• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your opinions regarding Star Trek that are, shall we say, unorthodox?

An opinion:

Eras don’t matter, except as for background. Unless it’s about very specific characters (whose actors are probably no longer available anyway), there’s no story you can tell in the Lost Era that you couldn’t tell in the 25th or 32nd century.
 
If it relies on specific set of circumstances, though (e.g. the Federation's known relationship with a particular power, which is different in different era), I suppose you could just change the species. Having the Federation be a third party observing/mediating between two other parties whose current relationship mirrors the Federation's earlier/later relationship with a fourth party wouldn't be quite the same story, though the Federation parallel could be compared to it.
 
It's both the most un-Treklike soundtrack in the franchise (next to "Faith of the Heart"), but also so recognizably Trek that I love it. Have for almost 40 years.
It's the score that sounds the most like a TOS score. If I had to compare it to a TOS composer it would probably be Duning.

It just doesn't sound anything like Goldsmith or Horner.

The so called "purists" have it backwards. It sounds like old school. It DOESN'T sound like the new kids!

Oh, and the music when the Enterprise leaves spacedock is the single best interpretation of the TOS theme ever.
 
Maybe this is more just headcanon, but...

Every starship bridge viewscreen, from NX-01 to the Enteprise-G, has been a window with holographic displays on it (except MAYBE the Enterprise-E and only then in First Contact, where the bridge seems to have a blank wall up front). At the very least, the "window at the front of the bridge" tradition began with the TOS ship in "The Cage" (you can even see a square light on the front of the bridge dome as the camera zooms in through the ceiling, which I also feel is totally transparent and you can see the stars through from inside) and carries through the movies and into the early 24th century (on the refit Enterprise, I could show you where the bridge window is, as well as two other windows on the bridge dome, port and starboard, which I pretend are unseen offices for the Captain and Exec Officer on either side of the bridge). A case MIGHT be made that the 24th century bridge viewers were just big TV monitors, but that's just so incredibly boring. LOL
 
Unfortunately, the overuse of the "Enterprising Young Men" theme throughout the first two movies really wears out that particular tune. Beyond did a better job having some musical variety in it.
I was REALLY hoping they'd have a dark version of the theme in Into Darkness, especially after the awesome piano theme at the start.
 
images


I would have liked a mishmash of the 3 nacelle / ring design with the forward facing portion of the NX-01 Enterprise we know and love. It would have made sense that early Starfleet would follow Vulcan design inspiration.
 
images


I would have liked a mishmash of the 3 nacelle / ring design with the forward facing portion of the NX-01 Enterprise we know and love. It would have made sense that early Starfleet would follow Vulcan design inspiration.
Or quite the opposite depending on how prevalent the Vulcans-have-held-us-back philosophy was among the designers.
 
images


I would have liked a mishmash of the 3 nacelle / ring design with the forward facing portion of the NX-01 Enterprise we know and love. It would have made sense that early Starfleet would follow Vulcan design inspiration.
from an RPG I used to co-run years ago:

N64YZ6z.png


set in 2081
 
having nacelles attached to the ring would seem to defeat the purpose of the ring, plus that looks very clunky
GjNipde.jpeg

the starship equivalent of the Thunderscreech. But I kind of like the idea of early human startships being kludges where they just hadn't figured out what worked best. The closest we got in ENT were maybe the ECS ships.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top