• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What happened to the Kataanians?

Had the brilliant scientists of Kataan focused less on mind-zapping technologies and more on space-faring ones, they would've been able to $ave their planet ... and Picard some grieving as well. I've always found "Inner Light" to be particularly overrated. I don't know how this whole idea got started with Picard wanting to be a Family Man, all of a sudden. It weakened the character, honestly. Maybe Sir Patrick Stewart requested the change, looking for something meatier to do. But I liked how he was before ... snooty and self-satisfied. He was doing exactly what he wanted with his Life and if he found out he had fathered an unknown kid or two, along the way, well ... he's a Frenchman. It's to be expected.
It's an exquisite episode that deals with some primal truths about living, death, change and loss. And that fulfillment can not only be found in the majesty of the galaxy but also within one's own family. Having rebelled from his own home for a career in the stars, Picard doesn't do anything as hokey as reject being an explorer or an individualist but he learns the value of home life for himself and becomes just a little more seasoned because of it. That kataanian scientists did this, that and the other is a completely trivial point really compared to the great themes that's explored in this episode. All in all, it's a very elegant episode.
 
It's an elegant episode when Jennifer Nash is on, who plays Meribor. She's a Smokin' Hotty and I'm not keen on blondes, generally. But when she's not onscreen, I start to lose interest. Before she was "born," though, there's this scene where Picard asks his imaginary wife Eline if he can build a nursery. And her reaction's always stayed with me. She's got her hands up to her face and she's all like, "omg! omg! omg!" because Picard's giving in to her Biological Clock's ticking, at long last. Picard, Mister "I hate kids" is about to procreate. A moment that was in no way underplayed, to be sure.

Whilst I know the fans love that kinda shite, I don't care for Picard as a Family Man, as I've mentioned, earlier. The show also had this air of self-importance to it, like they "knew" they were making an "important" STAR TREK episode. It never set well with me, at all. You know, had Picard been more like who he was before his robotic heart, I'm sure that he and Riker would've been more like brothers, in the end, than like the sort of Father & Son thing they settled into.

Oh, well ... even a bad TNG episode is still good STAR TREK and "Inner Light" is no exception. I just don't rank it as my favourite Picard episode. Due to my completest nature when it comes to TNG, I had - OK? - HAD to get The Picard Collection and was I ever disappointed! "Inner Light" was showcased, "Darmok" and "The Big Goodbye," alright? Let ME pick the Picard episodes, next time ... I know the good ones, trust me on that. But "Sarek" is in the offering, at least. Were he not my most favourite Vulcan ever, I might've felt otherwise about its inclusion ...
 
+1.. If you didnt get this from Paradis City.. Than u just didnt get it. Claps Hands*

It's an exquisite episode that deals with some primal truths about living, death, change and loss. And that fulfillment can not only be found in the majesty of the galaxy but also within one's own family. Having rebelled from his own home for a career in the stars, Picard doesn't do anything as hokey as reject being an explorer or an individualist but he learns the value of home life for himself and becomes just a little more seasoned because of it. That kataanian scientists did this, that and the other is a completely trivial point really compared to the great themes that's explored in this episode. All in all, it's a very elegant episode.
 
Data specifically says the star "went nova". It's difficult to tell what Trek era heroes would mean by "nova", though: today, it's reserved more or less exclusively for a specific type of event that is only possible in white dwarves that form close binaries with another star. And we know from Picard's dream that Kataan was not one half of a close binary.
Timo Saloniemi

It's been a while since I watched a space documentary but I thought Nova was what happened to a yellow dwarf (like our sun) at the end of its life. They turn into red giants and then collapse into white dwarfs. Yellow dwarfs have a large habitable zone (areas where liquid water can exist, not so cold that it freezes, not so hot that it boils off) so it's more likely that surface-dwelling intelligent life would evolve on planets circling that kind of star.
 
This happens so often youll know it when you see it buddy (nods)

It's been a while since I watched a space documentary but I thought Nova was what happened to a yellow dwarf (like our sun) at the end of its life. They turn into red giants and then collapse into white dwarfs. Yellow dwarfs have a large habitable zone (areas where liquid water can exist, not so cold that it freezes, not so hot that it boils off) so it's more likely that surface-dwelling intelligent life would evolve on planets circling that kind of star.
 
The classical nova (yes, they even officially call it that nowadays) is exclusively a thing binary stars do, with one or the other burping loudly when matter flows between them.

Since there's nothing "new" about such a nova, the name may be a bit misleading. But of course supernova is worse, as it's as "old" as one gets with stars. And worst of all is the idea that nova and supernova should somehow be aspects of the same thing.

With this much confusion today already, it doesn't sound too bad to assume that people in the Trek future would have found even further ways to abuse the word "nova", including a phenomenon that kills ironweavers on Kataan.

But no, so far "nova" isn't something that happens to "ordinary" yellow dwarves like the Sun. At least not in the classic form.

Timo Saloniemi
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top