• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Why no rock music in Star Trek?

Lynx

Vice Admiral
Admiral
Since a lot of main characters seem to be interested in music and culture from the past, it strikes me that late 20th century rock music seem to be totally abandoned when it comes to what the Star Trek generations people are listening to.

The only reference to late 20th culture and music in TOS are those space hippies who show up in the episode "The way To Eden". Plus the fact that Chekov looked like Davy Jones of The Monkees. But nothing more.

In TNG, Riker enjoys playing trombone in some 20th century jazz club on the holodeck. But it seems to be in an environment from the 1940:s or 1950:s, before rock music started. Otherwise it's classical music for Picard, Data and the others. One exception is Zefram Cocrane in "First Contact" but his appearance wasn't in the 24th century.
And yes, we have that country singer who had been frozen and brought back to life on the Enterprise. But he was from back then, not a 24th century person.

In DS9, the closest we get when it comes to 20th century music is Vic Fontaine. But he's doing Sinatra style music and his holodeck program is a music club in 1962, the year before The Beatles gave rock music a new boost.

In Voyager, we have Harry Kim who plays classical music on his clarinet. We do have Tom paris who claims to be a fan of 20th century North American culture, specifically the latter half of that century's pop culture. But no rock music in any Paris-created holodeck things, not even an Elvis song, despite his interest in old cars from that era.

So why no rock music in Star Trek? Has that music such a bad reputation in the 24th century Federation that it's totally forbidden?

Or are all Star Trek producers boring old woodblocks who don't appreciate rock music in any form?
 
sSd5KcD.gif
 
As a lover of metal and rock music myself, the question why it's not so much representated in Star Trek had come also to my mind some times. I think there's no clear in-universe explanation and I don't think that the federation, which stands also for being tolerant and open-minded, has abandoned it. I guess they didn't really incorporate it in the series because maybe it wouldn't have been so easy to "sell". Also I must admit that classical or jazz music, which are presented often especially in TNG, just fit better somehow. I couldn't really think of any main character in any ST series whom I'd consider a rock or even metal enthusiast (apart from Worf maybe :guffaw: but well, he's all into that klingon opera stuff).

But I recently watched the Voyager episode "Virtuoso" where different "old" music styles from the earth are presented to those alien dudes and as far as I remember, rock or rock'n'roll is at least mentioned.
 
I seem to recall a novel (maybe Diane Duane?) in which DEVO showed up in a throwaway list of "classical music."

At any rate, that which we call classical music isn't listened to because it's old; rather, it's the stuff that's still listened to in spite of being old. Remember Sturgeon's Law: 90% of everything is shit.
 
Cochrane listened to Rock'n Roll. Riker and Geordi seemed to enjoy it in the Phoenix. The Vulcans obviously didn't, though, when they were introduced to it.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top