• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Why didn't the Borg ever send an armada to assimilate the Federation?

It's the same script where Troi's job has been changed to communications officer.
In the 24th century "communications officer" isn't an actual job, it's a side gig for whoever has some extra space on their console to install the communications panel. If security chiefs and operations officers can do it why not the ship's counselor? On the D's battle bridge Troi was also the one handling communications.
 
I always aspire to the theory the Borg are constantly in the process of "fattening up" the Federation. As in, what one does to an animal before slaughter. During BOBW and FC, there really isn't anything too unique about the Federation's capabilities vs many other species in the galaxy. But keep sending a cube here and there, throw in some time travel, and maybe, just maybe the Federation will develop new skills and technology worthy of armada-sending assimilation down the road.

This was something of a missed opportunity.
To our knowledge, no other species in the galaxy managed to create a non-monetary alliance that spans over 8000 ly's and is comprised of over 150 different species.
In effect, the UFP SHOULD have been FAR more technologically advanced compared to what was shown just from that alone.

This would have been reason enough to show the uniqueness of the Federation and why they were saught out by the Collective.
But then Trek writers just decided to scale it down just to Humanity and Earth.
Why?
Trek shows the Federation where humans are part of a bigger interstellar alliance... so its not just humanity that should be of interest to them. The power of free exchange of ideas, resources, technology and bringing in automation into the mix without the interference of money (and focus on exponetnial developments and returns) could have presented a contrast to the Borg collective that do something similar, but in a violent capacity... and in turn, it could have demonstrated that the Federation is capable of advancing extremely fast even if they don't have 10 000 species in the Federation... but say 66.6 times less.

But, that would have also changed the dynamic of the show and how the writers go about Trek in the first place... it would be enlarged the scope of the universe and story-telling too.... something I don't think Trek writers at the time had the mentality for... so they keep it low key and fairly small scale resulting in a bit of an inadequacy when it comes to Borg reasoning.

I also thought that the Borg were basically 'farming the Federation' and because of their priorities being in the DQ, an interstellar alliance tens of thousands of LY's away was not an immediate priority.
Plus, the Borg don't just assimilate all the time... there are long waiting periods to allow for species to develop some unique defenses or technology.
In effect, the Borg should really just go into hybernation or stop asssimilation for 100 years or so... to allow the galaxy to recover and advance - otherwise, if they so wished, they probably could have assimilated majority of the galaxy by now - there's just no advantage to this as they would lose their source of new technologies, etc. (since we were told they are unable to innovate on its own - which isn't exactly correct because if they are able to assimilate technology from multiple alien species and integrate it into their own and adapt to it, that implies they CAN innovate to a degree).
 
That's the problem with the Borg. They created an enemy that's too powerful and too beyond the scope of both the Federation and Star Trek if they were allowed to use their full force.
So they always had to hand the characters some loop hole on how to quickly defeat them, or include the Borg without including the Borg (Hugh and Lor's splinter group)
And then they de-clawed them completely in Voyager

With enemies like the Borg you either have to eventually go for a climactic Galaxy-spanning battle (which is not what I come to Star Trek for. Plus the later seasons of GoT showed the difficulties of having such an invasion/battle on a TV budget/schedule) or you have to find excuses.
Plus you also don't want to end a popular villain in an open-ended franchise, it's the same with the Daleks in Doctor Who and the Joker in Batman.
 
I thought the Destiny novel trilogy handled it as well as could be done. They pulled a random super powerful species out of their butt and used them to exterminate the Borg once and for alll. The Borg needed to be gone. They were great for a few appearances, but as everyone made clear above, they overstayed their welcome and were becoming increasingly preposterous.
 
they overstayed their welcome
Have they though? While a vocal element of Trek fandom has expressed their fatigue regarding the Borg, the fact remains the Borg remain popular with the general fandom. Many of TNG's and Voyager's most popular and rewatched episodes are Borg episodes, and likewise the one TNG movie that has maintained any kind of following is First Contact, the one with the Borg in it. Also, one of the more popular non-TNG characters from the 90s Trek is Seven of Nine, a Borg character. With that in mind, it makes it pretty obvious why the franchise is always revisiting the Borg, and why they will never truly go away.
 
Have they though? While a vocal element of Trek fandom has expressed their fatigue regarding the Borg, the fact remains the Borg remain popular with the general fandom. Many of TNG's and Voyager's most popular and rewatched episodes are Borg episodes, and likewise the one TNG movie that has maintained any kind of following is First Contact, the one with the Borg in it. Also, one of the more popular non-TNG characters from the 90s Trek is Seven of Nine, a Borg character. With that in mind, it makes it pretty obvious why the franchise is always revisiting the Borg, and why they will never truly go away.

Yeah. I think we all need to let go of the idea that the Borg are ever gonna be "scary again." The Borg were scarier in their earliest appearances because they were so alien and so unknown. But that level of alienation made it virtually impossible to sustain dramatic storytelling around them, and the spookiness that comes from mystery always ceases as you learn more about a threat.

Simple fact is that in order to make the Borg a sustainable source of drama, they had to be re-conceptualized and personalized. That means the Queen, and that means embracing the idea that the Borg actually do have cultural idiosyncrises and aren't always perfectly rational instead of being perfectly logical machines that only consume. And when accept that, the later Borg stories become more acceptable and gain more dramatic power.
 
They just did on Thursday- but they unexpectedly used the Federation’s OWN armada…
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top