Among other things, Ogawa's kid.Been a while since I read these. What makes Book 3 incompatible?
Specifically, it's a girl in GW3, a boy named Noah in Titan. Also, isn't there disagreement between the two about whether her husband is alive?
Among other things, Ogawa's kid.Been a while since I read these. What makes Book 3 incompatible?
Among other things, Ogawa's kid.Been a while since I read these. What makes Book 3 incompatible?
Specifically, it's a girl in GW3, a boy named Noah in Titan. Also, isn't there disagreement between the two about whether her husband is alive?
I like the idea of amphibians with stubble, but you're right that subsequent references nailed that coffin. I'd forgotten that they showed up in Articles of the Federation later on.So I concluded that they had to be two different species from two separate worlds, with the name similarity just coincidental (but not exact -- Carreons from Carreon vs. Carreon from Carrea). And since I explicitly stated that in Watching the Clock, I guess it's official now.
That's explained as the result of unspecified time tampering in The Needs of the Many. The temporal psychosis-suffering Dulmer "remembers" both versions of Ogawa's child, Janeway's death and the subsequent Borg invasion and even the destruction of Vulcan in 2258. None of which happened in the novel's Star Trek Online(-ish) continuity.Among other things, Ogawa's kid.Been a while since I read these. What makes Book 3 incompatible?
Specifically, it's a girl in GW3, a boy named Noah in Titan. Also, isn't there disagreement between the two about whether her husband is alive?
That Reed is a Creole native of the West Indies, isn't he? Highly unlikely to be related to Malcolm.
^ But since 'Reed' is such a common name, why bother?
I don't think anyone's saying they would bother -- just that the fact that one Reed is Creole and one Reed is a WASP-y Englishman doesn't automatically preclude their being from the same family.
^ But since 'Reed' is such a common name, why bother?
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.