*Sees thread title*
SHE'S COMING BACK!!??
NERD RAGE!!
*reads thread*
oh.
SHE'S COMING BACK!!??
NERD RAGE!!
*reads thread*
oh.
Why Bring Back Rose Tyler?
- Thread starter TedShatner10
- Start date
Hello, misogyny. How are you today?
I feel the same. Martha never really got out of Rose's shadow. Donna was allowed to.
*giggle*
Ahem...anyway. I never got why people hate Rose so much. I always liked her. I hate Martha, though. She was the obnoxious bitch that should have died a gruesome death.
Rose's appearances in Series 4 are cool in my book - she got her Consolation Doctor and everyone was happy. I could have done without that bitch Martha in both Doctor Who and Torchwood. She was useless. The Master should have shut up and shot her already.
Can we possibly act like adults for once and not have to refer to female characters we don't like as obnoxious sluts? I don't care if you don't like Rose...there is no evidence she acted like a slut and no need to use that type of wording. She was not promiscuous just because she was in love with the Doctor. I can't stand using derogatory language to describe characters we don't like. End of rant.
Anyways yes season four was about closure for Rose. I suppose it is one of the reasons why the finale was called "Journey's End" it brought to a conclusion the Doctor and Rose's story. As for the original posters stance that season four is one of the weakest? Huh? Since when have people taken this stance? I remember most of us raving about it in our weekly episode thread discussions and how good Catherine Tate was. I think it's probably the strongest outside of series five.
Anyways yes season four was about closure for Rose. I suppose it is one of the reasons why the finale was called "Journey's End" it brought to a conclusion the Doctor and Rose's story. As for the original posters stance that season four is one of the weakest? Huh? Since when have people taken this stance? I remember most of us raving about it in our weekly episode thread discussions and how good Catherine Tate was. I think it's probably the strongest outside of series five.
Exactly. Calling a woman (or female character) a slut just because you dislike her is misogyny, pure and simple.
I came to say this, but I see that you got here before me.
I'm glad that Rose came back, myself. I felt she provided a fitting bookend to 10's story. I don't have the loathing for her that others in the thread obviously do.
^ That's something I agree with.
Just because she portrays one on TV doesn't mean it's actually true for the actress in question.
Why not bring back Rose Tyler?
DW with Rose trumps DW without. Check, please.
DW with Rose trumps DW without. Check, please.
Irrelevant to the question. You don't get to call a fictional black character the n-word just because you dislike the character without that behavior being acknowledged by others as racist. The same should apply to slurs against women.
Again. I don't give a damn if Rose Tyler is a fictional character or not. Or if you like her or not. It's not necessary to call her an obnoxious slut and I felt offended by Omaha Star using that term. I guess that's okay language to use though...and no one still has provided any shred of evidence to suggest otherwise to me. "It's a fictional character" just reeks of ignorance...and as for being on a soapbox...I guess you don't have a woman in your life Josan if you think it's okay to use derogatory terms in that manner. If you did then maybe you'd understand why this is offense. It's called having respect.
And I for one have no problem with that (even as I disagree with it), because "obnoxious" is not a slur against women.
Similar threads
