I have to agree that the shuttle movie was a little worn in the end. I have to wonder how many prints they had to work with... it was actually film in a projector, you know (how old school)! Surely they'll use a digital projection system going forward. I also agree that a little physical action on the bridge would enchance things... did you ever notice the way the floor would vibrate aboard Copernicus Station during the Borg adventure when the Borg were cutting away part of the station, looking for us? Something like that, if not Biggshow's aforementioned gimbals beneath the floor, would add a bit of oomph.
That said... the shuttle ride itself and the other special effects were never the most important part of the show for me. It was materializing in the transporter room and encountering Starfleet crew, being rushed onto the bridge, whisked into the turbolift, hustled through the grand corridor and into the shuttle bay... it was the actors and their tireless energy (keep in mind how many times per day/week/month/year those men and women experienced that particular "emergency") that sold it and made it feel so real. Had STTE been a mere tour through realistic sets it would have grown old and tired very quickly... but every time it was visceral... an adventure. .. like living in an episode... even better, like living in a real Star Trek universe.
All the technologies that will be applied to this new incarnation of STTE may make certain parts of it seem more authentic. It may stand up to close eyeball scrutiny better than the original, but if they fail to capture the energy and enthusiasm that was present in the original cast it'll all be for naught. I got the sincere impression that those people loved their jobs as evidenced by the fact that they sold it so damned hard each and every time.
So from this corner I say bring on the new tech, but don't forget that Star Trek has always been about the people and the way they relate to one another... even during quick, passing encounters with a herd of 21st century civilians, that has made Star Trek the amazingly satisfying epic tale it is, and will make the new STTE worthwhile and worth shelling out hard-earned dollars for repeat visits. It's about the actors - both those inside the attractions and those we encounter on the promenade (or whatever environment replaces it) and inside Quark's... and it's them that made me love the place.
Well, that and the drinks!
You listening, STTE developers? Build well, but
cast better!