• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Undercover Vote thread

Vote!


  • Total voters
    24
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

captcalhoun

Admiral
Admiral
undercover.jpg


CaptCalhoun

sleeperav2hi9.jpg


Klaus

SFFAv_Undercover.jpg


Skywalker

Dopplegangland.jpg


Rowan Sjet

rivas.jpg


Hermiod

angel2.jpg


Ethros

normal_THE_WIZARD_OF_OZ-507.jpg


Auntiehill



John Clark

cameronpolice.jpg


NX1701G

vlcsnap-185840.png


Tuln

mirroru.jpg


Temis the Vorta

newET.jpg


JiNX-01

pieceoftheaction.jpg


Chris3123

hill07.png


PointyHaired Jedi

farscape_scratchnsniff_dandydargo_av.jpg


Starscape

At the risk of the Wrath of Spiff, VOTE FOR THREE!!!! Votes close Sunday.
 
^I, on the other hand, had to narrow down from 6 to 3. And at the additional risk of the Wrath of Spiff, I do not understand how voting for 1 instead of 3 would reduce the number of ties. :confused:

VampWillow - Rowan
AngelHat - Ethros
DandyD'Argo - Starscape

By the way, no offence to cc, but I nearly voted for the wrong people because of the names being under the entries instead of on top and evenly spaced between them. It just wasn't very clear in my mind which avatar belonged to which person. Granted, I'm often easily confused, but was I the only one? :)
 
Nice job, people!
:techman:

auntiehill
John Clark (Casey’s most recent disguise, as the shaggy waiter guy, was the best yet! :rommie:)
Chris3123

Uncover the Big List of Past Contests!

I do not understand how voting for 1 instead of 3 would reduce the number of ties. :confused:
It wouldn't, it would increase the odds of a tie. Let's say you have two votes to distribute between two options. You could vote 1 and 1 or 2 and 0. 50/50 chance of a tie.

Let's say you have 120 million votes for those two options. That's a Presidential election. I dunno what the odds are of them getting exactly 60 million votes apiece, but it's a lot smaller than 50/50. If McCain and Obama had tied the popular vote, I think everyone would have fallen over dead. :rommie:

However, the odds of an Electoral College tie, with only 538 votes to distribute, are considerably higher than the odds for a popular vote. Certainly within the realm of possibility.

Thus proving that the more votes you have to distribute between whatever number of options you have, the lower the odds of a tie.

To lessen the chance of ties in the contest, we need to increase options:

-number of votes each person is given
-number of entries per contest
-number of people who vote

Those second two are outside the control of the contest rules so the first one is what we should focus on. Give everyone five votes, for instance, and we'd have fewer ties. Or ten. The limiting factor there is simply that gets silly to let people vote for ten options out of 15 or so.

That is, if ties bother people. Don't bother me. When there's a tie, let the person who won most recently off the hook and have the other guy set up the next contest. That distributes the workload around.
 
AngelHat - Ethros
DandyD'Argo - Starscape
VampWillow - Rowan
I have the very same favourites!
But I got it wrong and voted for only one.


The original thread is closed, so I'm replying to Rowan Sjet here.
I know the 140x140 avatar size is a general rule, but it isn't folled by the pixel: many people have slightly bigger avatars. I submitted a picture that was 144x180, unable to crop the sides.
So I get disqualified for a measly 4 pixels?
140x105 would have worked, but you don't think I would have done it if I'd known? Even if it's a general board rule, it might have been a good idea to remind it in the thread, if it was so strict. I would have expected in the least a friendly notification and I would've changed it, but I guess there was no time before closure. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt on that one.
This contest doesn't matter but I was vexed, captcalhoun.
CatStickingTongueSmiley.gif
 
Last edited:
sorry, Ria, but i thought everyone knew the avatar size rules.

sakrysta, i ge tthat every time i've done an av vote thread, so it's not just you.

i went with Rowan, NX and Tuln
 
Thanks for the votes, peeps!

Ideas for the next contest...I'm tempted to say Star Trek XI, either what you can glean online or just your own ideas. (So, what sort of bra should Uhura be wearing?)

Or:

Shoes
Short People
Vehicles
Premiere Episodes
Finale Episodes
Canon Violations
or just Mistakes in general
 
Ideas for the next contest...I'm tempted to say Star Trek XI, either what you can glean online or just your own ideas. (So, what sort of bra should Uhura be wearing?)
Uhhh.... on the chance that you might be serious ... no. ;)

After the last few days where any and all links to the trailer and images from the film have been removed, this is not the best idea for a contest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top