so long as they stick to lots of action, some character moments, and a few laughs. Basically as long as they stick to what makes a good action flick and make it easy on the brain cells it will do great.

 

Well, since you asked...I feel compelled to represent for the silent seething, um, "masses". yah.

The spawn of an Abomination can be nothing but ANOTHER ABOMINATION!

There. I said it. I embrace the Hate! I am the Hate! I live through the Hate and still have time for a late night snack!

mwah-haaa-haaa-haaah!
tired now.