• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Warp Drive Dangerous?

Well, they call it "warp" drive, because it literally warps (bends/distorts) the very fabric of reality (space-time). How could it NOT be potentially dangerous?
 
They have no idea how to even create a warp bubble and don't really know what they would need to do it and yet they think they have a clue of the temperature in the bubble and think it might create a blackhole? :wtf:

Are these fools for real?
 
^That was my reaction too.

"Well, we don't know how to do it, but when we're finally able to, we're pretty sure it could be horribly dangerous."

Imagine if these guys had speculated on man's discovery of fire. :vulcan:
 
They have no idea how to even create a warp bubble and don't really know what they would need to do it and yet they think they have a clue of the temperature in the bubble and think it might create a blackhole? :wtf:

Are these fools for real?
Those "fools" are probably right. Judging from your recent threads on pseudo-scientific matters, your grasp on hard science, action and reaction, and thermodynamics is tenuous at best.

Warping the fabric of space-time would be and incredibly dangerous venture in the real world, with potentially solar-system-swallowing repercussions.
 
I cannot see the link. Obviously chnaging the nature of space-time(in a warp drive) too close to a large body could have unwanted effects on both objects.
 
Those "fools" are probably right. Judging from your recent threads on pseudo-scientific matters, your grasp on hard science, action and reaction, and thermodynamics is tenuous at best.

Anything you say. Not sure what this has to do with anything. I haven't theorised what warp drive would cause or what the potential danger would be. :wtf: So saying this makes no sense. I don't have to know anything about warp drive to know these scientists are talking bull.

Warping the fabric of space-time would be and incredibly dangerous venture in the real world, with potentially solar-system-swallowing repercussions.

Yeh we can all guess (and probably be right) that warp would be dangerous but what I don't accept is that these scientists have any real clue as to what any temperature would be inside a warp bubble and what the possible effects of warp would be. Truth is, they have absolutely no idea and my theory on warp and what might happen (if I had one) would have just as much credence as theirs.

Do you truly believe these scientists really have any idea what they're talking about? if they knew what they were talking about they'd have invented warp drive by now.

Good grief!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
They don't even know what they are talking about. Going to warp doesn't create a black hole. Warp speed warp space only.
 
But that thinking is based on the concept of Alcubierre warp drive. I'd like to suggest another means of exceeding lightspeed. We know that the speed of light varies depending upon the medium through which it travels (higher speed through air than water, higher through open space than air, etc.) But space isn't exactly emply. The Casimir effect demonstrates that there is something there: virtual particles, zero-point energy, whatever you wish to call it, which slows things down less than air or water, but does have some effect. And saying that time itsef slows down as you push the envelope may just be a colorful way of saying that processes are slowed down by resistance from those virtual particles. Learn to disspiate those guys as you go (don't ask me how; I'm not a Starfleet engineer), and you might just be able to get around that speed limit. And that has nothing to do with bending space, exotic matter, or wormholes. But it would also require a new propulsion strategy, also possibly based on dealing with virtual particles.

That may seem too far out there, but recently researchers at Harvard University have done some strange things in this area, since research into anything to do with manipulating the Casimir effect has become important to development of nanomachines.
 
Last edited:
Do you truly believe these scientists really have any idea what they're talking about? if they knew what they were talking about they'd have invented warp drive by now.

Good grief!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You don't have to be able to invent warp drive to know what level of energy would be needed to warp space-time to the point of being able to propel a starship faster than light, nor what kind of side effects that might have on matter in the surrounding area. You'd be dealing with levels of spatial disruption approaching or exceeding that of a black hole, or at the very least a neutron star. I'd call that potentially dangerous.
 
Potentially dangerous yes ... however, we also have to keep in mind that they are theorizing on what might happen and have not produced a practical model to actually know what will happen.
The causes they listed are likely possible to happen ... but at this stage of our technological development of course that they will be stating the energy requirements and potential problems.

Not every solution comes problem-free.
This is just yet another obstacle for them to overcome until they solidify the theory enough and we further advance our tech so we can create a practical model.

The issue with making a practical model is money though.
If people in power retain present mindset and corporations have their way, moving to new technologies and energy sources will be a slow and painful process which in effect won't be fast enough to materialize the theory into practice soon enough ... that's the real issue on why 'Warp drive' or FTL propulsion may not be invented in our lifetimes.

But it's an interesting paper nevertheless.
:-)
 
How exactly did that warp-drive idea that Gerald Cleaver and Richard Obousy work -- the one that expanded one of the tiny rolled up dimensions?
 
How exactly did that warp-drive idea that Gerald Cleaver and Richard Obousy work -- the one that expanded one of the tiny rolled up dimensions?

I thought these tiny rolled up dimensions were to do with string theory and string theory was still just a theory and not yet proved?
Sounds like science fiction to me rather than science.
 
They have no idea how to even create a warp bubble and don't really know what they would need to do it and yet they think they have a clue of the temperature in the bubble and think it might create a blackhole? :wtf:

Are these fools for real?
What you call "fools", others call "theoretical physicists".
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top