• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

USS Discovery in TOS?

It's up to the viewers! After all that's who they are supposed to be making the show for isn't it? No viewers, no show!
JB

Exactly, JB. It's like the DISC team feels they can just spew out anything with impunity, take a whiz on TOS, and the viewers will just lap it up. And because no one has yet devised or had the will or power to implement a Nielsen-like system to measure viewership on streaming services, we don't know if they're right or not. I have always believed that this is why DISC was smuggled on to CBS All-Access (an ironic name) - TPTB wanted a layer of insulation from the fan base.

I don't really care if any of the Trek spinoffs are supposed to be in continuity with TOS or not.

I may enjoy them to varying degrees (or not), but to me, they are just different "versions" of Star Trek, whereas TOS is its own self-contained, standalone thing as true Star Trek. So none of the spinoffs affect the way I view and understand TOS itself and the events depicted therein.

Kor

Yes, fully agreed. I went into DISC with an open mind, but by about 10 minutes into the premiere (the title of which also indicated immediate issues, incidentally), it was clear that the only way I could enjoy it was to divorce it from any other Star Trek series, including particularly TOS. Standing alone in that way, it was a decent show until about episode 10, maybe 11. Then it just went off the rails completely as any kind of show. Disappointing in the extreme.

In any case, like you, no amount of Abrams movies or blithely unaware "prequels" is going to diminish my enjoyment of Star Trek: The Original Series, which is a timeless masterwork. And hey, maybe someday the folks at CBS will dope out that they could try the crazy, bats***, just UTTERLY BIZARRE idea of - stay with me here - setting a TV series *after* Voyager and Nemesis.
 
Well if they don't watch it, then according to the US ratings system over the years you ain't got a show! TNG, DS9 and VOY were all lucky in as much that they didn't have to go through that while DSC seems to have immunity from all types of ratings! :ouch:
JB
 
Found this on twitter, via reddit. This is going into the good old headcanon.
https://twitter.com/knazzer/status/997238738295099393
YsUobz4.jpg
 
Brilliant! This is very much the Discovery would look like when viewed through viewpoint "A" as opposed to the viewpoint "B" that we see on the new series.
Do you suppose the saucer still spins?
Maybe Crossfields dont have spinning sections unless they are running Spore Hub Drive
 
Maybe Crossfields dont have spinning sections unless they are running Spore Hub Drive
Assuming that DSC represents a new visual interpretation of Prime narrative, that means that there was a brief flirtation with spore tech in the 2250s.
You are quite correct however in that such a such a tech wouldn't necessarily result in spinning plates in a TOS visualisation
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top