• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Who win Shadows VS Dominion or Borg???

pimp

Commander
Red Shirt
I have always thought about who would win between Dominion or the Borg and there has been some debates about this in the forum but I have been recently watching B5 and thought to my self what if the Shadows stumbled upon The Dominion or even the the Borg who would win????? it would be a beauty if the Borg assembled the shadows you would have one hell of a mind fook, just thought I throw this question in and be interesting to see what wonderful evidence and theories people would bring :)

My money would be on the Shadows simply because they like a few billion years ahead. (I actually don't know how old the Borg are, they an ancient race too????)
 
I'd say Shadows > Borg > Dominion.

Would have been cool to see what would happen if the Borg assimilated a changeling.
 
I'd say Shadows > Borg > Dominion.

Would have been cool to see what would happen if the Borg assimilated a changeling.

Oh here we go again lol can the Borg assimilate the changelings?????

Founders are the only beings in the cosmos that the Borg cannot assimilate, and therefore when the Borg inevitably have you people by the gonads, you will come crawling to the Dominion for help. Therefore: Doms FTW!

There have been nasty rumors floating around the AQ that Founder immunity to assimilation is not a coincidence and the Borg are a Dominion plot. Ignore these rumors. :devil:
 
The Shadows would go through the Dominion like a scythe through wheat. They'd also
go through the Borg, until the Borg get a good look at a scout or a battle-crab..even then they might not be able to do anything with them, since they couldn't to 8472. And the Shadows are far more advanced than either.
 
The Shadows would go through the Dominion like a scythe through wheat. They'd also
go through the Borg, until the Borg get a good look at a scout or a battle-crab..even then they might not be able to do anything with them, since they couldn't to 8472. And the Shadows are far more advanced than either.


Ah the Daleks would take them all out.
 
The Shadows would go through the Dominion like a scythe through wheat. They'd also
go through the Borg, until the Borg get a good look at a scout or a battle-crab..even then they might not be able to do anything with them, since they couldn't to 8472. And the Shadows are far more advanced than either.


Ah the Daleks would take them all out.

lol
 
Even if the Borg couldn't assimilate the Founders, they could certainly assimilate the Jem'Hadar. They're great fighters, sure, but they're mostly brute force whereas the Borg adapt constantly. With their refusal to go down and their ramming attacks, the Jem'Hadar could hold their own for a while but eventually the Borg would wear them down through sheer numbers.

I do imagine, however, that the Dominion would have less of a problem with biological warfare than the Federation - but even with things like Thalaron weapons, the Borg have the advantage because of numbers.

I'd rather see the Dominion, at the height of it's power, take on the Goa'uld when they were on top. It would be interesting - two sets of genetically enhanced super-soldiers serving aliens who masquerade as gods. They'd try to infiltrate each other too - Goa'uld spies in Vorta, Changelings posing as Goa'uld...it'd be awesome!

Another interesting mashup would be the Dominion versus the Scarrans. I'd love to see Jem'Hadar fighting Scarran Soldiers!
 
Would a Jem'Hadar drone still require the white drug thing? Borg v Dominion would have made a great mini series, as the Borg gradually dominated the Jem'Hadar fleets and Armies and turned them against the Founders, driving the changelings back to their homeworld where they could be contained and studied, then they'd come for us.

With the Shadows around, the Borg would have been used to create chaos, conflict and technological progress inline with their philosophy, but they'd never have become a major power.
 
I've never understood why people think the Dominion can even compete with the Borg.

The Borg nearly wipes out the entire Federation with one ship even after the Federation has been planning for a Borg invasion for 16 years (First Contact). The Cube takes hundreds of Starfleet ships to destroy.

The Dominion loses a war with the Federation and their ships are about on par with StarFleet ships.

Okay, so let's say that in the Gamma Quadrant the Dominion has 100 times more ships than they sent to the Alpha Quadrant. So that means 200-300 Borg Cubes should do it.
 
Oh, please. The man dies like every week. That takes off some serious badass points.
 
^Ah, but the answer to the Dominion vs. Scarrans is Crichton. The answer to The Dominion vs. the Goa'uld is Jack O'Neill.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top