• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What is this Star Trek Beyond publication?

Enterprise1701

Commodore
Commodore
https://www.amazon.com/Star-Trek-Beyond-Kristin-Miller/dp/B08CWB7N4W

I stumbled across this Amazon USA webpage for a "Star Trek Beyond" paperback. Release date Tuesday 14 July 2020, the ISBN is 9798665987545, and the listed author is someone named "Kristin Miller". However, I cannot find any mention of this apparent...novelization?...on Memory Alpha or any startrek.com article. What gives?

Images for reference:

Ylz85fG.jpg


oe6Jvl1.jpg
 
From the reviews on that Amazon page:

I’m not even sure what this is. I can tell you what it isn’t. It is NOT a novelization of the movie which is what I was looking for. This has no explanation, it’s sort of lines from the movie but without speaking reference so unless you’ve got the movie memorized it will make no sense. It’s full of dictionary links like maybe it’s a kids book but again, no preface or explanation of any kind. Seriously, a waste of money.

It looks like someone copy-and-pasted a closed-caption transcript and published it as a book, some kind of cheap scam. It should be reported.
 
A big clue when it comes to anything that looks like a novel/etc. based on a TV or film property listed on Amazon or similar sites:

If the publisher is listed as “Independently published,” you know you’re dealing with a scammer or - at best - fan fiction the author has posted for sale.

Amazon really sucks at policing this sort of thing.
 
looks like someone taking advantage of there having been no Beyond novel to make a fast buck! (could've at least attempted to write it tho)
 
I've tried to report things like this to S&S in the past out of courtesy to them. I stopped because they kept asking exactly what novel was being infringed on. Having not read every book, I can't tell them that. I figured with something like Star Trek in the title it should be obvious. I wish it wasn't so difficult, I was just trying to be helpful in case someone else missed it.
 
It looks like someone copy-and-pasted a closed-caption transcript and published it as a book, some kind of cheap scam.

It's got "Look Inside" enabled, and yes, this is exactly what it appears to be. (And it's not even a *good* transcript!)

st-beyond-scam-book-excerpt.jpg


Too bad, too, because I actually really liked the cover! :( (Although I guess the fact that the "author"'s name doesn't appear on it anywhere should also be a tell.)
 
It never got a novel. Probably due to the previous movie novelisation not selling well. I mean they were just giving those away at a convention a few years ago. I think I was given 4 copies of that book
 
Against all odds, IDW released a comics adaptation of Wrath of Khan 27 years late, so I am holding out hope that in 2045 we'll get the Beyond novelization. And, I guess, the comic. We just need to hit the point where the staff of S&S Penguin Random HarperCollins Macmillan are people nostalgic for JJTrek.

(If they wanted to chuck in comics of Insurrection and Nemesis, too, I wouldn't object.)
 
Against all odds, IDW released a comics adaptation of Wrath of Khan 27 years late...

I used to write to DC Comics' lettercol every few months after their ST III adaptation came out suggesting angles for how a ST II adaptation could be incorporated, as a flashback, into the ongoing storyline. For example, Saavik could have been telling the story of her involvement to Bearclaw, Konom, Bryce and Sherwood.

I was thrilled when IDW finally did do an adaptation. It wasn't quite what I had hoped it would be, but yeah! I was fulfilled.

I do really want an actual novelization of "Star Trek Beyond".
 
It never got a novel. Probably due to the previous movie novelisation not selling well. I mean they were just giving those away at a convention a few years ago. I think I was given 4 copies of that book
I recall someone saying it was because of Beyond's rushed production following the cancellation of Orci's Into Oblivion (or whatever it was meant to be called)
 
I recall someone saying it was because of Beyond's rushed production following the cancellation of Orci's Into Oblivion (or whatever it was meant to be called)

I'm not sure being rushed would account for it. As I recall, Pocket got the go-ahead to novelize the '09 movie quite late in the game, so Alan Dean Foster had to write it really quickly, which he was able to do because he's the king of novelizations. And the whole publication process was similarly accelerated to get the book out in time for the film's release. Even a rushed movie production would take considerably more time than they had for that novelization.
 
I'm not sure being rushed would account for it. As I recall, Pocket got the go-ahead to novelize the '09 movie quite late in the game, so Alan Dean Foster had to write it really quickly, which he was able to do because he's the king of novelizations. And the whole publication process was similarly accelerated to get the book out in time for the film's release. Even a rushed movie production would take considerably more time than they had for that novelization.
sounds like they just didnt care to do a novel figuring it wouldnt sell these days. (despite annoying trekkies with that Beyond shaped gap in their Trek movie novels shelf). but had they released a novel of Orcis Into Oblivion now maybe that wouldve sold well!
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top