• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

When was the last time you saw Star Trek The Motion Picture?

I hosted a live fan commentary for the "Director's Edition" at a convention in Brisbane, Australia, in July 2019.


Ian's TMP fan commentary at ConQuest, Brisbane
by Ian McLean, on Flickr

And then invited 30 friends to a 40th anniversary screening of the theatrical in Sydney in December of that same year.


Ian at the Hayden Orpheum, Sydney
by Ian McLean, on Flickr

I love the away mission outfit! I wasn't a fan of TMP uniforms, but I did appreciate the away outfit (can it be considered a jacket? I doesn't seem to be a jacket, but that sounds more natural). I like the idea of specialized outfits for away missions, even if it is just additions to the regular uniform. Seems wise due to things like climate, the need for storage space, etc.

A few months ago.
I love revisiting TMP!

I do, too. In fact, I try to re-watch the movies every year starting in November/December. The funny thing is I usually whiz through the TOS movies. I really enjoy TMP and TWoK as a follow up can't be beat. It's the TNG movies that bog me down (though TFF slowed me down last year). In fact, despite starting in December with TMP, I just watched Nemesis tonight.
 
I love the away mission outfit! I wasn't a fan of TMP uniforms, but I did appreciate the away outfit (can it be considered a jacket? I doesn't seem to be a jacket, but that sounds more natural).

"Field jacket", yep. And yes, the pockets are useful at a convention.

I like the idea of specialized outfits for away missions...

Based on the field jackets featured in "The Cage".

Why is the control to magically put clothes on the person in the shower not IN the shower but instead on the wall by the door?

The person would normally key in their requirements before entering the shower recess. Similar to entering a holodeck.
 
Last edited:
The person would normally key in their requirements before entering the shower recess. Similar to entering a holodeck.

I guess we could assume there's a similar panel on the inside if one decides to change the parameters. I'm not sure whether the view we have of the shower precludes that?
 
I guess we could assume there's a similar panel on the inside if one decides to change the parameters. I'm not sure whether the view we have of the shower precludes that?

Sure. But I'm not jumping to that conclusion. This is something we would probably have seen in "Phase II".

In the Pocket novel, either "The Prometheus Design" or "Triangle"(?), someone tries to assassinate Spock by altering his sonic shower - and he almost drowns in liquid clothing.
 
It would be kind of silly if the settings couldn't be altered from the inside though. Certainly when I'm in the shower I may want to make it hotter or colder, and while I'm not sure how that applies to a sonic shower, I would imagine the same considerations apply.

I'd be pretty upset if I had to jump out of the shower, or even stick my dripping-wet hand outside the shower, just to nudge the dial a little more in one direction or the other. :)
 
"Field jacket", yep. And yes, the pockets are useful at a convention.

Convention, alien planet, it's all the same!



Based on the field jackets featured in "The Cage".

I don't think I've ever made that connection, but it was there the whole time. The WoK jackets/coats are my all-time favorite. Practical for an away team, but obviously not practical for a TV budget.

Either way, the connection to "The Cage" is another thing that will add to my list of reasons why I love watching TMP.
 
So my 6 yo son has trouble sitting through movies. Always gets fidgety. The first movie he could sit through and track? “Cloud Star Trek” ( it’s the only Star Trek film he requests by name.)

He does this with no other movies.

It’s a transformative bonding film …he asks, “I wonder what Kirk is thinking .

You have a gifted child who understands lofty concepts. My parents hated Star Trek.

I think The Cage had similar field jackets?
 
Huh? They are very similar. On purpose.

Field jackets of "The Cage" and "The Motion Picture" by Ian McLean, on Flickr
The jackets being handed off to a junior officer, intentional or otherwise, was a callback to the pilot, too.
0qhBWhV.gif
 
The jackets being handed off to a junior officer, intentional or otherwise, was a callback to the pilot, too.
0qhBWhV.gif

Yep. And a tiny bit of extra business for Billy Van Zandt's Rhaandarite ensign, after standing around watching filming for three months. (Billy kept saying, "Let me get killed by the Probe.")
 
When I upgraded my TV and got a Bluray player a few years ago. I'd only seen the Director's Edition for years on DVD, and it was a breath of fresh air to have the IMHO superior version back. I just wish they'd kept Spock's line in about everyone making God in their own image, which is the movie's ultimate wham line.
 
At the Fathom Events screening of 2019. Could only make it Sunday due to my job. But it was absolutely f-ing gorgeous. In theater I think only the 2009 movie compared to it in size. (Though it also matched my level of enthusiasm for catching The Undiscovered Country on its way out of theaters in high school, a movie I almost missed entirely because no one else in my family had wanted to see it over holidays.)

I made sure to catch TMP at the one theater in town that devoted a proper 2.35 screen to it, even though it was a bloody renovated luxury theater. I was so overwhelmed by the cinematic experience that I canceled my ticket for the Return of the King special edition at another theater and went right back in for the 7pm showing.

I'd already seen The Wrath of Khan nine times between the 2016 Cinemark Classic Movies release, the 2017 Fathom release and the 2018 Flashback Cinema (same series that ran the 2019 LOTR marathon around the time of TMP) release. And the TWOK experience is far more elusive by comparison, perhaps from seeing it too many times. Six of my nine screenings were letterboxed onto standard 1.85 screens, and four of those theaters booked it on the smallest screen available. Movie looked exceptionally good; I guarantee it was no 1080i cheat like some of Fathom's earlier events -- however only the Kobayashi Maru sequence, plus some of the TMP-recycled shots (however stripped of their original spatial continuity) stand out in my mind as seeming necessarily larger in scope compared to seeing it on a TV.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top